Wednesday, September 19 2018 18:58
Naira Badalian

Pailak Tadevosyan: Governments change in Armenia, but taxation  approaches do not change

Pailak Tadevosyan: Governments change in Armenia, but taxation  approaches do not change

ArmInfo.After the adoption of the Tax Code in 2016, the Armenian government immediately admitted that it is not only imperfect, but also "choking" business from all  sides. Nevertheless, due to a number of objective and subjective  reasons, reforms in the sphere for Karen Karapetyan's cabinet have  come to an end yet, without having begun, at the stage of the  "statement of intent".

"Pay taxes and live peacefully," declared the  new RA Cabinet of Ministers and responsibly took the baton, focusing  primarily on the reform of income tax - as the most "popular" type of  tax. And, despite the fact that the British statesman and politician  Sir Winston Leonard Spencer-Churchill acknowledged that good taxes do  not exist, the Cabinet of Nikol Pashinyan, after lengthy talks about  the availability of 8-10 scenarios for the revision of income tax,  recently announced two options, while declaring his personal  commitment to the second. Pylak Tadevosyan, chairman of the public  organization "Protection of taxpayers", told in an interview with  ArmInfo that we did not change the "sew on soap" and what the  citizens will end up with in the end.

Mr. Tadevosyan, on September 6 this year. Prime Minister Nikol  Pashinyan presented two options for changing the income tax rate,  stressing that the people should make the choice. The first option  proposed by the new Cabinet suggests a 3% reduction in the income tax  rate to 20% on wages up to 250 thousand drams, and for those who  receive more, the rate from the current 28% and 36% will decrease to  25%. The second scenario of changes is the introduction of a flat  scale of taxation, where, regardless of the amount of salary, 23%  income tax and profit tax plus dividend tax are also charged at 23%  (18% + 5%). In your opinion, which of the presented options is  preferable?

In order to answer this question, first of all, it is necessary to  understand what purpose the government is setting by initiating these  changes: has the government decided to reduce the tax burden of  employers, or is it intended to increase the amount of household  disposable income. It is also possible that if the government  promises, if it approves the second variant - the introduction of a  flat income tax scale, from receiving low wages of citizens - the  state will continue to collect the payments provided for by the  compulsory funded pension system (ONPS), at the same rate - 2.5%, the  government tries Do not create a new burden for citizens in the  implementation of the system. Or maybe the Cabinet promotes  attraction of investments in the republic, offering the formula "23%  + 23%", that is, income tax with consolidated tax (profit and  dividend taxation). Depending on the intended goal, it will be  possible to judge which of the options proposed by the Cabinet for  reforming the income tax is preferable.

Today, if we consider proposals, for example, from the point of view  of increasing the amount of disposable income of households, it is  not clear, for example, whether the tax burden of low-income people  is justified at the same level.  Many argue that the announced  changes are aimed at reducing the "shadow" in the economy and  identifying real wages. This, incidentally, does not hide the  country's financial authorities. Do you think, in fact, the  introduction of an equalization scale will serve these purposes?

And who said that reluctance to register employees is due only to  this argument? Maybe employees themselves ask the employer not to  register them, so that they will not lose their benefits? And is  there even an approximate calculation of how many employees are  "sitting in the shadows" and initiating such changes, the question of  how many we are solving. Or maybe the price of the issue - to  transfer to the "white field" only 5-6% of "shadow business". But  even in this case, there is a risk that only a good half of "illegal  immigrants" will decide to reveal themselves. In this case, it is not  feasible to go for such a large- scale change of the entire system,  if it is possible to achieve this goal by applying other instruments.

