Monday, January 27 2025 20:05
Karina Melikyan

Fitch Ratings affirms Armenia`s sovereign rating: outlook 

Fitch Ratings affirms Armenia`s <BB-> sovereign rating: outlook  <Stable>

ArmInfo. Fitch Ratings has affirmed Armenia's Long-Term Foreign Currency Issuer Default Rating (IDR) at <BB-> with a <Stable> outlook, as noted in the Fitch Ratings statement. It also includes an updated forecast for Armenia's GDP growth, projecting a slowdown to 4.8% in 2025 (down from an estimated  6% in 2024 and an actual  8.3% in 2023).

Key Rating Drivers

Credit Fundamentals: Armenia's <BB-> rating reflects per capita  income and governance indicators that are inline with peers,  stable  growth prospects and a robust macroeconomic policy framework. Set  against these strengths, Fitch notes the small size of the economy,  large fiscal deficit relative to with peers, relatively weak external  finances, high financial sector dollarization, and geopolitical  risks. 

Higher Fiscal Deficit: Fitch projects  the government deficit  to  increase to 5.5% of GDP in 2025 (2024:  4.7%; current BB median:3%),  reflecting  an expansionary fiscal policy. This incorporates  the  costs of integrating about 65,000 refugees from Nagorno-Karabakh  (presumably those who received social material assistance from the  state, out of around 120,000 Artsakh residents forcibly displaced to  Armenia in September 2023 - Ed.) and higher military spending. The  planned introduction of universal health insurance program from 2026  will increase expenditure by about 1.3% of GDP/ year, keeping the  deficit at 5.4% of GDP in 2026.

Adherence to Fiscal Rules: Fitch assumes the authorities will comply  with the fiscal rules that are triggered  when gross general  government debt/GDP exceeds 50%, including moderating current  expenditure growth (excluding interest payments) to below historical  nominal economic growth rates.  While planned capex  will be larger  than the fiscal deficit (both as a percentage of GDP) as per the  fiscal rules, Fitch expects capacity constraints to continue to limit  project execution.

Rising Debt Trajectory, FX Risk: Fitch projects that the fiscal  loosening will increase GGGD from an estimated 49.7% in 2024 to 55%   by end-2026, in line with projected peer medians. Debt dynamics are  heavily exposed to currency risk, given that as of October 2024,  48.6% of GGGD was foreign-exchange- denominated.  However, market  risks are mitigated by the fixed interest-rate structure of 85.7% of  outstanding debt, and the high (75%) proportion of concessional debt  owed to multilateral and bilateral lenders within external government  debt.  The authorities plan to issue a Eurobond in Q1 2025 to redeem  a maturing $313 million  Eurobond in March 2025. The authorities also  plan an overfinancing on external sources (including through  borrowings from multilateral organizations) and  domestic markets in  2025-2026, anticipating budgetary and project financing needs.

Negotiations with Azerbaijan: Armenia and Azerbaijan have reportedly  reached an agreement on certain key points for an eventual peace  treaty, including border delimitation. The flexibility and  willingness from both parties to resolve the outstanding issues and  the timing for a potential resolution remain uncertain.  Fitch does  not expect a sustained military re-escalation of the conflict. A  comprehensive peace treaty could potentially unlock trade routes to  Turkiye and benefit Armenia's long-term growth potential.

Worsening Relations with Russia: Armenia's relations with Russia  appear to be worsening, as Armenia is considering EU membership,  which may be incompatible with its membership in the Russian-led  Eurasian Economic Union. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has  reportedly expressed his desire to leave the Russia- led Collective  Security Treaty Organization. Fitch analysts believe, a fundamental  breakdown in relations is unlikely given Armenia's dependence on  Russia for energy and trade (24% of exports and 56% of imports).  We  expect Armenian banks to continue to comply with Western sanctions on  Russia.

