Monday, March 12 2018 18:17
Naira Badalian

Expert: The biggest gap in procurement legislation is the lack of an institution for accountability for its violation

Expert: The biggest gap in procurement legislation is the lack of an institution for accountability for its violation

ArmInfo. Procurement experts in Armenia believe that the proposals approved by the Government of Armenia for reforming the procurement system are generally acceptable.  "The ideas themselves are more progressive than the current ones, but we can say that the discussions of the Ministry of Finance with public organizations did not give anything, as the proposals of independent experts remained on paper," the head of the public programs said in an interview with ArmInfo organization "Anti-Corruption Center Transparency International" Varuzhan Oktanyan and Chairman of the Association of Procurement Specialists of Armenia Arsen Hambardzumyan.

According to the representative of Transparency International, it turned out that after discussions with representatives of public organizations, the Ministry of Finance passed proposals for the approval of the government, which he himself initiated. At a single meeting with representatives of the public, the Ministry presented a ready-made project related to the establishment of clearly regulated terms for the review and evaluation of applications, the minimum deadlines for the implementation of the contract. The Ministry of Finance also refused such an instrument to secure the application, as unilateral application of fines against companies that violated the rules of tenders with the amount of state purchases up to 70 million drams.  These innovations, as they noted, are welcomed by the expert community, and the need for them has ripened long ago.  Nevertheless, according to experts, in the current order of procurement organization there are a number of controversial points. In this regard, during the discussions "Anti-Corruption Center Transparency International" and NGO "Association of Procurement Specialists of Armenia" made a number of proposals that were not reflected in the final document. In particular, it was proposed to establish a requirement to secure bids ranging from 2% to 5% of the initial value of the contract, rather than 5% of the bidder's bid, which gives rise to certain abuses. Experts also insisted that the refusal to accept applications be specifically justified, while excluding the possibility of further adjustments. "These and other written comments were ignored without any explanation," said Arsen Armbartsumian.  According to Hamardzumyan, at the end of 2016, when adopting the law "On Procurement", the RA Ministry of Finance set the goal to bring its domestic legislation into line with international obligations.  Nevertheless, the process of harmonization was carried out with serious omissions, as a result of which the adoption of the new law did not make the process fairer. In particular, the electronic platform armeps.am, which is designed to provide equal competitive conditions for all participants of the process due to its publicity and accessibility, in fact does not work in full force, since it does not conduct periodic independent audit of information security, because the human factor nobody canceled it.  The Institute of Disclosure of Real Business Owners, according to experts, is also not able to carry out its mission - to identify the affiliation of the company with a government official or a member of the evaluation commission, if there are no clear mechanisms for verifying the information specified in the application of the company participating in the tender. "It turns out that you have to trust the participant's honest word, since, as a rule, he fills in the full name of the executive director or the main shareholder, but there are no mechanisms, as a result of lack of political will," Varujan Oktanian said. In addition, he does not see the availability of adequate resources from law enforcement agencies, the Commission on Ethics of Senior Officials (which from April will be transformed into the Anti-Corruption Commission), which is entrusted with the status of this issue.

Experts also question the Council's mandate to appeal against procurement. Despite the fact that it is declared as an independent and impartial body, the Ministry of Finance is responsible for ensuring its functioning and the Council itself works as a ministry building. In addition, there are shortcomings associated with the lack of organizational and legal status of the Council. "The biggest gap between the former and current legislation in the sphere of procurement is the absence of an institution of responsibility for violation of the legislation by the participants in the process." Under such conditions, however perfect the procurement legislation, it will be violated, "concluded economist Arsen Hambardzumyan.

