Monday, May 6 2019 10:42
Naira Badalian

Armand Arton: The question whether citizenship should be granted in  return for investments is rather rhetorical

Armand Arton: The question whether citizenship should be granted in  return for investments is rather rhetorical

ArmInfo.Citizenship by Investment (CBI) is a concept widely practiced all over the world. For the first time, representatives of Arton Capital, a company registered in  Canada, specializing in citizenship programs through investments,  spoke about it in Armenia in May 2017 at a meeting with the former  head of the Ministry of Economic Development and Investments.

The company then prepared a report in which, among other issues, noted  that even with a low price of an "investor's visa" of $ 50,000,  within six years Armenia can earn about $ 140 million. Meanwhile, the  question remains open when Armenia can enter the elite club of  countries offering foreigners the opportunity to apply for  citizenship by investment - quickly, profitably and legally. ArmInfo  correspondent appealed to Arton Capital President Armand Arton for  clarification.

Mr. Arton, in 2017, after your meeting with the Minister of Economic  Development and Investments of Armenia, the ministry issued a message  that cooperation with Arton Capital will contribute to attracting  foreign investment. Has any progress been achieved in implementation  of this idea?

The "Arton Capital" company was selected on the basis of a tender  under the "Support to Migration and Border Management" program. In  May 2017, representatives of the company visited Armenia at the  invitation of the International Center for Migration Policy  Development (ICMPD - an international organization headquartered in  Vienna), which, with EU funding, implemented this program in Armenia.

In September of the same year, Arton Capital prepared a report on the  "Granting citizenship in exchange for investments" project for  Armenia. The document presented the key elements of the program, the  strengths and weaknesses of the project, also presented strategies  for mitigating risk factors. We made recommendations in order to  attract foreign direct investment in exchange for obtaining permanent  residence and citizenship. We also proposed the model and the form,  the structure of this possible program.  This was our final task for  this project. By the way, Arton Capital donated the entire fee for  the services to the Red Cross Society of Armenia, due to which two  groups of children from refugee families were sent to summer camps in  Tsakhkadzor.

A generous action, indeed! After your May meeting at the Ministry of  Economic Development and Investments, there was a feeling that the  concept of the "citizenship by investments" program received the  support of the authorities. The ministry called your company an  experienced organization with representative offices in more than 15  cities, saying that you managed to attract more than $ 3 billion of  investments within similar projects. Meanwhile, today it is not known  when it will be implemented and whether it will be implemented at  all?

The incumbent government does not show much interest in it. At the  same time, the company understands that in 2018 a "velvet revolution"  and a peaceful change of government took place in Armenia, and the  new Cabinet would have to decide whether to launch the project or  not. We see that the "Citizenship by Investments" mechanism is not  the main priority of the new authorities. At the same time, we  remember that Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan declared the economic  revolution and the attraction of foreign investors to be the priority  of his new government. And in this light, one should understand that  the program proposed by us is an efficient mechanism for attracting a  new type of investors in Armenia.

Could you explain "citizenship by investment" mechanism? Who is this  type of new investor?

There are wealthy people who buy real estate, yachts, and there are  those who buy citizenship for greater mobility for the purposes of  tourism and business. By launching the program following the example  of many other states, for example, Cyprus, Portugal and Malta,  Armenia will be able to offer attractive immigration opportunities to  foreigners from third countries in exchange for purchasing real  estate and other investment options.

As practice shows, most of all investors come from Asian countries  and 50% of them from China. The second largest market (30%) is the  Middle East: these are investors from a wide geographic range - from  Morocco to India. Consumers of 15-20% of the market of "visa  investors" are representatives of the countries of the former Soviet  Union. Regarding Armenia, we think that wealthy people from the  Middle East are ready to invest in the Armenian economy for the  simple reason that the republic is located not far from the region  where political instability prevails. And, by the way, many of them  are Christians, and will feel safe in Christian Armenia.

Countries offering such programs require that foreigners make  investments of various levels  to obtain citizenship. Despite the  fact that the report itself does not speak about a specifically fixed  price, our company offered a certain tariff range "from" and "to".  That is, when entering the Armenian market it would be reasonable to  focus so far on a small amount of $ 50 thousand as the minimum  investment amount for a foreigner who wants to get a passport of a  citizen of Armenia. According to the report, even with such a low  threshold, the Armenian economy will receive additional income in the  amount of over $ 100 million within 3 years.

