Wednesday, July 16 2025 11:30
Alexandr Avanesov

NA opposition factions  appeal to  CC, challenging constitutionality  of  law on  nationalization of ENA

NA opposition factions  appeal to  CC, challenging constitutionality  of  law on  nationalization of ENA

ArmInfo.  The NA opposition factions "Armenia" and "I have Honor"  have filed an application to the Constitutional Court, challenging the constitutionality of a law adopted by the authorities regarding the nationalization of  Electric Networks of Armenia CJSC, as reported to the Pastinfo  by Artsvik Minasyan, the secretary of the opposition faction "Armenia".

The publication notes that the ruling faction "Civil Contract" in the  country developed a draft legislative amendment in just two weeks,  allowing the executive branch to take over the management of "ENA".  The presented package of laws was adopted by it during an  extraordinary session of the National Assembly within 24 hours. The  professional community is concerned about the lack of legal and  legitimate instruments for nationalizing property, viewing this as a  process of "taking away business" and an attempt to overthrow the  constitutional order, which is unacceptable in a state governed by  the rule of law. 

The professional community is confident that this political process  will ultimately fail in international courts. They believe that  another verdict will be passed against the Republic of Armenia, and  the financial burden will be shifted to the taxpayers of the Republic  of Armenia. In other words, the citizens will bear the burden of the  illegality of these authorities. Both opposition factions have now   filed an application to the Constitutional Court demanding that the  law adopted by the authorities be recognized as unconstitutional.   They also petitioned for the legislative package to be suspended  until the Constitutional Court makes a decision. As of now, a  decision on accepting the application filed on July 11 has not been  made. There is no information about this on the Constitutional Court  website, and the applicants have not received a response.  However, a  decision is expected in the near future, given the three-day period  established by law.

Artsvik Minasyan, a member of the "Armenia" faction in the Na,  told  Pastinfo in detail that several articles and amendments are being  contested in the statement. The first issue concerns the right of  ownership, particularly,  this amendment invalidates  a license   without a court decision, which means  a licensed company is deprived  of the right to use its property as intended. Additionally, it allows  for a property rights to be restricted by seizing property in ways  not outlined in international treaties and the Constitution. The  second group of violations pertains to the violation of the principle  of non-retroactivity of the law, considered fundamental.  For  instance, an energy system enterprise could  be held liable for  violations that occurred before this law was enacted. 

The third group of issues, according to Minasyan, involves the  violation of the principles of independence and autonomy of  autonomous bodies as outlined in the Constitution. Specifically, the  amendments  ignore the Public Services Regulatory Commission,  which  is as a collegial body. The appointment of a manager can only be made  only by the commission chairman, when is then given  the authority to  make all decisions of the energy system enterprise. This deprives the  owners, the board of directors and the executive director of the  ability to make any decisions. Minasyan also noted  that there are  several formulations that violate the principle of legal certainty in  determining the price. 

Particularly, it is stated that the preemptive right belongs to the  state, whereas in the case of  LLCs and CJSCs, the preemptive right  belongs to the shareholders. Now, this right has been granted to the  state without amending these laws. According to Minasyan, obvious  violations were also revealed in the procedures for adopting laws: no  conclusions were provided and, the public was deprived of the  opportunity to participate in making this decision through hearings.  In other words, the participation process was violated. However,  according to Artsvik Minasyan, the biggest threat is a possible  crisis in the energy system, which is guaranteed by these amendments.