READ ALL COMMENTS

Արսեն Համբարձումյան
Հայերենից ռուսերեն սխալ թարգմանելուց հետո գոնե հայերեն տարբերակում հարցերի և պատասխանների բնօրինակը դրեք, ոչ թե նորից սխալ ռուսերենից հայերեն թարգմանեք։ Իմ տված բոլոր պատասխանները աղավաղվել են և ներկայացվել են անիմաստ մտքեր։

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
WB approves new EUR 92.3 million loan to promote Green, Resilient and  Inclusive Development in ArmeniaWB approves new EUR 92.3 million loan to promote Green, Resilient and  Inclusive Development in Armenia
Inflow of private transfers from Russia to Armenia continues to  increase significantlyInflow of private transfers from Russia to Armenia continues to  increase significantly
AmCham introducing new standards into Armenia`s business culture -  Vahan KerobyanAmCham introducing new standards into Armenia`s business culture -  Vahan Kerobyan
Armenia, Brazil to strengthen trade and economic tiesArmenia, Brazil to strengthen trade and economic ties
Armenia to get EUR 92.3mln WB loan for budget deficit coverage Armenia to get EUR 92.3mln WB loan for budget deficit coverage 
Amazon Web Service to assist Armenia in old film digitizationAmazon Web Service to assist Armenia in old film digitization
Ameriabank honored as the Best Investment Bank in Armenia for 2023 by Global Finance Ameriabank honored as the Best Investment Bank in Armenia for 2023 by Global Finance 
Expert: Expenditures of Dry Port project exceed $100 millionExpert: Expenditures of Dry Port project exceed $100 million
Armenia Securities Exchange launches AMXTrader new trading system for  financial market participantsArmenia Securities Exchange launches AMXTrader new trading system for  financial market participants
Armenia`s economic indicators impressive in 2022 - IFC Armenia`s economic indicators impressive in 2022 - IFC 
Armenia welcomes Belarusian construction companies Armenia welcomes Belarusian construction companies 
FlyOne Armenia launches Yerevan - Larnaca - Yerevan direct flights FlyOne Armenia launches Yerevan - Larnaca - Yerevan direct flights 
Vahan Kerobyan: AMD 40 billion were returned to borrowers under 2022  state subsidy program for mortgage loansVahan Kerobyan: AMD 40 billion were returned to borrowers under 2022  state subsidy program for mortgage loans
Armenian winemakers participating in ProWein international trade fair  in DusseldorfArmenian winemakers participating in ProWein international trade fair  in Dusseldorf
Armenia`s vice-premier receives IMF repsArmenia`s vice-premier receives IMF reps
Armenia`s premier hosts IMF delegationArmenia`s premier hosts IMF delegation
Armenia`s Ministry of Economy draft law to introduce English law  jurisdiction - minister Armenia`s Ministry of Economy draft law to introduce English law  jurisdiction - minister 
U.S., Canadian and European companies interested in projects in  Armenia`s Syunik - Paruyr HovhannisyanU.S., Canadian and European companies interested in projects in  Armenia`s Syunik - Paruyr Hovhannisyan
Enterprise Armenia supporting 40 projects worth $2.4-3.2bln - premier Enterprise Armenia supporting 40 projects worth $2.4-3.2bln - premier 
In 2022 vs. 2021, number of RA citizens on migration registration in  RF decreased by 15% - ACSESIn 2022 vs. 2021, number of RA citizens on migration registration in  RF decreased by 15% - ACSES
Deputy PM, AmCham representatives discuss Russian-Ukrainian conflict  impact on Armenian economyDeputy PM, AmCham representatives discuss Russian-Ukrainian conflict  impact on Armenian economy
Armenia, Georgia discuss possibilities of expanding cooperation in  tourism sectorArmenia, Georgia discuss possibilities of expanding cooperation in  tourism sector
Rostelecom changes its mind about selling its Armenian subsidiary GNC  AlfaRostelecom changes its mind about selling its Armenian subsidiary GNC  Alfa
Yerevan hosts 19th International Specialized Caucasus Exhibition:  Building and Reconstruction EXPO 2023 Yerevan hosts 19th International Specialized Caucasus Exhibition:  Building and Reconstruction EXPO 2023 
Armenia`s Deputy Minister of Economy hosts UNCCD delegation  Armenia`s Deputy Minister of Economy hosts UNCCD delegation  
Threshold for duty-free importation of goods into EAEU for  individuals at level of EUR 1000 may return to previous level Threshold for duty-free importation of goods into EAEU for  individuals at level of EUR 1000 may return to previous level 
Saudi Flynas airline to launch flight to Yerevan in summerSaudi Flynas airline to launch flight to Yerevan in summer