How viable is the hypothesis that the advantage of the second  scenario is also that high-income workers accumulate additional  funds, according to the authorities' estimates of about 38.5 billion  drams? These funds, as the Cabinet expects, will either enter the  economy, or "settle" on deposits in banks, which in turn will lead to  a reduction in lending rates.  Believe me, the costs of this "estate"  will not change much. And then, who can guarantee that the employer  will not reduce the amount of the calculated salary and whether there  are administrative mechanisms that the employer will not allow to  take such measures. Or maybe the employer agreed with the employee  that he will pay him a conditional 300 thousand drams, and with the  reduction of the income tax rate, he will continue to pay these  agreed 300 thousand drams. In my opinion, as soon as the rate is  lowered, the employer will go on reviewing the estimated salary.  The  Prime Minister, speaking of the advantages of a flat tax scale, said  that it can stimulate the flow of financial resources into the  country. As Pashinyan pointed out, a potential investor wishing to  invest in Armenia is primarily interested in - whether there is a  flat tax scale in the country. In your opinion, in fact, this aspect  is of such fundamental importance when choosing a country for  investment and can its revision become a green signal for an  investor?  The issue of stimulating investment through fiscal policy  of the state should be considered in a comprehensive manner. The  investor before "investing" in the Armenian economy, will consider  different types and regimes of taxation. In this context, the tax on  dividends should not be considered a matter of paramount importance:  the investor will look at how the issues on depreciation charges are  solved in Armenia, for example, in the light of the recent  restrictions on reducing the base rate, in some cases, the effective  tax rate for profits reaches 30% -35 %. Thus, not knowing whether the  non-taxable threshold of personal income will be provided, the  turnover tax will be revised, whether tax regimes or benefits for  border villages will be preserved, it is unlikely that the investor  will be guided only by the rate of profit tax and dividends.  Based  on the foregoing, today to judge the success of the proposed changes,  to assess the first or second option, speaking about their  preferences - it's a thankless task. Without a well-defined and clear  goal, any changes will not be successful unless the goals, criteria  for achieving them are initially clear, as well as the obvious  advantages of the new, desired state. So far, we have not been  declared a goal. And what we were presented today is just a digital  balancing act, where the choice should be guided by sympathy for the  given figures: "Choose, figure 20 looks better or figure 23" ?. In  this context, I hope that we will still see real public discussions,  but not in the format of a written response to a corresponding  request from the state department, but in a live controversy.  Having  announced possible scenarios for changing the rate of income tax, the  prime minister, and then the head of the State Revenue Committee,  spoke in favor of the second option - the introduction of a  flat-scale income tax. Do not you think that this way they direct  public opinion?  It seems that governments have been changing for  many years in Armenia, but approaches, in particular in the tax  sphere, do not change. That is, the country's financial authorities  are not guided by specific goals, but only perform simple  mathematical actions, increasing or decreasing the tax rate.  Meanwhile, it is more correct to outline the goal, and only then to  look for approaches to it, considering each type of tax in  conjunction with other types and regimes affiliated with it.  The  financial authorities, speaking of possible changes, assured that the  reforms will be continued and the reduction of the income tax rate to  20% will be ensured within the next 5 years. According to Pashinyan,  the government is ready to commit itself in the coming years to  reduce the flat scale of taxation by at least 0.5% per year in order  to achieve this 20% threshold in 5 years. What is it - a  demonstration of a clear intention of the Cabinet in the future to  reduce the rate of income tax or "good wish" in order to buy time and  today to achieve what you want?  