Monday, March 5 2018 18:39
Naira Badalian

Artak Manukyan: absurd theater in Armenian or Armenian procurement reforms

Artak Manukyan: absurd theater in Armenian or Armenian procurement reforms

ArmInfo. The problems in Armenia's procurement sphere have never been conditioned by the existence of gaps in the legislation. The roots of problems lie in law enforcement practice. The economist, chairman of the NGO "National Research Center of Public Policy" Artak Manukyan stated in an interview with ArmInfo correspondent, commenting on the cardinal changes in the sphere of legislative regulation of the procurement system that started in April 2017.

According to the expert, Armenia had the best legislation in the field of procurement until April 2017. In 2011 it was brought into line with the best procurement standards of the World Trade Organization. In addition, according to the expert, speaking of his reformist intentions in the field of procurement, the government behaved not completely to the end. "The adoption of the new law was also conditioned by membership in the EAEU, so the authorities tried to ensure the harmonization of the national legislation, both with the WTO norms and the EAEU," he said.

Nevertheless, the expert is sure that the task to this day is impunity and the authorities have no will to destroy quasi-monopolies. The head of the NGO is sure that from April 25 until today no company, due to concealment of the fact of affiliation with the state official, or information about the real owner of the company, fell into the so-called "black list". "You can talk incessantly about the desire to identify the affiliation of the company participating in the tender with officials and the purposes to disclose the real owners. But if you continue to look through your fingers to see how the owner further artificially splits one company into many dwarfs, will not move from the dead center," he said.  As Artak Manukyan assures, for today purchases from one person continue to remain the Achilles' heel of the whole sphere. The expert does not believe in official statistics, which says a multiple reduction in the number of purchases under this procedure. "The procurement of the three main state structures that carry out protocol purchases from one person - the presidential apparatus, the National Assembly and the government, was called secret information by virtue of the law." Thus, the authorities improved statistics by one movement of the pen," Manukyan explained, urging not to forget that formally sugar imports to Armenia 39 business entities, again formally providing a competitive environment. With more detailed study, the expert noted, it becomes obvious that all 39 are the property of one person.

In general, according to the expert, if the government had the purpose to really reform the sphere, first of all, it would provide a free system of appealing the decisions of the tender commission. For today, consideration of disputes over the results of the contest, the appellant will cost 30 thousand drams (whether it's a contestant, a representative of the public organization, or an investigative journalist who at some stage sees violations and signals a problem). When making a positive decision on it - the amount is returned. While the services of the hotline in Armenia, which also provide anonymity, are free of charge. Meanwhile, the appellant in the procurement system has no right to anonymity, he reveals himself that in the context of Armenian reality, in the opinion of the economist, means to burn all the bridges behind him. "I will not open America if I say that after that they will become outcasts of the system and after that they will not be able to hope for victory in the contest," he said. In many countries, according to the economist, if the state is really interested in receiving signals from the public about the existing problems, then it, if possible, ensures the free process. "The theater of the absurd is nothing more," Artak Manukyan said.

Within the same feedback, according to the statements of the Ministry of Finance, permanent discussions are being held with the representatives of the PA, expert circles to implement reforms in the procurement sphere. However, according to the expert, the question is with whom and with what purpose this work is conducted - to listen to their opinion or again "clean water PR". In the opposite case, in his opinion, the agency was to invite alternative media to these discussions. Otherwise, according to the economist, "these discussions are worthless." "There are numerous pocket NGOs that are invited to the discussion for the sake of a tick, but it is not a fact that the participants in such discussions are satisfied with the results of the joint work," Artak Manukyan said.

As a result, as the expert assured, everything depends on the following: how much is the result obtained consistent with the stated goal - is there any chance that the bio-toilet purchased for a rather cheap price will be placed on the street, or how morally it is to talk about the 30% poverty level, continuing the former luxuries of the state apparatus.

In one, he is sure that in no problem-sphere in Armenia is legislation at the center, because Armenia already has legislation, perhaps the most liberal one, and that is in line with European standards, and it's about ensuring law enforcement practice. "No matter how much we talk about improving the legislation, if the country has a centralized economy, the result will be the same - just permanent players will already win by the law." How many we would not open the field if from year to year the tenders were won by the same persons it is meaningless to expect the participation of new players. The Armenian market is small and does not have the attractiveness that players from outside express a desire to participate in the process - as a result, again, the tender will win "Flash", concluded the head of the NGO.