"If these amendments are implemented, the energy system will  collapse," Minasyan noted. The deputy also reported that a request  has been submitted to the Constitutional Court to suspend the  amendments to the laws if the appeal is accepted for proceedings  before a decision on the merits is made, as this could have extremely  irreversible consequences for the system. Additionally, a request  will be submitted to consider the case orally, as the issue has a  significant public resonance and impacts crucial societal and state  matters, including security. "Although we don't have high  hopes for  the current composition of the Constitutional Court, this is  important for the international community," the parliamentarian  noted. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
In Armenia`s  interbank foreign exchange market,  dollar, ruble  transactions decreased from August 25 to 29, 2025In Armenia`s  interbank foreign exchange market,  dollar, ruble  transactions decreased from August 25 to 29, 2025
A New Funding Opportunity - Unsecured Agri Loan from AraratBankA New Funding Opportunity - Unsecured Agri Loan from AraratBank
Zakharova does not rule out  Armenian  Prime Minister`s   participation in  Zakharova does not rule out  Armenian  Prime Minister`s   participation in  "World Atomic Week"
Armenia, U.S. to cooperate in nuclear energy, including small modular  reactorsArmenia, U.S. to cooperate in nuclear energy, including small modular  reactors
Ameriabank presents the First Digital Business Cards in ArmeniaAmeriabank presents the First Digital Business Cards in Armenia
Minister:  Draft law Minister:  Draft law "On Cybersecurity" submitted to  National  Assembly  for consideration
Armenia to regulate regular road transportation of passengers and  goods with ChinaArmenia to regulate regular road transportation of passengers and  goods with China
Pashinyan: Armenia is at historically highest point of its well-beingPashinyan: Armenia is at historically highest point of its well-being
Fresh fruit and vegetable exports increased: Economy MinisterFresh fruit and vegetable exports increased: Economy Minister
RA Central Bank Governor: Banking system assets reach 109% of GDPRA Central Bank Governor: Banking system assets reach 109% of GDP
SRC: In January-July, taxi drivers issued a total of 57 million  receipts, amounting to  $16.9 millionSRC: In January-July, taxi drivers issued a total of 57 million  receipts, amounting to  $16.9 million
Cashback system for non-cash payments to be launched in Armenia in a  pilot modeCashback system for non-cash payments to be launched in Armenia in a  pilot mode
Armenia  preparing for international wine competition Mondial de  BruxellesArmenia  preparing for international wine competition Mondial de  Bruxelles
EFSD mission got acquainted with  construction of 32-km section of   Kajaran-Agarak road EFSD mission got acquainted with  construction of 32-km section of   Kajaran-Agarak road 
Ameriabank Leads Mortgage Market with More Than 22% ShareAmeriabank Leads Mortgage Market with More Than 22% Share
UNICEF and CyberHUB-AM launch first online platform in Armenia to  support children and adolescentsUNICEF and CyberHUB-AM launch first online platform in Armenia to  support children and adolescents
Armenia, Iraq exploring opportunities to restore direct flightsArmenia, Iraq exploring opportunities to restore direct flights
Next year, Tumo Center for Creative Technologies to open in UruguayNext year, Tumo Center for Creative Technologies to open in Uruguay
Armenian Card reports: Due to issues with Internet channels,  E-commerce transactions are unavailableArmenian Card reports: Due to issues with Internet channels,  E-commerce transactions are unavailable
Iraq proposes to establish joint committee with Armenian businessmen  to boost trade and economic relationsIraq proposes to establish joint committee with Armenian businessmen  to boost trade and economic relations
4th meeting of  Intergovernmental Commission on Economic Cooperation   held in Yerevan 4th meeting of  Intergovernmental Commission on Economic Cooperation   held in Yerevan 
Non-resident electronic services providers paid 3.1 billion drams in  VAT to Armenia`s state treasury-  SRC head Non-resident electronic services providers paid 3.1 billion drams in  VAT to Armenia`s state treasury-  SRC head 
So, who`s the one lying now: Rosselkhoznadzor  returned 21 trucks  with quarantine products to Armenia over  the past three daysSo, who`s the one lying now: Rosselkhoznadzor  returned 21 trucks  with quarantine products to Armenia over  the past three days
State support program for energy-efficient renovation in Armenia  concluded, with no plans for continuationState support program for energy-efficient renovation in Armenia  concluded, with no plans for continuation
12th Harvest Festival kicks off in Dzoraghbyur12th Harvest Festival kicks off in Dzoraghbyur
5 042 314 AMD to the Zark eco-camp. The August beneficiary of the Power of One Dram initiative is the Bridge of Hope NGO5 042 314 AMD to the Zark eco-camp. The August beneficiary of the Power of One Dram initiative is the Bridge of Hope NGO
Industrial price index weakened due to decline in industrial sector Industrial price index weakened due to decline in industrial sector 
Armenia`s economic growth slowed to 7% in January-July 2025, with a  41.4% decline in foreign tradeArmenia`s economic growth slowed to 7% in January-July 2025, with a  41.4% decline in foreign trade
