Saturday, December 23 2017 16:17

Expert: Energy component of the Armenia-EU agreement conceals big threats for Armenia

Expert: Energy component of the Armenia-EU agreement conceals big threats for Armenia

ArmInfo. Over the past almost 30 years, Armenia and the whole region are in a state of rupture between two major integration projects - conditionally integration along the West-East axis (or the "Western Project") and the North-South axis (the "Eurasian Project"). Such an opinion at the conferences "Three years of the Unified Energy System: achievements and prospects" within the framework of the annual meeting of the Eurasian Expert Club, the leading analyst of Noravank, the national expert of the UN on energy Ara Marjanyan expressed.

According to him, it is within the framework of the "Western Project" that the energy transport blockade of Armenia is being implemented. "It is not just about laying the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline or the railway blockade of Armenia, but also what little is known about, and even less about cutting off Armenia from the development of the regional high-voltage power line network (Borchka-Ahlha line), achieved in 2004-2007 within the framework of the Organization of the Black Sea Economic Cooperation, at the initiative of Turkey and with the support of the United States and the EU. Or isolating Armenia from the development of backbone optic-logical networks of broadband networks and the Internet in the region, in the late 90s and early 2000s," the expert explained.

Concerning Armenia's integration preferences, the expert cites the opinion polls of the Helsinki Conference and Norway (Vanadzor office). "So, according to the results of the survey, third of respondents (33%) considered the desired participation of Armenia in the European Union, and another third (32%) - in the Eurasian. 12% considered the desirable participation in both of these unions, and 10% - in none of them. In August 2016, 41% of the respondents considered the participation of Armenia in the European Union, and only 25% in the Eurasian Union. No country in the world has caused such a serious damage to the positive attitude towards the Eurasian integration process and Russia, than Russia itself. The situation here was stabilized only by extraordinary measures: deliveries of Iskander, the creation of a single field of air defense and missile defense, the formation of a unified army, the consistent implementation of measures to extend the life of the Armenian nuclear power plant to 2026-2027," he said.

Concerning the agreement on comprehensive and expanded partnership between Armenia and the EU, the expert, in particular, focused on the energy component of it. Article 42 of the second chapter of the agreement states in part: "In the civil nuclear sector, in particular, to pay special attention to the high level of nuclear safety, based on IAEA standards and European Union standards and practices, and on the basis of international guidelines and practices on nuclear safety, cooperation in this area should include, inter alia: the closure and safe decommissioning of Metsamor NPP and the early adoption of a "road map" or plan for this purpose, taking into account the need for substitution nuclear power plants of new capacity, providing energy security of the Republic of Armenia and conditions for its sustainable development".

According to the expert, this formulation contains both positive and dangerous points. The positive moment is the 2nd block of Metsamor NPP. "The tasks are important and included in the list of priorities of the Armenian government," Marjanyan said. "Second, the recognized fact" of the specifics of "Armenia, in the formulation that leaves freedom in interpreting this very specifics", as well as "emotional security", the countries deprived of their own hydrocarbon resources and dependent on the supply of primary energy carriers," he said.

As the third argument of the expert, he cited the fact that he recognized the need for a substitute Metsamor NPP capable of ensuring energy security and sustainable development of the republic. Here it is necessary to emphasize that Metsamor NPP is first of all "guaranteed generating capacity"(GGM) and only then - a source of energy. It is the deficit of GGM - the main problem of the Armenian energy. It is the GGM that is the basis for energy security and the key to its development in the long term (solar, wind energy, small hydropower plants, and can not serve as substitute power for nuclear power plants.) For Armenia, these are either a new nuclear unit (and this, by the way, is the second principle of a state energy strategy developed by the government and approved by the President of Armenia in 2015.) Either large hydropower stations with reservoirs of long-term regulation, and nothing more," Marjanyan said.

The concealed dangers of the text of the agreement, in his opinion, should be attributed to the fact that the above formulation actually erodes the sole responsibility of the IAEA, the only professional international organization that has been dealing with the Armenian nuclear power plant for decades. "Today, after the signing of the agreement, in the issue of the Armenian NPP, and, consequently, in the matter of choosing the technology of the new nuclear power plant unit, Euratom and its 28 members joined the IAEA. The situation here alarmingly resembles attempts to blur the single mandate of the Minsk Group for the settlement of the confrontation in Artsakh, or attempts by the US and Israel to dilute the mandate of the same IAEA to monitor the implementation of the agreement on Iran's nuclear program," the expert said.

Summing up, according to Marjanyan, it turns out that Prague (sells weapons to Azerbaijan and calling for lifting the EU's restrictions on the sale of lethal weapons to this country), Warsaw (with its military- strategic cooperation with Turkey within NATO, including missile defense and nuclear weapons), or Budapest - with its close relations with Azerbaijan, as well as Vilnius, Riga or Tallinn, can effectively and, most importantly, legally, block the use of any Russian nuclear technology in the construction of a new unit of the Armenian NPP. Including the technology of WWER-type reactors familiar to Armenian specialists, which for today, and in the foreseeable future - are the most reliable, effective, and most importantly competitive in nuclear energy.

