Friday, August 23 2024 13:14
Naira Badalian

Arrest of businessmen for tax evasion to cause more harm to state -  businessman 

Arrest of businessmen for tax evasion to cause more harm to state -  businessman 

ArmInfo. The arrest of a businessman for tax evasion brings more harm to the state than good.  This point of view was expressed on a social network by the co-founder and head of the Union of Entrepreneurs  Vahram Mirakyan, once again touching upon the draft law proposed by  the State Revenue Committee of the Republic of Armenia to abolish incentive norms and establish stricter criminal liability for tax violations. 

Earlier, ArmInfo reported that the SRC, in particular, proposes to  recognize Part 5 of Article 290, which allows economic entities that  have committed violations to avoid criminal liability by paying the  amount, as invalid. The initiator proposed to establish punishment  for tax violations in the form of imprisonment for a term of 3 years  or more, in the event of violations amounting to 10 million drams or  more. The bill was met with extreme negative reactions from the  business community and expert circles.

Vahram Mirakyan insists that by arresting a businessman for tax  evasion, the State Revenue Committee harms the state.

After 2 months of detention and trial, the businessman pays the 100  million drams demanded by the State Revenue Committee, the State  Revenue Committee inspector receives his reward, and the businessman  is released from prison.

Then the businessman goes to court, proves that the tax violation was  20 million drams, not 80, and gets his money back. But the process  lasted 2 years, the tax inspector has long since received his  bonuses, moved to another job or went to Los Angeles to drive Uber>,  - Mirakyan noted.

Meanwhile, the head of the Union notes that a businessman cannot be  arrested for tax violations for a number of reasons. Firstly, the  only task of the tax inspector is to fulfill his plan (sometimes  there is also a corrupt interest), therefore the inspector is an  interested party and cannot be neutral, which is why the businessman  should not be arrested on the basis of the inspector's preliminary  tax calculation. Otherwise, the arrest turns into a blackmail tool in  the hands of an interested party - the inspector, who uses it in his  own interests and against the businessman. In addition, the arrest of  businessman X, who, for example, has 10 stores and paid taxes to the  state in the amount of 200 million drams per year, risks losing his  suppliers during the period of his detention, since the latter in  turn may refuse to supply him with goods due to fear of possible  bankruptcy of their counterparty. As a result, if earlier this  businessman paid 20 million drams in taxes every month, then due to  the problems that arose during the 2 months of the businessman's  arrest, the amount of the tax paid is reduced to 10 million drams per  month, and sometimes - even .  It also happens that  after such the business changes its mind about working  in Armenia and moves to another - freer country.

 

The point of the story is that the businessman creates benefits, and  we must help him with this, and if he made a mistake or deceived the  state, say, by 20 million drams, he will be obliged to pay an amount  of, say, 30 million, but on the basis of a court decision, and not  arrest without arrest, since in the latter case the state loses more  than those 20 million>, - Vahram Mirakyan summed up.

Responding to the concerns of the business community, the head of the  State Revenue Committee, Rustam Badasyan, in a conversation with  journalists the other day noted that due to the presence of this  article (Part 5 of Article 290 of the Criminal Code of the Republic  of Armenia - ed.), the competitive environment in the republic has  been undermined. , - asks Badasyan. 

