Tuesday, February 7 2017 17:50

Banks and economy: multi-directionality with claim to growth

Banks and economy: multi-directionality with claim to growth

ArmInfo. ArmInfo. The preliminary results of 2016 fixed on the banks’ balance sheets inspire hope for recovery of the general economic situation in the country in 2017. In an interview with NEWS.am, AmRating head, ArmInfo News Agency director general Emmanuil Mkrtchyan says that the data on the banking system of the country have proved to be beyond expectations and demonstrate gradual expansion of lending that contributes to growth of economic activity.      

What makes you think that in 2017 the Armenian economy will start overcoming the crisis?

As a matter of fact, one cannot yet say that the country is overcoming the economic crisis because we deal with a too low base and we should pass a certain path, after which it will be possible to speak of creation of prerequisites for a way out of the current economic stagnation. The results of the Armenian banking system activities demonstrate such prerequisites. I mean the vivid and tangible imbalance between the economic activity of Armenia in 2016 (0.5%) and the significant growth of the banking system’s main indicators. Such imbalances are quite justified under conditions of a low base and unbalanced structure of our economy. However, the figures speak for themselves. Look. The GDP growth slackened from 3.1% to 0.5% in 2015, the important indicator of the banks’ lending grew from 1.1% to 16%.We seem to have come across a paradox, but facts remain facts. After all, the banking system is a litmus test of the economy, figuratively speaking. If as compared to 2015, a significant increase in lending was fixed last year, with a certain time lag this active lending should be partially reflected in the economic activity indicators. Thus, speaking about the interdependence of the banking system heath and the economy in general, one can say that the former can in some way become the harbinger of the latter’s condition.

Unfortunately, we have not yet got such an important indicator as the investment position of the banking sector. In addition, the loan book is preliminary – “the wheat is not separated from the chaff”. Nevertheless, the growth of the lending indicator is so tangible that it leaves no doubt whatsoever. In 2016 the aggregate lending of the banks exceeded 2.5 trillion AMD or 5.2 bln USD. It is an essential figure. 

Isn’t this growth of the loan book explained with the banks’ merger in 2016?

Certainly, I think the system consolidation process has had a relevant effect on the overall growth of the forex balance of some banks , but this could not be the main driver of such a significant increase in the aggregate loan book. This conclusion is also suggested by the fact that not all players had to replenish their capital because their capital was sufficient and not all of them participated in mergers and acquisitions, due to which the number of the banks in the country dropped from 21 to 17. Here one can speak about both organic and quite successful and significant growth and growth related to the consolidation process in one way or another. In both cases the banking system has worked splendidly.

For instance, one can point at the dynamics of Ameriabank, which has taken the lead in the market in terms of all indicators amid organic growth. The growth of the bank's assets made up 39.2% with the growth of lending being 63.6%. At the same time, the general liabilities increased by 43.2%, while time deposits and call liabilities rose by 41%. To answer the question how effectively the bank worked on the credit market, one can take one indicator for a rough estimate – the matter concerns the level of generation of interest income. It makes up almost 80% of the bank’s total income, with a nearly 20% year-over-year growth. Over the past year the bank’s lending amounted to 501.4 billion drams, or $ 1.04 billion. It should be noted for comparison that a year earlier, in 2015 the growth was less tangible: the assets increased by only 29%, and the loan book - by 12.4%.

These indicators are very important if we talk about the condition of the loan market.  It is especially important to take into account that for the first time over the crisis-affected years the growth dynamics of interest income of Armenian banks, that is, the income received from lending began to return to its normal course. That is to say, this dynamics stopped to yield to the growth dynamics of interest expenses. Thus, the profitability loss risk, which has been exacerbated amid the credit market shrinkage in the crisis situation, has weakened. Of course, not all the banks were able to overcome this situation, which threatened to put them into a trap in the course of time, but most of them managed to overcome this situation.

Has a new pool of the major banks been determined after the consolidation? Have the roles been redistributed in the system?