For this, experts recommended the Armenian government to offer  potential foreign investors two investment options: a direct  contribution to the state fund of $ 50,000 (non-refundable), or a  contribution of $ 100,000 to government bonds at zero coupon, that  is, at a zero rate. An investment of $ 100,000 in "equity", that is  in the authorized capital of a government-selected asset management  company is also possible, with the possibility of obtaining  investment benefits. In addition, the company offers Armenia to  introduce two types of commission fees. The first is a non-refundable  service charge of up to $ 10 thousand. And the second, without  specifying the amount, must cover the costs of checking the previous  activities of applicants for citizenship and their sources of income.

In order to understand how profitable it is for the state, I would  say that the rate on government loans in foreign markets averages 7%,  and with a zero coupon, the authorities will save on interest.

Currently, Arton Capital is also promoting the Global Citizen Tax  initiative, lobbied in the EU countries, which is aimed at  establishing an additional tax of 5% on investments for "visa  investors", which will be further focused on solving problems with  refugees. Thus, the money of wealthy clients would help less wealthy  ones. In Armenia, this is also a sensitive issue given the  integration of compatriots arriving from troubled Syria.  Can our  government, in your opinion, control this process in view of its lack  of experience and practice?

The Armenian authorities should not have concerns due to the  establishment of a certain tariff corridor in the form of investments  for applicants for an "investor passport", as well as the existence  of strict selection criteria. Of course, it is necessary to take into  account the presence of a number of risks for the investor himself -  closed borders with neighbors - Azerbaijan and Turkey, the conflict  over Nagorno-Karabakh, corruption that has not been eliminated  completely yet.

But there are also positive moments, since on the existing  list of  "good news" - close ties with world economic centers, as well as  geographical and cultural proximity to strategic markets (EAEU, IRI),  such a "brand" as the Armenian "velvet revolution" and a peaceful  change of power in the country can aslso be added.

The democratic processes in Armenia allowed the international  community to take a new, more positive look at the republic. This is  one of the reasons why we decided to hold the Global Citizen Forum in  Armenia this year. And if Armenia also agrees on a visa-free entry  into the Schengen zone, the Armenian passport will drastically  improve its position in the global passport index.

At present, Armenia occupies an average 63 position in the rating of  countries with the most powerful passports compiled by our company,  as citizens of the Republic of Armenia can visit 69 countries without  visas. The neighboring Azerbaijan occupies the 60th line, its  citizens can enter 72 countries without visas, but Georgia is far  ahead of us, having visa-free access to the Schengen countries and  thus occupying the 38th position, as the doors to 116 countries are  opened for the citizens of the country.

In your opinion, which model is more acceptable for Armenia?

The choice of the program implementation model is an exclusive  prerogative of the government of Armenia. For my part, I can assure  you that, whatever you choose, I, as an Armenian, will be proud and  happy with any scenario and role that the Republic of Armenia will  define for Arton Capital. We do not in any way try to emphasize our  role or monopolize the market.

The program can be managed directly by the authorities of the  country, employing a reputable and professional operator with  experience in the field of investment immigration who is able to  ensure its successful and stable operation. In addition, we even  strive for competition, because we believe that this will ensure the  transparency of the whole procedure. In this context, we are  currently working with European lobbyist organizations that promote  the idea against the concentration of services in this area in the  hands of one company. For example, verification of the data of  potential clients, designed to provide the project with maximum  protection against surprises, our company conducts with reputable  American, British and Canadian partners, who check both the investors  themselves and the sources of the origin of the funds.

Mr. Arton, you have mentioned citizens of the Middle East countries  as potential players at the Armenian "blue passport" market? Are  there any grounds for concern in the context of national security?

Any candidate for citizenship under this mechanism undergoes a strict  "filtering", his background is studied from the moment of birth until  the moment of submission of documents. His financial situation is so  thoroughly verified that it is easier for a dubious person to obtain  refugee status in the country than to become a beneficiary of the  program. So, without a shadow of a doubt, I will tell you that there  is no cause for concern.