In August, 2,427 trucks with export products from Armenia entered  Russia - Minister of EconomyIn August, 2,427 trucks with export products from Armenia entered  Russia - Minister of Economy
Luys Foundation: Armenian government continues to face challenges in  budget planningLuys Foundation: Armenian government continues to face challenges in  budget planning
RA President: Stable peace to open up huge economic potential for  ArmeniaRA President: Stable peace to open up huge economic potential for  Armenia
In Armenia`s interbank foreign exchange market from August 18 to 22,  2025, dollar transactions decreased while ruble increasedIn Armenia`s interbank foreign exchange market from August 18 to 22,  2025, dollar transactions decreased while ruble increased
Armenia, UNWTO discuss possible joint initiativesArmenia, UNWTO discuss possible joint initiatives
Construction of Kajaran-Agarak road proceeding at rapid pace - Road  Department FoundationConstruction of Kajaran-Agarak road proceeding at rapid pace - Road  Department Foundation
In Armenia, taxes collected in first 7 months of 2025 were 424.8  billion drams less than plannedIn Armenia, taxes collected in first 7 months of 2025 were 424.8  billion drams less than planned
Number of tourists in Armenia 2.5% down in Jan-July, 2025Number of tourists in Armenia 2.5% down in Jan-July, 2025
In the first half of 2025, Armenia`s GDP reached nearly $12 billion,  showing a decline in growthIn the first half of 2025, Armenia`s GDP reached nearly $12 billion,  showing a decline in growth
Pashinyan: State budget for 2026 does not provide for significant  increase in defense spendingPashinyan: State budget for 2026 does not provide for significant  increase in defense spending
Papoyan: Armenia actively diversifying  export destinations for  finished productsPapoyan: Armenia actively diversifying  export destinations for  finished products
Armenia becoming from labor-exporting country to destination for   migrants: PashinyanArmenia becoming from labor-exporting country to destination for   migrants: Pashinyan
Economy Minister: Armenia has no political issues with EAEUEconomy Minister: Armenia has no political issues with EAEU
School purchases are more profitable with Idram&IDBankSchool purchases are more profitable with Idram&IDBank
Online purchase and sale of real estate to take effect in Armenia Online purchase and sale of real estate to take effect in Armenia 
Armenia and Supermicro Consider Prospects for Cooperation in  Development of Digital InfrastructuresArmenia and Supermicro Consider Prospects for Cooperation in  Development of Digital Infrastructures
RA minister of economy hosts ODDO BHF financial group delegationRA minister of economy hosts ODDO BHF financial group delegation
Iran persuading us to more actively use logistics route: Russia,  Armenia, Iran and Persian Gulf - LukashenkoIran persuading us to more actively use logistics route: Russia,  Armenia, Iran and Persian Gulf - Lukashenko
Idram Junior: The best companion for your child Idram Junior: The best companion for your child 
Implementation of  agreements from 23rd meeting of Intergovernmental  Commission meeting and  bilateral cooperation agenda between Armenia  and Russia discussed in YerevanImplementation of  agreements from 23rd meeting of Intergovernmental  Commission meeting and  bilateral cooperation agenda between Armenia  and Russia discussed in Yerevan
Pashinyan, Overchuk discuss Armenia-Russia agenda mattersPashinyan, Overchuk discuss Armenia-Russia agenda matters
Armenian IT companies to participate in GITEX GLOBAL-2025 technology  exhibition in Dubai Armenian IT companies to participate in GITEX GLOBAL-2025 technology  exhibition in Dubai 
In the first half of 2025, Russia led in  transfers to Armenia, while  the UAE and Switzerland led in outflowsIn the first half of 2025, Russia led in  transfers to Armenia, while  the UAE and Switzerland led in outflows
Aram Sargsyan: Armenia has a real chance to become a regional NVIDIA  hubAram Sargsyan: Armenia has a real chance to become a regional NVIDIA  hub
Armenia`s Economy Minister announces increase in GDP growth Armenia`s Economy Minister announces increase in GDP growth 
Fitch Ratings: Armenia-Azerbaijan peace framework may support  positive credit trendsFitch Ratings: Armenia-Azerbaijan peace framework may support  positive credit trends
$176mln reimbursed to mortgage-holders under income tax reimbursement  program $176mln reimbursed to mortgage-holders under income tax reimbursement  program 
 Armenia`s exports of flowers, decorative products 88.7% up  Armenia`s exports of flowers, decorative products 88.7% up 
Armenian Prime Minister, Iranian President participate in  Armenian-Iranian business forum  in Yerevan Armenian Prime Minister, Iranian President participate in  Armenian-Iranian business forum  in Yerevan 
Yerevan, Tehran bring standards closer together: memorandum of  understanding signedYerevan, Tehran bring standards closer together: memorandum of  understanding signed
Minister: Construction of new Iran-Armenia power transmission line is  in its final stageMinister: Construction of new Iran-Armenia power transmission line is  in its final stage
Tehran, Yerevan agree to construct second border bridge - Iranian  officialTehran, Yerevan agree to construct second border bridge - Iranian  official
Read more
Exchange rates
29.08.2025
RUB4.76-0.01
USD382.52-0.45
EUR446.29-0.71
GBP514.87-2.98
CAD278.20-0.10
JPY25.99-0.08
CNY53.63-0.07
CHF476.66-2.41