Wednesday, December 21 2016 17:33

Expert: Programs on provision of advisory services and subsidization of fertilizers and fuel are ineffective

Expert: Programs on provision of advisory services and subsidization of fertilizers and fuel are ineffective

ArmInfo. The governmental programs on provision of advisory services and subsidization of fertilizers and fuel are ineffective, Karine Harutyunyan, Representative of the Economic Development and Research Center (EDRC), said during the presentation of the findings of the survey of budget programs on December 21. The monitoring was conducted by Oxfam Armenia and the EDRC. 

She noted that these programs are ineffective in terms of both expenses and public involvement. In particular, Harutyunyan pointed out that the farmers can receive government-subsidized fertilizers at more affordable prices unless there are monopolies in this field.  "The fertilizer prices are artificially raised both after being imported from Georgia and after subsidization. There is a possibility to provide fertilizers to the farmers at prices, which are by 30-35% lower than the current ones," Harutyunyan said. She added that prices may be reduced if fertilizers are imported from Israel, not from Georgia.  "The required fertilizers can be replaced by the local ones at least partly, particularly, with the products of Vanadzor-Khimprom Chemical Plant. In addition, it is necessary to choose the supplier via a tender and to divide the whole volume of supplies into parts in order to prevent any possible monopolies and to allow various companies to take part in the tenders," Harutyunyan said. The expert pointed out that in 2015 64% of the farmers were the beneficiaries of the fertilizer subsidization program, with 15% being beneficiaries of the fuel subsidization program. In 2016, the former dropped by 10%, and the latter - by 4%. 

For her part, Margarita Hakobyan, Country Director at Oxfam Armenia, said that the program on advisory services for agriculture is ineffective, because it involves only 20% of beneficiaries. She thinks that provision of high-quality advisory services needs integrated solutions and a transition to advanced technologies.  "Probably, it is necessary to change the format, particularly, to transform the regional centers supporting the rural communities into a republican center and to authorize a rural administration employee to provide such services or to render the services online, which is more affordable," she stressed. 

Armenian Deputy Minister of Agriculture Ashot Harutyunyan, in turn, agreed with the opinion that there are some flaws in the program implementation process, however, he thinks they are generally effective. He also shares the view that it is necessary to apply new approaches and advanced technologies. "We have received the relevant instructions from the Minister and we are working to enhance the efficiency of the regional centers to support the rural communities," the deputy minister noted.     

Harutyunyan also said that there are some shortcomings in the program supporting farmers. He noted that the Minister has already instructed revision of subsidization mechanisms. "As regards the fertilizer supplies, they are carried out through a tender won by a company offering a lower price," he added. He noted that he campaigns for supplies of locally made fertilizers, which will be both more affordable and of better quality.

The budget of the program on advisory services for agriculture for 2016 is 397.3 mln AMD. Since 2008, the program funding has increased 2.8-fold or by an average of 13.9% per annum. According to the survey, only 20% of farm entities are aware of this program or have participated in it. Only 9.8% of the participants in the survey of farm entities made use of the advisory services. 46.6% have never used the skills or recommendations, because the provided information was useless.

The budget of the program on government support to land users for 2016 is 3.1 bln AMD or 23.1% of the funds allocated for agriculture and 0.2% of the budget. As much as 2.8 bln AMD has been allocated for subsidization of fertilizers, and 0.3 bln AMD for subsidization of fuel. The survey conducted by Oxfam and EDRC says that over the past three years 65.9% of the respondents took part in the given program, 64.3% acquired fertilizers, and 15.6% acquired fuel. 