Besides, when Arton Capital started negotiations with the government  of the Republic of Armenia Moldova didn't even think about launching  such a program. We advised the Government of the Republic of Moldova,  and for several months now the country has launched it. We are also  negotiating with the Government of Georgia about the implementation  of a similar program. Already more than 10 countries, from the  Pacific to the Caribbean, are currently consulting with Arton Capital  on the mechanisms for implementing such programs. Recently, Arton  Capital was one of three companies approved by the government of  Montenegro for the implementation of its citizenship investment  program in exchange for investment and its promotion in the  international market. Indeed, in our rapidly developing world, the  one who responds in time and concentrates resources on key areas  wins. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
Sales of new cars increase by 10% in ArmeniaSales of new cars increase by 10% in Armenia
Ministry of Economy initiated the first workshop on the development  of the securities market in ArmeniaMinistry of Economy initiated the first workshop on the development  of the securities market in Armenia
Molybdenum enrichment plant was launched in Armenia`s Armavir on the  basis of the old glass factoryMolybdenum enrichment plant was launched in Armenia`s Armavir on the  basis of the old glass factory
IMF will continue to support the efforts of the Armenian government  to develop the Armenian economyIMF will continue to support the efforts of the Armenian government  to develop the Armenian economy
The Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Armenia discussed the  concept of universal health insurance proposed by the Ministry of  HealthThe Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Armenia discussed the  concept of universal health insurance proposed by the Ministry of  Health
Non-cash bank card transactions show unprecedented growth for the  second year in a rowNon-cash bank card transactions show unprecedented growth for the  second year in a row
CBA: Armenian card market is gaining momentumCBA: Armenian card market is gaining momentum
The terms of the program to extend the life of Armenian NPP`s second  power unit will be extended until December 31, 2021 The terms of the program to extend the life of Armenian NPP`s second  power unit will be extended until December 31, 2021 
Beeline and the British Council launch a joint program <Coding  Skills: Linking the Present and the Future>Beeline and the British Council launch a joint program
ADB to provide a loan of 36.5 mln euros to Armenia for the second  program of social efficiency and financial marketsADB to provide a loan of 36.5 mln euros to Armenia for the second  program of social efficiency and financial markets
Company owned by daughter of an Armenian oligarch granted another tax  exemption from the government Company owned by daughter of an Armenian oligarch granted another tax  exemption from the government 
German KfW Bank to provide Armenia 40 million euros for actvities in  the field of nature protectionGerman KfW Bank to provide Armenia 40 million euros for actvities in  the field of nature protection
A comprehensive social services center opened in the Shengavit  administrative district of Yerevan with the support of the World BankA comprehensive social services center opened in the Shengavit  administrative district of Yerevan with the support of the World Bank
Minister: There is a positive trend in the country`s water resources  managementMinister: There is a positive trend in the country`s water resources  management
Armenia continues to work on developing a strategy for the SMEs  development Armenia continues to work on developing a strategy for the SMEs  development 
Deputy Minister: 2019 will be the last year of attracting credit  funds for budget assistanceDeputy Minister: 2019 will be the last year of attracting credit  funds for budget assistance
WB to provide Armenia a loan of $ 45.8 million to finance the state  budget deficit in 2019WB to provide Armenia a loan of $ 45.8 million to finance the state  budget deficit in 2019
Deputy Minister of Economy of Armenia participated in the Second  World Eco-Design Conference in Guangzhou, ChinaDeputy Minister of Economy of Armenia participated in the Second  World Eco-Design Conference in Guangzhou, China
Deputy Minister: As of October 10, the Armenian government placed 272  billion drams in the Central Bank of the countryDeputy Minister: As of October 10, the Armenian government placed 272  billion drams in the Central Bank of the country
Lydian Armenia paid over 930 000 USD to local communitiesLydian Armenia paid over 930 000 USD to local communities
Pashinyan: The framework of cooperation with the WB is completely  consistent with the priorities of the Armenian governmentPashinyan: The framework of cooperation with the WB is completely  consistent with the priorities of the Armenian government
By joint efforts, Armenia can be turned into a leading technological  hub - AvinyanBy joint efforts, Armenia can be turned into a leading technological  hub - Avinyan
Mher Grigoryan stated the need for cooperation with the WB in order  to develop the capital market in ArmeniaMher Grigoryan stated the need for cooperation with the WB in order  to develop the capital market in Armenia
Ardshinbank December 16 will begin the initial placement of dollar  bonds in the amount of $ 5 millionArdshinbank December 16 will begin the initial placement of dollar  bonds in the amount of $ 5 million
Armenian State Control Service revealed violations of 2 billion 103  million 988 drams at <Jrar> CJSCArmenian State Control Service revealed violations of 2 billion 103  million 988 drams at CJSC
SRC of Armenia: Starting January 1, 2020, the  cost of duty-free  import of goods will be reduced SRC of Armenia: Starting January 1, 2020, the cost of duty-free  import of goods will be reduced 
AmRating: Increasing toxicity of consumer loans will push banks to  not put all their eggs in one basketAmRating: Increasing toxicity of consumer loans will push banks to  not put all their eggs in one basket
ANPP scheduled stop scheduled for May 15ANPP scheduled stop scheduled for May 15
Vice Prime Minister: Armenia`s cooperation with ADB is complex and  multifacetedVice Prime Minister: Armenia`s cooperation with ADB is complex and  multifaceted
Too big to innovate?  The secrets to innovating at a big corporateToo big to innovate? The secrets to innovating at a big corporate