Talking about its intentions for the  future 5-year anniversary, the Armenian government, wishing it or  not, announces about its program for this period. If this is actually  a benchmark for a given period of time, then this implies the  intention of a more thorough revision of the RA Tax Code in the long  term. In this context, it is reasonable to present approaches and  principles for a possible revision of all tax legislation. There can  not be a tax reform only on the part of income tax for the next 5  years, since all other types of taxes and tax regimes somehow come  into contact with it..  And if the authorities are not ready to talk  about a 5-year program, then now it would be more correct to state a  specific figure - the rate of income tax for the current year,  without touching the topic of future changes in the tax rate, keep  the threshold of the non-taxable VAT on turnover at 115 million,  which is planned from January 1, 2019 to reduce to 58.35 million.   Even Albert Einstein, being a Nobel Laureate said that "the most  incomprehensible in the world - a tax scale", so that not having the  desire to comprehend the incomprehensible, I would like to know your  point of view, as an expert, how should the tax system, in particular  In addition to solving fiscal problems, it would be aimed at ensuring  social justice, as Nikol Pashinyan said, by the way.  I am in favor  of a progressive scale of income tax. For example, I am in favor of  setting a 23% rate of income tax from wages to 2 million and 36% on  wages above this threshold. If the employer decided to pay someone a  salary of 4 million for "doing nothing", then why deprive the state  of the tax base.  On the other hand, let's not forget that the  progressive scale of income tax solves certain issues of income  redistribution in society. In this context, it may be necessary to  compare the issue of income redistribution with property taxes, that  is, to consider the issue of tax consolidation, including property  tax. Here it is necessary to be guided by the fact that persons who  receive income above a certain threshold accumulate their assets in  real estate objects or invest them.  But, since we are talking about  social justice, it is possible to be guided by the experience of a  number of Western countries, which establish the non-taxable  threshold of personal income, and only in excess of this figure, the  tax begins to calculate the income tax on a progressive scale. You  can also calculate and tax the cumulative income of the whole family,  rather than its individual working member, taking into account all  possible and necessary costs of the family. A taxpayer integrity  issue can be to stimulate when it - the taxpayer to make sure that  the taxes paid by them in the form of any of the services provided by  the state (medicine, education) be returned to him.  I recall that a  few years ago, initiating the process of adoption of the Tax Code,  the authors have proclaimed a number of basic principles, involving  including limiting the clarity of the document, no fancy wording and  its focus on stimulating the business environment and investment. The  provisions were fixed in the Concept to documents, but they were  successfully forgotten in the development of the Code - they  increased the tax burden on income tax and taxed dividends, revised  depreciation rates. Meanwhile, to stimulate investment, the tax  burden must be competitive in the region, including through indirect  taxes, the legislation should be accessible and not be at variance.  Thus, if today we want to reform the tax legislation, we must return  to the ideas fixed in the Concept to the code of October 2016. In  addition, we must guarantee a stable tax environment for business -  that is, consolidate mechanisms that will protect a potential  investor from frequent changes in tax legislation. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
International IT Cooperation Platform to be established in ArmeniaInternational IT Cooperation Platform to be established in Armenia
Ruben Vardanyan on the question related to offshore: When you do  something good, always expect bad things Ruben Vardanyan on the question related to offshore: When you do  something good, always expect bad things 
It turned  possible to obtain synthetic petroleum products from coal  obtained as a result of the development of the Karabakh deposit  MagavuzIt turned  possible to obtain synthetic petroleum products from coal  obtained as a result of the development of the Karabakh deposit  Magavuz
International Finance Corporation can assist Armenia in capital  market developmentInternational Finance Corporation can assist Armenia in capital  market development
The head of the SRC for auto-importers: the tax is obliged to adhere  to the framework of the current legislation, but for now will refrain  from measures of administrative coercionThe head of the SRC for auto-importers: the tax is obliged to adhere  to the framework of the current legislation, but for now will refrain  from measures of administrative coercion