To note, Oxfam is an independent charitable organization founded in Oxford, UK, in 1942. The organization covers more than 70 countries.  In Armenia the program was approved in March 1993 and supports the Armenian Government in implementation of national development priorities. The EDRC is an independent research institute based in Yerevan in 2001 to conduct independent surveys in social development.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
National Geographic recommends visiting Armenia as an attractive  tourist destinationNational Geographic recommends visiting Armenia as an attractive  tourist destination
Pashinyan: program for providing housing to forcibly displaced  persons from Nagorno-Karabakh is entering practical stage of  implementationPashinyan: program for providing housing to forcibly displaced  persons from Nagorno-Karabakh is entering practical stage of  implementation
Projects implemented jointly with Rosatom State Corporation discussed  in ArmeniaProjects implemented jointly with Rosatom State Corporation discussed  in Armenia
Assessing long-term impact of new US sanctions against Russia will  take time - Central Bank GovernorAssessing long-term impact of new US sanctions against Russia will  take time - Central Bank Governor
Martin Galstyan: Azerbaijan is not among top 50 remittance  destinationsMartin Galstyan: Azerbaijan is not among top 50 remittance  destinations
Armenian Parliament approves report on  Execution of State Budget for  2023Armenian Parliament approves report on  Execution of State Budget for  2023
Fly Arna staff demand salariesFly Arna staff demand salaries
Pashinyan: Work has begun on developing program to address priority  issues for restoring disaster zone Pashinyan: Work has begun on developing program to address priority  issues for restoring disaster zone 
Instant money transfers from Russia to Armenia with the “ФОРА-БАНК” appInstant money transfers from Russia to Armenia with the “ФОРА-БАНК” app
Since 2017, National Foundation for Servicemen Insurance has paid  monetary compensation to families of 5,345 dead, missing servicemenSince 2017, National Foundation for Servicemen Insurance has paid  monetary compensation to families of 5,345 dead, missing servicemen
Armenia`s CB revises GDP growth forecast for 2024 upward Armenia`s CB revises GDP growth forecast for 2024 upward 
Economic entities must not get accustomed to Economic entities must not get accustomed to "cottonwood existence" -  minister
State budget both financial and political document - minister State budget both financial and political document - minister 
Premier was presented with draft strategic employment programPremier was presented with draft strategic employment program
WB does not change previous improved forecast for Armenia`s GDP  growth of 5.5% in 2024 and 4.9% in 2025 WB does not change previous improved forecast for Armenia`s GDP  growth of 5.5% in 2024 and 4.9% in 2025 
Martin Galstyan: Under favorable conditions, loan interest rates may  dropMartin Galstyan: Under favorable conditions, loan interest rates may  drop
CBA: GDP above-potential growth and its non-widespread nature poses  uncertainties regarding relative position of aggregate demand versus  aggregate supplyCBA: GDP above-potential growth and its non-widespread nature poses  uncertainties regarding relative position of aggregate demand versus  aggregate supply
Central Bank Governor: Inflation in Armenia to approach 2.2%-2.5% by  end of yearCentral Bank Governor: Inflation in Armenia to approach 2.2%-2.5% by  end of year
Armenia`s Central Bank expects additional incentives after Government  increases spending on eliminating consequences of disaster Armenia`s Central Bank expects additional incentives after Government  increases spending on eliminating consequences of disaster 
idcoin: New tool in IDBank’s loyalty systemidcoin: New tool in IDBank’s loyalty system
Armenia`s Central Bank continues reducing refinancing rate Armenia`s Central Bank continues reducing refinancing rate 
Income tax on mortgage loans to be abolished in 2029 Income tax on mortgage loans to be abolished in 2029 
About 173 Million Drams and More Than 30 Beneficiary Funds. About 173 Million Drams and More Than 30 Beneficiary Funds. "The Power of One Dram" is 4 Years Old
Armenia to participate in Food Africa-2024 exhibition Armenia to participate in Food Africa-2024 exhibition
EasyPay Supports Launch of “Financial Literacy” Program by Armenian Code Academy and Technological Education Foundation EasyPay Supports Launch of “Financial Literacy” Program by Armenian Code Academy and Technological Education Foundation 
 Team promotes business education: CaseKey Academy opened Team promotes business education: CaseKey Academy opened
Armenian-Indian business forum held in YerevanArmenian-Indian business forum held in Yerevan
Armenia elected UN Economic and Social Council Member for 2025-2027Armenia elected UN Economic and Social Council Member for 2025-2027
Central Bank identifies two main risks threatening Armenia`s  financial stabilityCentral Bank identifies two main risks threatening Armenia`s  financial stability