Exchange rates
12.12.2019
RUB7.560.03
USD477.71-0.31
EUR531.551.76
GBP629.961.94
CAD362.731.58
JPY43.96-0.02
CNY68.000.08
CHF486.120.82


Experts
Analysts Opinion on Central Bank Report Analysts Opinion on Central Bank Report 
Mining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-MiceMining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-Mice
Tigran Khachatryan: Attracting several transnational investors to  Armenia will allow the country to start playing for high stakesTigran Khachatryan: Attracting several transnational investors to  Armenia will allow the country to start playing for high stakes
During the first 5 years, the agricultural insurance market in Armenia will operate at a lossDuring the first 5 years, the agricultural insurance market in Armenia will operate at a loss
Artak Kamalyan: Education is the key to success. Everything else is of secondary importanceArtak Kamalyan: Education is the key to success. Everything else is of secondary importance
Head of PSRC: Whatever the agreement, the domestic tariff is  dependent on the price at the borderHead of PSRC: Whatever the agreement, the domestic tariff is  dependent on the price at the border
IMF: Armenia needs to achieve sustainable inclusive growthIMF: Armenia needs to achieve sustainable inclusive growth
Artur Atoyan: Problems of fish farmers are solved by the communist  method, that is, they are not solved at allArtur Atoyan: Problems of fish farmers are solved by the communist  method, that is, they are not solved at all
HSBC Bank Armenia digitalizes cooperation with retail clients HSBC Bank Armenia digitalizes cooperation with retail clients 
AmRating agency in cooperation with European Rating-Agentur Expert RA  GmbH has issued regular research on Armenia`s banking systemAmRating agency in cooperation with European Rating-Agentur Expert RA  GmbH has issued regular research on Armenia`s banking system
Yulia Ustyugova: Armenia can get access to IMF “insurance line”Yulia Ustyugova: Armenia can get access to IMF “insurance line”
Armand Arton: The question whether citizenship should be granted in  return for investments is rather rhetoricalArmand Arton: The question whether citizenship should be granted in  return for investments is rather rhetorical
Former head of the Ministry of Finance: <Confrontation> with Lydian may cost much to ArmeniaFormer head of the Ministry of Finance: with Lydian may cost much to Armenia
Vardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDPVardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDP
HSBC Bank Armenia increases efficiency and focuses on digital servicesHSBC Bank Armenia increases efficiency and focuses on digital services
Bulgarian Minister: The level of Armenian-Bulgarian economic  cooperation is still unsatisfactoryBulgarian Minister: The level of Armenian-Bulgarian economic  cooperation is still unsatisfactory
Expert: Recruitment market in Armenia from the point of view of  supply and demand is sleepingExpert: Recruitment market in Armenia from the point of view of  supply and demand is sleeping
Expert: Despite the adequacy of Armenian banks` capitals, the  opportunities for its optimal use are severely limitedExpert: Despite the adequacy of Armenian banks` capitals, the  opportunities for its optimal use are severely limited
Association of Organic Agriculture is being created in ArmeniaAssociation of Organic Agriculture is being created in Armenia
Pailak Tadevosyan: Governments change in Armenia, but taxation  approaches do not changePailak Tadevosyan: Governments change in Armenia, but taxation  approaches do not change

Search by date

Government Bonds

Issue volume

10 billion

Volume of T-bills for placement

200 million

Volume of submitted competitive applications

200 million

Volume of satisfied bids

200 million

Yield at cut-off price

 5.8314%

Maximum yield

 5.8314%

Мinimum yield

 5.8314%

Weighted average yield

 5.8314%

Number of participants

2

The maturity date of T-bills

03.02.2020

ArmEx

 

СПРОС (Покупка)

USD

Средневзв. Цена

482,00

ПРЕДЛОЖЕНИЕ (Продажа)

  USD

Средневзв. Цена

-

СДЕЛКИ

USD

Цена откр.