Despite the restructuring process, the Ministry of Transport of  Armenia is ready to support new programs and ideasDespite the restructuring process, the Ministry of Transport of  Armenia is ready to support new programs and ideas
EDB forecasts acceleration of economic growth in Armenia in 2019 due  to recovery of investment activityEDB forecasts acceleration of economic growth in Armenia in 2019 due  to recovery of investment activity
EDB launched a settlement system for legal entities with no need to  use SWIFT EDB launched a settlement system for legal entities with no need to  use SWIFT 
Natural gas supplies from Russia to Armenia in January-March 2019  increased by 6%Natural gas supplies from Russia to Armenia in January-March 2019  increased by 6%
Armenia intends to increase transparency in subsoil useArmenia intends to increase transparency in subsoil use
Armenian Foreign Minister visited Armenian Foreign Minister visited "Engineering City"
Armenian parliament amended law on state assistance in the field of  information technologyArmenian parliament amended law on state assistance in the field of  information technology
Armenian parliament approves agreement on trade and economic  cooperation between China and the EAEUArmenian parliament approves agreement on trade and economic  cooperation between China and the EAEU
Beeline Armenia PR manager reads  Beeline Armenia PR manager reads  "PR and Communication Technologies"   lecture for students 
Central Bank of Armenia and KfW to discuss the possibility of  implementing 3 new programs in the fields of renewable energy,  mortgage, trade and SMECentral Bank of Armenia and KfW to discuss the possibility of  implementing 3 new programs in the fields of renewable energy,  mortgage, trade and SME
Within framework of digital services, Ardshinbank activated Within framework of digital services, Ardshinbank activated "Money  transfer by telephone call" service 
Armenian parliament agreed to raise customs duty on cement, leaving  the same rate on clinker unchangedArmenian parliament agreed to raise customs duty on cement, leaving  the same rate on clinker unchanged
Head of Ministry of Emergency Situations doubts effectiveness and  justification of anti-hail stations and calls for thinking about  introduction of agricultural insuranceHead of Ministry of Emergency Situations doubts effectiveness and  justification of anti-hail stations and calls for thinking about  introduction of agricultural insurance
Armenian government ready to consider extending customs duty on  imported clinker for cement productionArmenian government ready to consider extending customs duty on  imported clinker for cement production
Russian company is interested in the program of reforming Yerevan  transport system Russian company is interested in the program of reforming Yerevan  transport system 
Advertising of financial intermediaries to be banned in ArmeniaAdvertising of financial intermediaries to be banned in Armenia
Subsoil Code and the package of related laws have been amended in the  first reading of the Armenian ParliamentSubsoil Code and the package of related laws have been amended in the  first reading of the Armenian Parliament
Armenian SRC carries out various activities at 71 gas filling  stationsArmenian SRC carries out various activities at 71 gas filling  stations
VivaCell-MTS service centers operational on Good FridayVivaCell-MTS service centers operational on Good Friday
Cloud PBX solution by VivaCell-MTS: Cost-efficient services for companiesCloud PBX solution by VivaCell-MTS: Cost-efficient services for companies
Head of SCS: Two companies of farmers-water users are obliged to  restore to the budget the amount of more than 2 billion dramsHead of SCS: Two companies of farmers-water users are obliged to  restore to the budget the amount of more than 2 billion drams
Minister: A 10-year program worth $ 700 million is implemented in  Minister: A 10-year program worth $ 700 million is implemented in  "Armenian Electric Networks" CJSC
The implementation of the modernization program of the second power  unit of the Armenian nuclear power plant will lead to an increase in  plant capacity by 10%The implementation of the modernization program of the second power  unit of the Armenian nuclear power plant will lead to an increase in  plant capacity by 10%
State Interest Fund to be established in ArmeniaState Interest Fund to be established in Armenia
PharmaTech JSC invests 4.2 billion drams into the modernization of  productionPharmaTech JSC invests 4.2 billion drams into the modernization of  production