Moderating Growth: Fitch estimates the economy to have grown by 6% in  2024 (vs 8.3% in 2023; 12.6% in 2022) as the spillovers of the large  increase in migration from Russia and Ukraine, as well as the refugee  influx from Nagorno-Karabakh, have abated. Fitch has reduced its  growth expectations for 2025 to 4.8% from 5.5%, given that the  opening of the Amulsar gold mine has been pushed back to at least  4Q25 (from 1Q25). We expect growth to ease to 4.5% in 2026, as the  services sector growth may be difficult to sustain, and as credit  growth moderates, although production from Amulsar could provide an  upside.

Weak External Balance Sheet: External finances are a rating weakness  for Armenia, given its record of large current account deficits  (CADs) and high net external debt relative to rating peers. The CAD  was 4.2% of GDP in 1Q24-3Q24 (current 'BB' median: 2.2%). The large  flow of gold re-exports (USD4.9 billion, equivalent to 47% of total  Armenian goods exports) from Russia to the United Arab Emirates, in  1Q24-3Q24 has significantly moderated, and is not likely to recur.  Fitch expects the CAD to average 4.3% of GDP in 2025-2026,  characterised by continued large goods deficits and services  surpluses.

International reserve coverage fell to just 2 months of current  external payments (CXP) in 2024, although this was skewed by the  large increase in re-exported gold imports. Excluding these, coverage  was 2.7 months of CXP, and Fitch expects it to average 3.2 months in  2025-2026 (current 'BB' median: 4.9). Fitch expects that authorities  will not draw down the USD121 million available under the IMF  Stand-By Arrangement (expiring this year), and will treat it as a  precautionary buffer. Net external debt will be about 2x the  projected 'BB' median, averaging 26.8% of GDP in 2025-2026.  

Stable Inflation and New inflation Target: Inflation averaged 0.3% of  GDP in 2024, driven partly by base effects, food prices, as well as  zero growth in core inflation. Inflation will average 3.3% in  2025-2026 given Fitch's expectation of a depreciation of the Armenian  dram, and fiscal policy loosening. Policy rates were cut by a  cumulative 225bp in 2024; the scope for further cuts is limited.    Effective January 2025, the Central Bank of Armenia reduced its  medium-term inflation target to 3% (with a variation band of +/-1  pp).  Armenia has a record of low inflation relative to rating peers,  but also has an inconsistent record of meeting the previous inflation  target of 4% with a tolerance band of +/-1.5pp, which was introduced  in 2006. We expect the authorities to remain largely committed to a  floating exchange rate.

ESG - Governance: Armenia has an ESG Relevance Score of '5' for  Political Stability and Rights, and '5+' for the Rule of Law,  Institutional and Regulatory Quality, and Control of Corruption.  These scores reflect the high weight that the World Bank Governance  Indicators (WBGI) have in our proprietary Sovereign Rating Model.  Armenia has a medium WBGI ranking at the 45th percentile, reflecting  a moderate level of rights for participation in the political  process, relatively high geopolitical risks, moderate levels of  political stability, moderate institutional capacity and rule of law  and a moderate level of corruption.

Rating sensitivities

Factors that Could, Individually or Collectively, Lead to Negative  Rating Action/Downgrade

- Public Finances: Macroeconomic or policy developments that result  in a rapid increase in general government debt/GDP.

- External Finances: Increased external vulnerabilities, for example  as a result of a sustained decline in international reserves or wider  CADs.

- Structural: A materialisation of geopolitical risks that undermines  political and economic stability.  Factors that Could, Individually  or Collectively, Lead to Positive Rating Action/Upgrade

- Macro: Increased confidence in the sustainability of high growth  rates relative to peers, for example, due to a durable decline in  geopolitical risks that results in a sustained increase in GDP per  capita.

- Public Finances: Fiscal consolidation that supports a decline in  general government debt/GDP, and deepening of local-currency funding  sources that durably reduces the FX proportion of government debt.

It should be noted that in August 2024, the S&P Global Ratings ( S&P)  confirmed Armenia's sovereign rating at "BB-" with a "Stable"  outlook. They also predicted a 6.2% GDP growth in Armenia for 2024  with a further slowdown to 5.2% in 2025.