News
 About $ 60 million will be invested in a new ski resort in the  Aragatsotn region of Armenia. About $ 60 million will be invested in a new ski resort in the  Aragatsotn region of Armenia.
Converse Bank has completed the placement of corporate bondsConverse Bank has completed the placement of corporate bonds
Armenian government to identify obstacles to launching Armoil  petrochemical plant in Kotayk regionArmenian government to identify obstacles to launching Armoil  petrochemical plant in Kotayk region
Fundraising for the start of construction of the airport UAV named  after Karen Vardanyan has been completedFundraising for the start of construction of the airport UAV named  after Karen Vardanyan has been completed
TOP-5 large taxpayers of Armenia reduced tax payments in the first  half of the yearTOP-5 large taxpayers of Armenia reduced tax payments in the first  half of the year
Managing Director of Japan Bank for International Cooperation is  ready to visit Armenia to get acquainted with cooperation  opportunitiesManaging Director of Japan Bank for International Cooperation is  ready to visit Armenia to get acquainted with cooperation  opportunities
In H1, 2021 Armenian banks transferred to the state treasury USD 60.6  million taxes with a 19.4% y-o-y growth In H1, 2021 Armenian banks transferred to the state treasury USD 60.6  million taxes with a 19.4% y-o-y growth 
Telecommunications operators of Armenia reduced tax payments to the  state budget by 12.8% in H1, 2021Telecommunications operators of Armenia reduced tax payments to the  state budget by 12.8% in H1, 2021
Delegation of Armenian Economy Ministry is in Georgia to discuss the  possibilities of expanding cooperation in the trade and economic  fieldsDelegation of Armenian Economy Ministry is in Georgia to discuss the  possibilities of expanding cooperation in the trade and economic  fields
ANIF Head: New Law on Public-Private Partnership has become an  important step towards stimulating investment in ArmeniaANIF Head: New Law on Public-Private Partnership has become an  important step towards stimulating investment in Armenia
French experts proposed mechanisms for identifying and analyzing  risks to improve the process of tax audits in ArmeniaFrench experts proposed mechanisms for identifying and analyzing  risks to improve the process of tax audits in Armenia
In H1 2021, ARMENAL plant produced 16.9 thousand tons of productsIn H1 2021, ARMENAL plant produced 16.9 thousand tons of products
 ACBA Bank: USD 5 million will be allocated to development of Green  Economy in Armenia ACBA Bank: USD 5 million will be allocated to development of Green  Economy in Armenia
Ameriabank is the leading taxpayer among Armenian banks in the first  half of 2021Ameriabank is the leading taxpayer among Armenian banks in the first  half of 2021
Armenia`s foreign trade deficit reduced in June 2021 by 20.2% per  annumArmenia`s foreign trade deficit reduced in June 2021 by 20.2% per  annum
Growth of economic activity accelerates in ArmeniaGrowth of economic activity accelerates in Armenia
Armenia intends to expand cooperation with leadership of Iran`s  Social Security Investment CompanyArmenia intends to expand cooperation with leadership of Iran`s  Social Security Investment Company
Clarification of State Revenue Committee about new advantages of  obtaining  certificate of  law-abiding taxpayerClarification of State Revenue Committee about new advantages of  obtaining  certificate of  law-abiding taxpayer
1000 large taxpayers of Armenia paid about $ 1.2 billion to the state  budget in H1, 2021: Defense Ministry apparatus is the third on the  list 1000 large taxpayers of Armenia paid about $ 1.2 billion to the state  budget in H1, 2021: Defense Ministry apparatus is the third on the  list 
US State Department Investment Review: The financial sector in  Armenia is not highly developedUS State Department Investment Review: The financial sector in  Armenia is not highly developed
Government of Armenia discussed agricultural programs implemented  with support of stateGovernment of Armenia discussed agricultural programs implemented  with support of state
Updated RA Law Updated RA Law "On Combating Money Laundering and Financing of  Terrorism" will enter into force on July 26
Armenian Regulator excludes cartel agreement in liquefied gas marketArmenian Regulator excludes cartel agreement in liquefied gas market
Tax revenues of the Armenian state treasury as of July 20 amounted to  865.2 billion AMD with an annual indicator of 1 trillion 510 billion  AMDTax revenues of the Armenian state treasury as of July 20 amounted to  865.2 billion AMD with an annual indicator of 1 trillion 510 billion  AMD
Armenian Ambassador to the Czech Republic held talks with the  leadership of Armenian Ambassador to the Czech Republic held talks with the  leadership of "CzechInvest"
Agricultural land sales remain high in the regions of ArmeniaAgricultural land sales remain high in the regions of Armenia
Deputy Minister of Economy and Russia`s Ambassador discussed  development of the Armenian-Russian strategic, trade and investment  cooperation Deputy Minister of Economy and Russia`s Ambassador discussed  development of the Armenian-Russian strategic, trade and investment  cooperation 
Resident of FEZ Resident of FEZ "Alliance" LLC "Arides" intends to expand activities  in the field of electronics and precision engineering
The trend of monthly growth in apartment prices in Yerevan continuesThe trend of monthly growth in apartment prices in Yerevan continues
It was a joke: Armenian Minister of Economy on his call to It was a joke: Armenian Minister of Economy on his call to "detain"  labor migrants