I do not like to talk on this topic because I think it is wrong to say the larger the bank, the reliable it is. The US giants that exploded in 2009 are a bright example of it. Therefore, it is necessary to speak of the banks with the highest level of assets. Though, looking through the preliminary statistics, I can only say that due to the CB requirement to ensure a six-fold increase in the minimum regulatory capital by 1 Jan 2017 to 30 bln AMD, Armenia got rid of the conditional concept of “small banks”. These banks were most risk-affected. The CB predicted further deterioration of the economic environment in the country and took a decision to oblige the banks’ shareholders to increase the liquidity. This was very important for our small and weak economy, which needed to be protected against emergency situations. At the same time, the country came across reputation-related expenses. Some investors - German ProCredit Bank and Russian Gazprombank - had to sell their shares and leave the country. These are serious losses. On the other hand, obvious outsiders have left the market by being acquired by stronger, aggressive and healthy players. When the number of banks is 17, one cannot worry about deterioration of the competitive environment in the sector of banking services.

It is very important that the pool of the banking system leaders has not changed after the consolidation. I spoke of Ameriabank, which is a leader and has the highest indicators. But Ardshinbank, which is another large bank, follows Ameriabank too closely. Ardshinbank ensured double – both organic, by tangibly increasing its indices due to an active credit policy and through actual acquisition of Areximbank-Gazprombank Group. The transactions will strengthen Ardshinbank’s positions on the market, increase the level of asset diversification and give new customers to the bank. By the way, the fight for corporate customers has become the key strategic line for the system over the past 5 years. The economy stagnation hinders emergence of new economic entities in the country, therefore it is the seizure of the customer base rather than the balance sheet of the acquired bank that has become the driver of merger transactions. As a result, the total capital of the bank grew to 54 bln AMD. In 2016 Ardshinbank’s assets increased by 26% to 504.7 bln AMD and the loan book grew by 23% to 337.7 bln AMD. The total liabilities rose by 28% and the total deposits – by 23%.

Can we say that these two banks are currently the pillars of our banking system?  

Probably, you are guided by the structure of the Russian banking system, which is actually based on three state-controlled giants. Armenia lacks such banking pillars and I think it would be wrong for our country. The economy structure is different and the cash flow sources are also different. Traditionally, analysts speak of top five banks, with ArmBusinessBank, ACBA Credit Agricole Bank and Anelik Bank being the third, the fourth and the fifth on that list. But this classification is conventional. Any bank has its strong and weak sides. I do not think I should name the other banks, which operated quite successfully in 2016. I think everyone can look through the statistics. The most important thing is that the banking system of the country should get rid of the “problematic” banks hindering the system’s recovery.

As I have already mentioned, due to the process of consolidation, Armenia has two groups of banks – conventionally “large” and conventionally “medium-sized”. The latter contains banks, whose shareholders should look for their own niches on the market. Otherwise, these banks will also shortly have to leave the market.

So, you think the consolidation process is not over, don’t you?

Yes, I do. Let me explain why. When the decision on the new capital standard was being taken, the country’s economy was not brilliant, but it was far from being in the depressive condition it got into due to the lack of development-oriented reforms and “thanks to” the new external shocks. The matter concerns unprecedented drop of foreign investments and domestic capital investments, as well as unprecedented decline of foreign transfers. The decrease of the aggregate demand and consumer expenses as well as other negative factors considerably reduced the margin of banking operations and decreased the yield. The lending market kept “breathing”, but the success mostly depended on “the lung volume”. The CB staked on that. The banks that lacked relevant niches on the market and lacked poorly diversified operations came across certain difficulties and started yielding their positions to the larger players. So, the process of mergers and acquisitions is not over. At least three-four more banks may leave the market. It is a matter of price. It would simply be unprofitable to sell a bank in the depressive year 2016. It would be easier to replenish the total regulatory capital with subordinated loans for instance than to sell the bank at a low price. As soon as the situation in the economy stabilizes, we will witness new transactions.

It is no wonder that despite the tangible growth in liabilities and assets and first of all lending, the net profit of the banking system in 2016 dropped by 29.9%. In Q4 2016 alone, this indicator fell by 82.1% versus Q4 2015 given that the balance sheets got rid of toxic loans. Thus, things are not unambiguous though they seem to be stable and reliable.