In response to a remark about how fair it is to deprive citizens of  their freedom for a term of three years or more for a violation in  the amount of 10 million drams, the chief tax officer said: . At the same time, as Badasyan  noted, there is no criminal liability for accidental, technical and  unintentional errors, which many of the project's counterparts  .  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
The October beneficiary of The October beneficiary of "The Power of a Dram" is the Children of Armenia Fund
Head of Synopsys Armenia: IT sector accounts for 5.5% of Armenia`s  GDP, an indicator comparable to developed countries Head of Synopsys Armenia: IT sector accounts for 5.5% of Armenia`s  GDP, an indicator comparable to developed countries 
Armenian CB to establish control over nonpublic funds Armenian CB to establish control over nonpublic funds 
Armenia to take out loans to cover budget deficitArmenia to take out loans to cover budget deficit
Armenia`s deputy minister confirms his resignation Armenia`s deputy minister confirms his resignation 
Armenia`s deputy minister of economy resignsArmenia`s deputy minister of economy resigns
Top official in charge of energy sector dismissed Top official in charge of energy sector dismissed 
Garegin Baghramyan resigns as head of PSRCGaregin Baghramyan resigns as head of PSRC
Second Armenian-UAE business forum held in Abu DhabiSecond Armenian-UAE business forum held in Abu Dhabi
Wizz Air Group successfully promoted Armenia in international markets  - RA Ministry of EconomyWizz Air Group successfully promoted Armenia in international markets  - RA Ministry of Economy
AraratBank and Matenadaran: An Innovative Collaboration Across Science and CultureAraratBank and Matenadaran: An Innovative Collaboration Across Science and Culture
Armenian government approves import of 600 electric cars Armenian government approves import of 600 electric cars 
Armenian customs operation needs improving - official Armenian customs operation needs improving - official 
Taxi companies` turnover billions of drams - official Taxi companies` turnover billions of drams - official 
Simplified car registration procedure for forcibly displaced  Nagorno-Karabakh ArmeniansSimplified car registration procedure for forcibly displaced  Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians
Armenia`s vice-premier proposes recylcing fee for eletric cars Armenia`s vice-premier proposes recylcing fee for eletric cars 
AraratBank Allocates Over 6 Million Armenian drams to Innovative Ideas Over Two YearsAraratBank Allocates Over 6 Million Armenian drams to Innovative Ideas Over Two Years
"Synopsys" company among leaders of Armenia`s technology sector -  premier 
South Caucasus Railways reports 2.8% y/y increase in number of  passengers South Caucasus Railways reports 2.8% y/y increase in number of  passengers 
Balance of Attached Cards in the Idram&IDBank AppBalance of Attached Cards in the Idram&IDBank App
Funding for education, science, culture, and sport programs in  Armenia expected to rise by 5% in 2025Funding for education, science, culture, and sport programs in  Armenia expected to rise by 5% in 2025
Total healthcare expenditure in Armenia`s GDP to decrease in 2025Total healthcare expenditure in Armenia`s GDP to decrease in 2025
Converse Bank- Nelly Kocharyan: The exit of major foreign banks from  Armenia poses a new challenge for the country`s banking sector, as it  grapples with the issue of de-riskingConverse Bank- Nelly Kocharyan: The exit of major foreign banks from  Armenia poses a new challenge for the country`s banking sector, as it  grapples with the issue of de-risking
Ameriabank’s New Offer: Draw of Investment Portfolios for AMD 2MAmeriabank’s New Offer: Draw of Investment Portfolios for AMD 2M
Armenia`s Ministry of Finance on tax arrears and <optimization> of  budget expendituresArmenia`s Ministry of Finance on tax arrears and of  budget expenditures
Net investment flow into Armenian economy shifted from positive  $146.5 million to negative $91.3 millionNet investment flow into Armenian economy shifted from positive  $146.5 million to negative $91.3 million
Armenia Minister of Economy, Ambassador of Germany discuss  opportunities for enhancing bilateral cooperationArmenia Minister of Economy, Ambassador of Germany discuss  opportunities for enhancing bilateral cooperation
The winners of the 2024 joint program between SIA Armenia and The winners of the 2024 joint program between SIA Armenia and "The Power of One Dram" have been announced
WB, ADB collaborate on housing program for Nagorno-Karabakh IDPsWB, ADB collaborate on housing program for Nagorno-Karabakh IDPs
U.S remains dedicated to building economic resilience of Armenia -  ambassadorU.S remains dedicated to building economic resilience of Armenia -  ambassador