Armswissbank issues 3 bonds from the 10th of juneArmswissbank issues 3 bonds from the 10th of june
The Power of One Dram to The Road of Life: July`s Beneficiary is Strong MindThe Power of One Dram to The Road of Life: July`s Beneficiary is Strong Mind
Recent floods in Armenia confirm need to ensure food security -  statementRecent floods in Armenia confirm need to ensure food security -  statement
AraratBank places dollar bondsAraratBank places dollar bonds
Russia making efforts to resume launch of Mir cards in Armenia,  Kyrgyzstan Russia making efforts to resume launch of Mir cards in Armenia,  Kyrgyzstan 
Deputy Minister of Finance: Export of goods of Armenian origin  decreased by 14.3% in Q1 2024Deputy Minister of Finance: Export of goods of Armenian origin  decreased by 14.3% in Q1 2024
OVIO modernizes its sales and service centers in Kapan, Kajaran and  GyumriOVIO modernizes its sales and service centers in Kapan, Kajaran and  Gyumri
EU to allocate EUR11 million for next 5 years to implement R2D Syunik  projectEU to allocate EUR11 million for next 5 years to implement R2D Syunik  project
New sports complex to be constructed in KapanNew sports complex to be constructed in Kapan
Higher-rate economic activity growth in Armenia Higher-rate economic activity growth in Armenia 
 Armenia`s regional administration to receive AMD 2.5bln for  subvention programmes  Armenia`s regional administration to receive AMD 2.5bln for  subvention programmes 
Turnover tax forming unhealthy economic environment should be  abolished - premier Turnover tax forming unhealthy economic environment should be  abolished - premier 
Armenia is especially loved by tourists from Russia, Georgia, Iran,  the USA, Germany, France, Ukraine, China and BelarusArmenia is especially loved by tourists from Russia, Georgia, Iran,  the USA, Germany, France, Ukraine, China and Belarus
CBA CBA "accuses" bank clients of "illogical behavior"
Sanosyan: some problems arose during implementation of first landfill  construction projectSanosyan: some problems arose during implementation of first landfill  construction project
Russian Digital Attache in Armenia: Russia`s experience in building  underwater fiber-optic link may be relevant, including for ArmeniaRussian Digital Attache in Armenia: Russia`s experience in building  underwater fiber-optic link may be relevant, including for Armenia
YOY inflation in Armenia decreased from 1.3% to 0.3% in May, due to  cheaper food productsYOY inflation in Armenia decreased from 1.3% to 0.3% in May, due to  cheaper food products
Agriculture is becoming labor reservoir for more efficient service  industry - expertAgriculture is becoming labor reservoir for more efficient service  industry - expert
Part of main gas pipeline supplying Armenia with Russian gas will  come under Azerbaijani control - political scientistPart of main gas pipeline supplying Armenia with Russian gas will  come under Azerbaijani control - political scientist
EU allocated EUR 2.9 million to Armenia for rebranding of Armenian  brandyEU allocated EUR 2.9 million to Armenia for rebranding of Armenian  brandy
Use of electric cars and solar energy will limit Armenia`s dependence  on oil and gas marketsUse of electric cars and solar energy will limit Armenia`s dependence  on oil and gas markets
Armenian MFA: decision on Armenia`s participation in Chabahar port  project to be made within few monthsArmenian MFA: decision on Armenia`s participation in Chabahar port  project to be made within few months
Papoyan: export development strategy is almost readyPapoyan: export development strategy is almost ready
North-South`s construction odyssey: Only 10% of road has been  completed in 12 yearsNorth-South`s construction odyssey: Only 10% of road has been  completed in 12 years
Formation of common energy markets major factor of EAEU development -  Armenian vice-premier Formation of common energy markets major factor of EAEU development -  Armenian vice-premier 
Armenia`s taxpayers carried out 59.9mln transactions worth AMD  1,086blnArmenia`s taxpayers carried out 59.9mln transactions worth AMD  1,086bln
Armenian producers to participate in Sial-2024 exhibition in Paris Armenian producers to participate in Sial-2024 exhibition in Paris 
Armenia requests assistance from European Peace Foundation - FMArmenia requests assistance from European Peace Foundation - FM
Armenian producers to participate in Foodex Saudi-2024Armenian producers to participate in Foodex Saudi-2024
Armenia, Ukraine considering prospects for development of bilateral  economic ties Armenia, Ukraine considering prospects for development of bilateral  economic ties 
Armenia`s transition to clean energy and power transmission grid  upgrades to benefit from World Bank supportArmenia`s transition to clean energy and power transmission grid  upgrades to benefit from World Bank support
Read more
Exchange rates
14.06.2024
RUB4.400.04
USD388.490.45
EUR415.57-3.28
GBP493.58-2.10
CAD282.330.08
JPY24.740.05
CNY53.540.04
CHF434.892.00