Exchange rates
23.04.2019
RUB7.560.00
USD481.56-0.42
EUR542.00-0.18
GBP626.560.47
CAD360.15-0.67
JPY43.05-0.01
CNY71.79-0.11
CHF472.81-2.23


Experts
Former head of the Ministry of Finance: <Confrontation> with Lydian may cost much to ArmeniaFormer head of the Ministry of Finance: with Lydian may cost much to Armenia
Vardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDPVardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDP
HSBC Bank Armenia increases efficiency and focuses on digital servicesHSBC Bank Armenia increases efficiency and focuses on digital services
Bulgarian Minister: The level of Armenian-Bulgarian economic  cooperation is still unsatisfactoryBulgarian Minister: The level of Armenian-Bulgarian economic  cooperation is still unsatisfactory
Expert: Recruitment market in Armenia from the point of view of  supply and demand is sleepingExpert: Recruitment market in Armenia from the point of view of  supply and demand is sleeping
Expert: Despite the adequacy of Armenian banks` capitals, the  opportunities for its optimal use are severely limitedExpert: Despite the adequacy of Armenian banks` capitals, the  opportunities for its optimal use are severely limited
Association of Organic Agriculture is being created in ArmeniaAssociation of Organic Agriculture is being created in Armenia
Pailak Tadevosyan: Governments change in Armenia, but taxation  approaches do not changePailak Tadevosyan: Governments change in Armenia, but taxation  approaches do not change
Rouben Indjikian: Everyone should follow the established unified and fair rules of the gameRouben Indjikian: Everyone should follow the established unified and fair rules of the game
Mher Arakelyan:  Armenia`s payment business has great prospectsMher Arakelyan:  Armenia`s payment business has great prospects
Rating-Agentur Expert RA GmbH and AmRating issued an industry report  on Armenia`s banking systemRating-Agentur Expert RA GmbH and AmRating issued an industry report on Armenia`s banking system
Igor Nazaruk: Each planted sprout has the right to a successful prospect if it is cherished and taken care ofIgor Nazaruk: Each planted sprout has the right to a successful prospect if it is cherished and taken care of
Ara Khzmalyan: Armenia is comfortable to Russian touristAra Khzmalyan: Armenia is comfortable to Russian tourist
The Armenian delegation to the US followed the advice of President TrumpThe Armenian delegation to the US followed the advice of President Trump
Outflow of population and passivity of the Diaspora pushes property prices downOutflow of population and passivity of the Diaspora pushes property prices down
Finombudsman: Amendments to the Civil Code on the imposition of fines and penalties will reduce the number of outstanding loans and  non-creditworthy consumersFinombudsman: Amendments to the Civil Code on the imposition of fines and penalties will reduce the number of outstanding loans and non-creditworthy consumers
Vahan Shakaryan: If we promote Armenia, the promotion of economic sectors will not be a run with obstacles, but a light run for short distancesVahan Shakaryan: If we promote Armenia, the promotion of economic sectors will not be a run with obstacles, but a light run for short distances
Gagik Aghajanyan: There is no need to look for alternatives - it is necessary to work and develop actual   directionsGagik Aghajanyan: There is no need to look for alternatives - it is necessary to work and develop actual   directions
Vitaly Nesis: Armenia is very promising from the geological point of viewVitaly Nesis: Armenia is very promising from the geological point of view
The market of OSAGO goes into virtual spaceThe market of OSAGO goes into virtual space