"In the final analysis, all this means that a mechanism has been created that could potentially deprive Armenia of nuclear energy." Moreover, a mechanism has been created that can cut Armenia off from Russia in the most significant, technological, long-term and science-intensive segment of cooperation," he concluded, saying that the wording of article 42 of the agreement has some freedom of interpretation.

READ ALL COMMENTS

ArmInfo
Вы совершенно правы. Ошибка исправлена. Спасибо!!!
Эдвард Арзуманян
Автор неправильно указал фамилию эксперта -правильно Марджанян а не Мараджян

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
Armenian IT sector`s output developed as compared with other regional states - expert Armenian IT sector`s output developed as compared with other regional states - expert 
Lawyer on `legal terror` surrounding ENA Lawyer on `legal terror` surrounding ENA 
AraratBank participated in the WEPs regional experience-sharing workshopAraratBank participated in the WEPs regional experience-sharing workshop
1,507 trucks with apricots leave for Russia since beginning of summer 1,507 trucks with apricots leave for Russia since beginning of summer 
TechWeek transforms Vanadzor into an innovation hubTechWeek transforms Vanadzor into an innovation hub
In Q1 2025, unemployment rate in Armenia decreased to 13.9%In Q1 2025, unemployment rate in Armenia decreased to 13.9%
Moody`s upgrades Converse Bank`s ratingsMoody`s upgrades Converse Bank`s ratings
Armenia`s industrial sector is experiencing a significant  declineArmenia`s industrial sector is experiencing a significant  decline
Power generation in Armenia increased by 3.6% in a yearPower generation in Armenia increased by 3.6% in a year
Armenia`s State Revenue Committee proposes postponing payment of  road, environmental taxes, entry duties Armenia`s State Revenue Committee proposes postponing payment of  road, environmental taxes, entry duties 
46 trucks with Armenian brandy enter Russia 46 trucks with Armenian brandy enter Russia 
Expert: Armenia has every chance to become a key regional  hub for  innovative solutionsExpert: Armenia has every chance to become a key regional  hub for  innovative solutions
IDBank issues the 3rd, 4th and 5th tranches of bonds of 2025IDBank issues the 3rd, 4th and 5th tranches of bonds of 2025
ARMSWISSBANK Launches Mastercard World – A New Premium CardARMSWISSBANK Launches Mastercard World – A New Premium Card
Ministry of Economy: Compared to 2018, job numbers in Armenia  increased by 33.9%Ministry of Economy: Compared to 2018, job numbers in Armenia  increased by 33.9%
Illegal mining in Armenia`s Syunik causes AMD 63mln damage to public Illegal mining in Armenia`s Syunik causes AMD 63mln damage to public 
Rospotrebnadzor requested additional information from competent  authorities in Armenia regarding the reason for the ban of Eskimo ice  cream Rospotrebnadzor requested additional information from competent  authorities in Armenia regarding the reason for the ban of Eskimo ice  cream 
Pashinyan discusses steps for establishing a major AI data center in  ArmeniaPashinyan discusses steps for establishing a major AI data center in  Armenia
In June,  Armenia`s annual inflation rate increased to 3.9%  driven  by higher prices for food  and servicesIn June,  Armenia`s annual inflation rate increased to 3.9%  driven  by higher prices for food  and services
Armenian products to enter Cyprus and US markets: CIBRS announces National Warehouse program strategyArmenian products to enter Cyprus and US markets: CIBRS announces National Warehouse program strategy
European Investment Bank remains Armenia`s key partner in  infrastructure projects - MinisterEuropean Investment Bank remains Armenia`s key partner in  infrastructure projects - Minister
Armenian Parliament gives  Armenian Parliament gives  "green light" to nationalization of ENA
Armenia`s dividends from ZCMC $113mln since 2022Armenia`s dividends from ZCMC $113mln since 2022
Ardshinbank summed up the raffle organized for Mastercard Business cardholdersArdshinbank summed up the raffle organized for Mastercard Business cardholders
Armenia extends ban on export of scrap metal until Feb. 1 2026 Armenia extends ban on export of scrap metal until Feb. 1 2026 
62 trucks with Armenian brandy cross Russian border 62 trucks with Armenian brandy cross Russian border 
Armenia to fix tariff quota on individual types of goods imported  from Iran Armenia to fix tariff quota on individual types of goods imported  from Iran 
Narek Karapetyan: Almost all infrastructure companies, except for  ENA, have increased their tariffs for servicesNarek Karapetyan: Almost all infrastructure companies, except for  ENA, have increased their tariffs for services
EIB: Education is one of key areas of partnership between EU-Armenia EIB: Education is one of key areas of partnership between EU-Armenia 
Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister participates in  4th International  Conference on Financing for Development in SevilleArmenian Deputy Foreign Minister participates in  4th International  Conference on Financing for Development in Seville
Armenian Prime Minister, President of  Trafigura Group discuss  potential  cooperation  in mining sector  Armenian Prime Minister, President of  Trafigura Group discuss  potential  cooperation  in mining sector  
ADB to provide Armenia with EUR236 million for construction of  Sisian-Kajaran roadADB to provide Armenia with EUR236 million for construction of  Sisian-Kajaran road
Vassilis Maragos: EU willing to strengthen technological cooperation with Armenia through concrete stepsVassilis Maragos: EU willing to strengthen technological cooperation with Armenia through concrete steps
Ardshinbank at the Forefront of Digital Security: Sponsor and Participant of BugBounty 2025 EventArdshinbank at the Forefront of Digital Security: Sponsor and Participant of BugBounty 2025 Event
Armenia`s regulator  approved the sale of 100% of GNC-ALFA s shares  to Viva Armenia CJSCArmenia`s regulator  approved the sale of 100% of GNC-ALFA s shares  to Viva Armenia CJSC
 International Chamber of Commerce ready to assist Armenia in hosting COP-17 International Chamber of Commerce ready to assist Armenia in hosting COP-17
Armenia to extend ban on ferrous metal exportsArmenia to extend ban on ferrous metal exports
IDBank Opens a New Branch at Homplex MallIDBank Opens a New Branch at Homplex Mall
MONEYVAL experts to visit Armenia in September to assess work on money laundering control MONEYVAL experts to visit Armenia in September to assess work on money laundering control 
Goods traceability to be improved in Armenia Goods traceability to be improved in Armenia 
Vaharshapan and Khoi communities to be merged Vaharshapan and Khoi communities to be merged 
Armenian NA OKs ENA nationalization Armenian NA OKs ENA nationalization 
Viva celebrates 20th anniversary: Armenia`s high-tech industry  minister on reforms in Armenia`s telecommunication industry Viva celebrates 20th anniversary: Armenia`s high-tech industry  minister on reforms in Armenia`s telecommunication industry 
Economic diversification meets Armenia`s interests - Kaja Kallas Economic diversification meets Armenia`s interests - Kaja Kallas 
5.1% increase in number of jobs in Armenia 5.1% increase in number of jobs in Armenia 
AraratBank: Special Rate for SWIFT Transfers up to EUR 20,000AraratBank: Special Rate for SWIFT Transfers up to EUR 20,000
Team Telecom Armenia, Team Systems under one roof: new Team Place  smart solutions center  openedTeam Telecom Armenia, Team Systems under one roof: new Team Place  smart solutions center  opened
Armenian Parliament discussing  nationalization of Electric Networks  of Armenia CJSCArmenian Parliament discussing  nationalization of Electric Networks  of Armenia CJSC
Armenia values development of  cooperation with Denmark in  high  technology and renewable energyArmenia values development of  cooperation with Denmark in  high  technology and renewable energy
ArmSwissBank: First in Armenia to Publish a Climate Transition PlanArmSwissBank: First in Armenia to Publish a Climate Transition Plan
Ucom Launches 5G Network in Abovyan and EjmiatsinUcom Launches 5G Network in Abovyan and Ejmiatsin
Armenia`s government to be entitled to approve new vehicle purchase support programmesArmenia`s government to be entitled to approve new vehicle purchase support programmes
WB appoints Fabrizio Zarcone as its new Country Manager for ArmeniaWB appoints Fabrizio Zarcone as its new Country Manager for Armenia
Armenia`s government violating Constitution and laws by trying to expropriate ENA - lawyer Armenia`s government violating Constitution and laws by trying to expropriate ENA - lawyer 
Armenian president holds bilateral meetings in Spain Armenian president holds bilateral meetings in Spain 
RA Tourism Committee, South Caucasus Railway combine efforts to develop tourism RA Tourism Committee, South Caucasus Railway combine efforts to develop tourism 
Populism being institutionalized in Armenia - ex-official Populism being institutionalized in Armenia - ex-official 
Samvel Karapetyan`s family starts investment dispute with Armenia Samvel Karapetyan`s family starts investment dispute with Armenia 
RA Minister of Economy  discussed  Armenian cargo carriers` situation  with his Georgian counterpartRA Minister of Economy  discussed  Armenian cargo carriers` situation  with his Georgian counterpart
Expert: Armenian businesses  face obstacles  to growth due to  unfavorable conditions Expert: Armenian businesses  face obstacles  to growth due to  unfavorable conditions 
Read more
Exchange rates
07.07.2025
RUB4.880.00
USD384.11-0.15
EUR450.45-2.13
GBP522.39-2.05
CAD281.13-1.56
JPY26.41-0.21
CNY53.54-0.11
CHF481.76-2.38