News
US$30m OPEC Fund loan to Ameriabank to promote sustainable energy and support small businesses in ArmeniaUS$30m OPEC Fund loan to Ameriabank to promote sustainable energy and support small businesses in Armenia
One Success Story: Trimming the SpiritsOne Success Story: Trimming the Spirits
EDB projects 2.9% growth in aggregate GDP of Bank`s member states in  2022EDB projects 2.9% growth in aggregate GDP of Bank`s member states in  2022
Representatives of Trade Mission of RF and EFSD discuss financing of  investment projects in Armenia and support for Russian exportersRepresentatives of Trade Mission of RF and EFSD discuss financing of  investment projects in Armenia and support for Russian exporters
4.3% year-on-year increase in economic activity in Armenia in  Jan-Oct, 20214.3% year-on-year increase in economic activity in Armenia in  Jan-Oct, 2021
New operator of Meghri FEZ plans to build a food packaging plantNew operator of Meghri FEZ plans to build a food packaging plant
Government subsidies to Syunik region reached 1.1 billion drams Government subsidies to Syunik region reached 1.1 billion drams 
Armenian authorities consider building three more bypass roads in  Syunik regionArmenian authorities consider building three more bypass roads in  Syunik region
Armenian government approves signing of Agreement on navigation seals  in EAEUArmenian government approves signing of Agreement on navigation seals  in EAEU
Contract for Kaps reservoir construction put out to tenderContract for Kaps reservoir construction put out to tender
VPOS number steadily increasing in Armenia  VPOS number steadily increasing in Armenia  
Non-cash plastic transactions continue to gain momentum; 30%  threshold in total volume has already been passedNon-cash plastic transactions continue to gain momentum; 30%  threshold in total volume has already been passed
Armenia to acquire a loan of 20 million euros for modernization of  urban land transportArmenia to acquire a loan of 20 million euros for modernization of  urban land transport
Russian company won tender on Ajapnyak subway station development  project: Yerevan Mayor hopes earliest possible financing of projectRussian company won tender on Ajapnyak subway station development  project: Yerevan Mayor hopes earliest possible financing of project
Black Friday CashBack from Converse BankBlack Friday CashBack from Converse Bank
Armenian-Belarusian Economic Cooperation Commission to meet in Minsk  Armenian-Belarusian Economic Cooperation Commission to meet in Minsk  
2.621mln plastic cards in Armenia`s banking market 2.621mln plastic cards in Armenia`s banking market 
Armenia, Belarus study prospects for cooperation in organic  agricultureArmenia, Belarus study prospects for cooperation in organic  agriculture
Mher Grigoryan, Sergei Glazyev discuss main areas of cooperation  within EAEUMher Grigoryan, Sergei Glazyev discuss main areas of cooperation  within EAEU
Macroeconomic Research Centre at Financial Research Institute of RF  ready to assist RA Economy Ministry Macroeconomic Research Centre at Financial Research Institute of RF  ready to assist RA Economy Ministry 
Delegation of RA Economy to get acquainted with peculiarities of  operations with precious metals and stones in Bishkek within EAEUDelegation of RA Economy to get acquainted with peculiarities of  operations with precious metals and stones in Bishkek within EAEU
Armenia can be a major exporter of intellectual property and software  - Chi-Foon ChanArmenia can be a major exporter of intellectual property and software  - Chi-Foon Chan
Bank loans in all member-states to be available to all EAEU citizens Bank loans in all member-states to be available to all EAEU citizens 
Armenia most important EAEU member - Ilya Malkina Armenia most important EAEU member - Ilya Malkina 
How to escape the “black” side of Black Friday?  Some tips from Converse BankHow to escape the “black” side of Black Friday?  Some tips from Converse Bank
Allow yourself more: Rocket line - the leading Armenian Allow yourself more: Rocket line - the leading Armenian "Buy now, pay later" payment format from Idram&IDBank digital platform
On November 24-27, Yerevan will host 1st International Trade and  Industrial Exhibition On November 24-27, Yerevan will host 1st International Trade and  Industrial Exhibition "Eurasia 2021" and Eurasian Business Forum 
ICAO and IATA provide identification codes to FLYONE ARMENIA ICAO and IATA provide identification codes to FLYONE ARMENIA 
Pashinyan: Armenia registered stable growth rates of trade with the  EEU countriesPashinyan: Armenia registered stable growth rates of trade with the  EEU countries
New foil annealing mode reduces scrapNew foil annealing mode reduces scrap