Armenia Deputy PM, World Bank discuss potential for enhancing  cooperationArmenia Deputy PM, World Bank discuss potential for enhancing  cooperation
Armenia`s industrial sector still experiencing double-digit growthArmenia`s industrial sector still experiencing double-digit growth
In January-August, electricity production in Armenia increased by  2.4%In January-August, electricity production in Armenia increased by  2.4%
Fixing over-ambitious and unrealistic goals most dangerous - expert Fixing over-ambitious and unrealistic goals most dangerous - expert 
Concept paper outlining creation of AI ecosystem global network to be  presented at  WCIT2024Concept paper outlining creation of AI ecosystem global network to be  presented at  WCIT2024
WCIT2024 officially launched with a focus on Artificial IntelligenceWCIT2024 officially launched with a focus on Artificial Intelligence
Ardshinbank started making international money transfers via UBPay systemArdshinbank started making international money transfers via UBPay system
Ameriabank - fintech partner of DigiTec2024Ameriabank - fintech partner of DigiTec2024
AraratBank Expands International Transfer Options with Golden Money SystemAraratBank Expands International Transfer Options with Golden Money System
10% idcoin with IDBank Mastercard cards10% idcoin with IDBank Mastercard cards
Armenia expects participation of French companies in implementation  of nuclear and renewable energy projects - PashinyanArmenia expects participation of French companies in implementation  of nuclear and renewable energy projects - Pashinyan
12.5% y/y increase in state budget revenues of Armenia in Jan-Sep  202412.5% y/y increase in state budget revenues of Armenia in Jan-Sep  2024
DigiTec2024 officially launched, with over 200 companies presenting  their innovative solutionsDigiTec2024 officially launched, with over 200 companies presenting  their innovative solutions
ACE interested in cooperating with Armenia in wine-makingACE interested in cooperating with Armenia in wine-making
Annual inflation in Armenia in September amounted to 0.6%Annual inflation in Armenia in September amounted to 0.6%
Armenian startups will have the opportunity to receive investments  from the foundation of the legendary Argentine footballer Lionel  MessiArmenian startups will have the opportunity to receive investments  from the foundation of the legendary Argentine footballer Lionel  Messi
More and more young people in Armenia dreaming of becoming nuclear  engineers More and more young people in Armenia dreaming of becoming nuclear  engineers 
Armenia improves its position in Global Innovation Index -2024Armenia improves its position in Global Innovation Index -2024
Ameriabank’s Special Offer for New Mastercard Holders.  1% Cashback and Lots of GiftsAmeriabank’s Special Offer for New Mastercard Holders. 1% Cashback and Lots of Gifts
Double-digit growth of import prices observed in Armenia`s foreign  tradeDouble-digit growth of import prices observed in Armenia`s foreign  trade
532.5mln transactions worth a total of AMD 9,782.7bln  effected in  Armenia in Jan-Sept 2024532.5mln transactions worth a total of AMD 9,782.7bln  effected in  Armenia in Jan-Sept 2024
We are conservative in making forecasts - ADB We are conservative in making forecasts - ADB 
Armenia takes over chairmanship of coordinating council of CIS  financial supervision bodies Armenia takes over chairmanship of coordinating council of CIS  financial supervision bodies 
Bakhytjan Sagintayev: Since the formation of the EAEU, the Union`s  foreign trade grown by 60%Bakhytjan Sagintayev: Since the formation of the EAEU, the Union`s  foreign trade grown by 60%
Cryptocurrency actively and uncontrollably cashed in ArmeniaCryptocurrency actively and uncontrollably cashed in Armenia
Armenia`s first regional landfill to be completed in HrazdanArmenia`s first regional landfill to be completed in Hrazdan
Mohammad Reza Aref: Iran is ready to play a more serious role in the  EAEUMohammad Reza Aref: Iran is ready to play a more serious role in the  EAEU
Mishustin: It is important to create single transport space, develop  international logistics corridors and establish appropriate  infrastructureMishustin: It is important to create single transport space, develop  international logistics corridors and establish appropriate  infrastructure
EEC to sign joint action plan with Uzbekistan for 2024-2026EEC to sign joint action plan with Uzbekistan for 2024-2026
RA government proposes granting new functions to Military-Industrial  CommitteeRA government proposes granting new functions to Military-Industrial  Committee
Read more
Exchange rates
11.10.2024
RUB4.030.06
USD387.170.02
EUR423.33-0.17
GBP505.68-1.14
CAD281.27-0.56
JPY25.97-0.04
CNY54.780.07
CHF451.250.24