Armenian government allocated about $ 17.8 million for overhaul of  roads with length of 50.7 kmArmenian government allocated about $ 17.8 million for overhaul of  roads with length of 50.7 km
Armenian authorities will fight against tax Armenian authorities will fight against tax "parasites"
Issues of implementation of a number of investment programs discussed  in the Armenian governmentIssues of implementation of a number of investment programs discussed  in the Armenian government
Best specialists of nuclear industry started annealing reactor vessel  metal of Armenian NPPBest specialists of nuclear industry started annealing reactor vessel  metal of Armenian NPP
Armenia will explore space with Russian partnersArmenia will explore space with Russian partners
Vahan Kerobyan: Armenia`s labor market has set a new recordVahan Kerobyan: Armenia`s labor market has set a new record
Papikyan announces investments in Gyumri in amount of about $ 8.5  millionPapikyan announces investments in Gyumri in amount of about $ 8.5  million
As part of 2025 strategy, EAEU will develop a concept for  implementation of principles of green economyAs part of 2025 strategy, EAEU will develop a concept for  implementation of principles of green economy
EEC supported  draft roadmap for formation of common market for  organic agricultural productsEEC supported  draft roadmap for formation of common market for  organic agricultural products
For 5 months of 2021, the mutual trade of the EAEU member states  increased by 33%For 5 months of 2021, the mutual trade of the EAEU member states  increased by 33%
SRC of Armenia reports on the next record in the number of jobsSRC of Armenia reports on the next record in the number of jobs
Electronic system of Electronic system of "single window" in the field of foreign trade  will be launched by the end of 2021
Deputy Minister of Economy of Armenia sent on an official trip to  Russia to discuss issues of bilateral trade and economic cooperationDeputy Minister of Economy of Armenia sent on an official trip to  Russia to discuss issues of bilateral trade and economic cooperation
Revazyan: After the formation of a national air carrier, Armenia will  appeal to Europe with a request, as an exception, to allow access to  the Revazyan: After the formation of a national air carrier, Armenia will  appeal to Europe with a request, as an exception, to allow access to  the "European sky"
Life on loan: In six months, Armenia`s public debt grew by $ 901  million - up to $ 8 billion 869 millionLife on loan: In six months, Armenia`s public debt grew by $ 901  million - up to $ 8 billion 869 million
Armenia considers possibility of canceling excise tax for winemakersArmenia considers possibility of canceling excise tax for winemakers
Armenian customs officers with Iranian colleagues discussed  modernization of Meghri checkpointArmenian customs officers with Iranian colleagues discussed  modernization of Meghri checkpoint
Government together with KfW, EIB and EU will allocate 81 million  euros to ensure water supply in several regions of ArmeniaGovernment together with KfW, EIB and EU will allocate 81 million  euros to ensure water supply in several regions of Armenia
Nikol Pashinyan visited Nikol Pashinyan visited "Saranist" glass production company and got  acquainted with activities of new brandy factory
The next vector of ANIF activities is to provide support to water and  waste management systemsThe next vector of ANIF activities is to provide support to water and  waste management systems
With formation of national air carrier and increase in passenger  traffic, issue of expanding Zvartnots airport may ariseWith formation of national air carrier and increase in passenger  traffic, issue of expanding Zvartnots airport may arise
Ameriabank receives Euromoney Euromoney Award for Excellence 2021 as  the Best Bank in ArmeniaAmeriabank receives Euromoney Euromoney Award for Excellence 2021 as  the Best Bank in Armenia
The largest aviation concern in Europe - Lufthansa enters the  Armenian marketThe largest aviation concern in Europe - Lufthansa enters the  Armenian market
National air carrier to be established in Armenia within the  framework of the agreement with Air ArabiaNational air carrier to be established in Armenia within the  framework of the agreement with Air Arabia
Vahan Kerobyan once again found it realistic to end 2021 with  economic growth of 10-11%Vahan Kerobyan once again found it realistic to end 2021 with  economic growth of 10-11%
EU to allocate 600 million euros for the construction of the southern  section of the North-South highwayEU to allocate 600 million euros for the construction of the southern  section of the North-South highway
IDBank`s Visa Digital card: another key to online and contactless paymentsIDBank`s Visa Digital card: another key to online and contactless payments
In H1 2021, Armenia`s international reserves increased by 18.7%  amounting to $ 3.1 billionIn H1 2021, Armenia`s international reserves increased by 18.7%  amounting to $ 3.1 billion
Armenian government convened an extraordinary meeting to discuss a  four-year program to reduce public debtArmenian government convened an extraordinary meeting to discuss a  four-year program to reduce public debt
Export of ferromolybdenum, copper and molybdenum concentrate to third  countries will be subject to a 15% state dutyExport of ferromolybdenum, copper and molybdenum concentrate to third  countries will be subject to a 15% state duty
Read more


Exchange rates
29.07.2021
RUB6.620.06
USD484.362.04
EUR575.085.07
GBP675.636.36
CAD388.544.59
JPY44.090.23
CNY74.580.30
CHF533.085.55