Ameriabank to start distribution of $8mln USD tranche bonds on Nov.  25 Ameriabank to start distribution of $8mln USD tranche bonds on Nov.  25 
 One Success Story: When the idea turns into reality One Success Story: When the idea turns into reality
Investments in Armenia`s communities nearly $400mln since 2018 -  premier Investments in Armenia`s communities nearly $400mln since 2018 -  premier 
Minister of Economy: A number of Iranian companies are ready to  invest in FEZ Minister of Economy: A number of Iranian companies are ready to  invest in FEZ "Meghri"
Armenia exempts imports of electric vehicles from VAT for another two  yearsArmenia exempts imports of electric vehicles from VAT for another two  years
Armenian government approves its program of activities for 2021-2026Armenian government approves its program of activities for 2021-2026
Mutual investments in Eurasia reaches US $46 billionMutual investments in Eurasia reaches US $46 billion
$72.5 million to be available to Armenia after IMF Board meeting in  Dec $72.5 million to be available to Armenia after IMF Board meeting in  Dec 
Armenia s government revising GDP growth forecast Armenia s government revising GDP growth forecast 
I am proud of our participation in the project that helped make the  Armenian nuclear power plant safer and more efficient - Rosatom  Director GeneralI am proud of our participation in the project that helped make the  Armenian nuclear power plant safer and more efficient - Rosatom  Director General
About 10% of budget expenditures to be directed to serve government  debt in 2022About 10% of budget expenditures to be directed to serve government  debt in 2022
Extension of NPP operation until 2036 mere desire yet - Ashot  Martirosyan Extension of NPP operation until 2036 mere desire yet - Ashot  Martirosyan 
RA Finance Ministry: By the end of 2022, government debt will decrease by 0.6 p.p. - from 60.8% at the end of 2021 to 60.2%RA Finance Ministry: By the end of 2022, government debt will decrease by 0.6 p.p. - from 60.8% at the end of 2021 to 60.2%
From July 1, 2022, gradual abolition of income tax refund system for  mortgage loan starts in YerevanFrom July 1, 2022, gradual abolition of income tax refund system for  mortgage loan starts in Yerevan
Armenia`s Ministry of Economy, UNIDO sign Country Programme for  Inclusive and Sustainable Industrial DevelopmentArmenia`s Ministry of Economy, UNIDO sign Country Programme for  Inclusive and Sustainable Industrial Development
PM Pashinyan, representatives of IT companies discuss public-private  cooperation prospectsPM Pashinyan, representatives of IT companies discuss public-private  cooperation prospects
Armenia will switch to a new energy model from February 2022Armenia will switch to a new energy model from February 2022
Agreement on Technical and Economic Cooperation between Armenia and  China signed in YerevanAgreement on Technical and Economic Cooperation between Armenia and  China signed in Yerevan
Armenia considers possibilities of expanding economic cooperation  with California StateArmenia considers possibilities of expanding economic cooperation  with California State
World Bank assesses action plan of RA government for solving set  tasks: Anna BjerdeWorld Bank assesses action plan of RA government for solving set  tasks: Anna Bjerde
Deputy Prime Minister received Vice President of World Bank Deputy Prime Minister received Vice President of World Bank 
Armenia, Switzerland to abolish dual income and property tax taxationArmenia, Switzerland to abolish dual income and property tax taxation
Armenian-Iranian annual trade turnover could reach $1bln, ambassador  says Armenian-Iranian annual trade turnover could reach $1bln, ambassador  says 
New business lending product from Converse BankNew business lending product from Converse Bank
ACBA Bank shows highest number of shareholders in Armenia`s banking  sectorACBA Bank shows highest number of shareholders in Armenia`s banking  sector
Armenia to stop being GSP+ beneficiary from next Jan Armenia to stop being GSP+ beneficiary from next Jan 
Italy interested in discussing, implementing new investment programs  with Armenia, ambassador says Italy interested in discussing, implementing new investment programs  with Armenia, ambassador says 
Investments in solar power station in Vaiots Dzor, greenhouse  facility in Kotayk to total AMD 4bln Investments in solar power station in Vaiots Dzor, greenhouse  facility in Kotayk to total AMD 4bln 
Anapa to implement $500,000 investment projects in ArmeniaAnapa to implement $500,000 investment projects in Armenia
Campaign Winners of Converse Bank Got Gold BarsCampaign Winners of Converse Bank Got Gold Bars
Read more


Exchange rates
26.11.2021
RUB6.38-0.06
USD483.072.85
EUR544.185.23
GBP643.162.83
CAD378.64-0.56
JPY42.370.73
CNY75.560.50
CHF521.286.85