482,00

Цена закр.

482,00

Мин. Цена

482,00

Макс. Цена

482,00

Ср/взв. Цена

482,00

-0.16

Кол-во сделок

1

Объем (инвал.)

200 000

0бъем (драм)

96 400 000

Commented
Mining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-MiceMining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-Mice
Russian processing company Russian processing company "MultiCarta" discussed cooperation  opportunities with Yerevan Municipality in the transport sector
$ 270 Million to be invested in the construction of the first  skyscraper in Yerevan$ 270 Million to be invested in the construction of the first  skyscraper in Yerevan
The AGBU Women Entrepreneurs Program Launched in Artsakh: FRUITFUL  ARMENIA Foundation is the partnerThe AGBU Women Entrepreneurs Program Launched in Artsakh: FRUITFUL  ARMENIA Foundation is the partner
Forecast: Armenia has good prospects for expanding its presence in  the Polish marketForecast: Armenia has good prospects for expanding its presence in  the Polish market
Armenian government`s delegation headed by Prime Minister will take  part in the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum on June 6-7Armenian government`s delegation headed by Prime Minister will take  part in the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum on June 6-7
Concessionaire of Zvartnots International Airport promises to become  one of the best operators in the worldConcessionaire of Zvartnots International Airport promises to become  one of the best operators in the world
Arthur Javadyan: Central banks are not responsible for economic  growthArthur Javadyan: Central banks are not responsible for economic  growth
Forecast: Electricity exports to the Middle East through Iran are a  key component of Armenia`s geo- economic strategyForecast: Electricity exports to the Middle East through Iran are a  key component of Armenia`s geo- economic strategy
ArmInfo IC: In Armenia,  CMTPL loss ratio increased up to 64.5% in Q1  2019ArmInfo IC: In Armenia,  CMTPL loss ratio increased up to 64.5% in Q1  2019
From January 1, 2020, the cost of customs clearance of cars from  non-EEU countries in Armenia will increase by at least 4-5 fold:  whether the market for used cars is going upFrom January 1, 2020, the cost of customs clearance of cars from  non-EEU countries in Armenia will increase by at least 4-5 fold:  whether the market for used cars is going up
Overdue loans accelerate growth in banking system of ArmeniaOverdue loans accelerate growth in banking system of Armenia
RA Prime Minister: European Union is not ready to finance 100% of  development programs implementation in ArmeniaRA Prime Minister: European Union is not ready to finance 100% of  development programs implementation in Armenia
Converse Bank offers online loans at a low effective interest rateConverse Bank offers online loans at a low effective interest rate
Renco company will attract additional shareholders and partners to  the project of building a new thermal-power plant in ArmeniaRenco company will attract additional shareholders and partners to  the project of building a new thermal-power plant in Armenia
T.Avinyan: The Government is open for cooperation and encourages  active dialogue and interaction in all areas T.Avinyan: The Government is open for cooperation and encourages  active dialogue and interaction in all areas 
Agreement on construction of a new unit with combined gas cycle  signed in YerevanAgreement on construction of a new unit with combined gas cycle  signed in Yerevan
Veolia Jur: Regulatory charges are false and unfoundedVeolia Jur: Regulatory charges are false and unfounded
Armenian Prime Minister: We are gaining momentum for economic takeoffArmenian Prime Minister: We are gaining momentum for economic takeoff
Through the mobile banking application of Ardshinbank you can get a  loan in seconds.Through the mobile banking application of Ardshinbank you can get a  loan in seconds.
By the end of 2018, By the end of 2018, "Galburdjian Group" will launch the production of  sesame oil in Armenia
Expert: Armenia has a problem with effective use of water resources,  rather than small hydropower stationsExpert: Armenia has a problem with effective use of water resources,  rather than small hydropower stations
Investment forum Investment forum "Energy Week 2018" to be held in Armenia