Search by date

Government Bonds

 

ISIN AMGT13291250
Auction ID AMGB1029A250A
Date 02.02.2019
Issue date 29.10.2019
Issue volume (AMD) 50 000 000 000
Maturity date 29.10.2025
Coupon year yield 11.00%
Auction volume (AMD) 1000 000 000 - 2.000 000 000
Auction date 12.05.2017
DLS
Total amount (AMD) 1 000 000 000
Amount of the total bids (AMD) 787 200 000
Amount of the total accepted bids (AMD) 787 200 000
Cut of yield (%) 10,6447
Weighted avrage yield (%) 10,6447
Auction max  yield (%) 10,6447
Auction min  yield (%) 10,6447
Number of participants 5
ArmEx

 

СПРОС (Покупка)

USD

Средневзв. Цена

482,00

ПРЕДЛОЖЕНИЕ (Продажа)

  USD

Средневзв. Цена

-

СДЕЛКИ

USD

Цена откр.

482,00

Цена закр.

482,00

Мин. Цена

482,00

Макс. Цена

482,00

Ср/взв. Цена

482,00

-0.16

Кол-во сделок

1

Объем (инвал.)

200 000

0бъем (драм)

96 400 000

Commented
Overdue loans accelerate growth in banking system of ArmeniaOverdue loans accelerate growth in banking system of Armenia
RA Prime Minister: European Union is not ready to finance 100% of  development programs implementation in ArmeniaRA Prime Minister: European Union is not ready to finance 100% of  development programs implementation in Armenia
T.Avinyan: The Government is open for cooperation and encourages  active dialogue and interaction in all areas T.Avinyan: The Government is open for cooperation and encourages  active dialogue and interaction in all areas 
Agreement on construction of a new unit with combined gas cycle  signed in YerevanAgreement on construction of a new unit with combined gas cycle  signed in Yerevan
Veolia Jur: Regulatory charges are false and unfoundedVeolia Jur: Regulatory charges are false and unfounded
Armenian Prime Minister: We are gaining momentum for economic takeoffArmenian Prime Minister: We are gaining momentum for economic takeoff
Through the mobile banking application of Ardshinbank you can get a  loan in seconds.Through the mobile banking application of Ardshinbank you can get a  loan in seconds.
By the end of 2018, By the end of 2018, "Galburdjian Group" will launch the production of  sesame oil in Armenia
Expert: Armenia has a problem with effective use of water resources,  rather than small hydropower stationsExpert: Armenia has a problem with effective use of water resources,  rather than small hydropower stations
Investment forum Investment forum "Energy Week 2018" to be held in Armenia
Expert: It is necessary to start implementing the program for the  construction of a new nuclear unitExpert: It is necessary to start implementing the program for the  construction of a new nuclear unit
The Armenian government suggests raising the minimum pension by 60%The Armenian government suggests raising the minimum pension by 60%
The updated feasibility study of construction project of electricity transmission line Armenia- Georgia will be ready by the end of the year - the Ministry of EnergyThe updated feasibility study of construction project of electricity transmission line Armenia- Georgia will be ready by the end of the year - the Ministry of Energy
Eurasian Development Bank wishes to expand its activities in ArmeniaEurasian Development Bank wishes to expand its activities in Armenia
$ 100 million to be invested in repatriation project Build Armenia$ 100 million to be invested in repatriation project Build Armenia
FRV: Armenia`s growing desire to increase renewable energy sources is  a decisive factorFRV: Armenia`s growing desire to increase renewable energy sources is a decisive factor
Suren Papikyan: It`s safe now to do business in Armenia, assures  Armenian MinisterSuren Papikyan: It`s safe now to do business in Armenia, assures  Armenian Minister
Armenian state debt started reducing up to $6.7 bln to June 1 2018Armenian state debt started reducing up to $6.7 bln to June 1 2018
Minister: Implementation of program on liberalization of the electric  power complex of Armenia will be completed within the next two yearsMinister: Implementation of program on liberalization of the electric  power complex of Armenia will be completed within the next two years
Nikol Pashinyan: In a number of cases after paying fines and  penalties the borrowers will be allowed to take new loan Nikol Pashinyan: In a number of cases after paying fines and  penalties the borrowers will be allowed to take new loan 
German bank KFW urges Armenia to build power line in the direction to  GeorgiaGerman bank KFW urges Armenia to build power line in the direction to  Georgia
Anna Chobanyan-one of most likely candidates for new Head of General  Department of Civil Aviation Anna Chobanyan-one of most likely candidates for new Head of General  Department of Civil Aviation 
IFAD confirms its readiness to develop and implement new joint programs with Armenia`s Agriculture MinistryIFAD confirms its readiness to develop and implement new joint programs with Armenia`s Agriculture Ministry
Rosselkhoznadzor asks not politicize the issue of deliveries of tomatoes from Armenia to RussiaRosselkhoznadzor asks not politicize the issue of deliveries of tomatoes from Armenia to Russia
Armenian nuclear power station has a resource for work for another 30  yearsArmenian nuclear power station has a resource for work for another 30 years
Premier: Construction of a new nuclear power plant in Armenia is one of the priorities of the new government of the countryPremier: Construction of a new nuclear power plant in Armenia is one of the priorities of the new government of the country