Vahan Kerobyan: Turkey actively buys gold from Armenia, while  selectively buying other productsVahan Kerobyan: Turkey actively buys gold from Armenia, while  selectively buying other products
CBA Head: Surveys show that international visitors have begun making  long-term plans for Armenia and its economyCBA Head: Surveys show that international visitors have begun making  long-term plans for Armenia and its economy
Central Bank Head: FAO index has stabilized and there are no new  upward trendsCentral Bank Head: FAO index has stabilized and there are no new  upward trends
Martin Galstyan: Armenia Securities Exchange is currently in process  of forming new board and strategyMartin Galstyan: Armenia Securities Exchange is currently in process  of forming new board and strategy
CBA improves its 2023 GDP growth forecast for Armenia to 5.8%,  indicating construction and services as main driversCBA improves its 2023 GDP growth forecast for Armenia to 5.8%,  indicating construction and services as main drivers
Western sanctions against Russia pose a threat to Armenia - PMWestern sanctions against Russia pose a threat to Armenia - PM
New Armenia-ADB cooperation strategy under developmentNew Armenia-ADB cooperation strategy under development
AraratBank joins the United Nations Women`s Empowerment Principles InitiativeAraratBank joins the United Nations Women`s Empowerment Principles Initiative
Armenia`s CB leaves refinancing rate unchanged, 10.75%Armenia`s CB leaves refinancing rate unchanged, 10.75%
With organizational support of Ameriabank and SPRING PR, first  With organizational support of Ameriabank and SPRING PR, first  "Doing Digital-Exploring Digital Future" forum to be held in Yerevan  on April 5
Armenia, Egypt discuss possible cooperation in renewable energy,  energy infrastructuresArmenia, Egypt discuss possible cooperation in renewable energy,  energy infrastructures
 State Control Service returned about 121 million drams to budget in  2022 State Control Service returned about 121 million drams to budget in  2022
Vahan Kerobyan: No outflow of immigrants is expected in near futureVahan Kerobyan: No outflow of immigrants is expected in near future
Vahan Kerobyan: During the year, 7,328 companies and individual  entrepreneurs were registered in Armenia by Russian citizensVahan Kerobyan: During the year, 7,328 companies and individual  entrepreneurs were registered in Armenia by Russian citizens
This year, demand is gradually stabilizing, and growth of Armenian  economy to be 4.2% - EDBThis year, demand is gradually stabilizing, and growth of Armenian  economy to be 4.2% - EDB
Global economic recession risks remain significant - EDBGlobal economic recession risks remain significant - EDB
"MTS Armenia" changes its owner
Armenia`s former premier records absolute decline in population`s  living standards for 2018-2022Armenia`s former premier records absolute decline in population`s  living standards for 2018-2022
Armenia on way to modernization of major branches of its economy -  vice-premierArmenia on way to modernization of major branches of its economy -  vice-premier
Karen Karamyan: 70% of Ameriabank`s business loans are provided  through Ameria Business online platformKaren Karamyan: 70% of Ameriabank`s business loans are provided  through Ameria Business online platform
Ameriabank`s cosmic pavilion at DigiTec: Digital services,  consultations, lotteries, charity, discussionsAmeriabank`s cosmic pavilion at DigiTec: Digital services,  consultations, lotteries, charity, discussions
Armenia plans to start negotiations with India to raise funds for  construction project of Persian Gulf-Black Sea corridorArmenia plans to start negotiations with India to raise funds for  construction project of Persian Gulf-Black Sea corridor
Hayk Yesayan: Team always has and will have innovative solutionsHayk Yesayan: Team always has and will have innovative solutions
IDBank - participant of DigiTec ExpoIDBank - participant of DigiTec Expo
Armenia`s GDP growth in 2018-2022 qualitatively significantly lower  than in previous 3 five-year plans - Hrant BagratyanArmenia`s GDP growth in 2018-2022 qualitatively significantly lower  than in previous 3 five-year plans - Hrant Bagratyan
Team Telecom Armenia is first among Armenia`s telecom operators to  provide access to 5G networkTeam Telecom Armenia is first among Armenia`s telecom operators to  provide access to 5G network
Vahan Kerobyan: Armenian companies do not fully exploit opportunities  in innovative termsVahan Kerobyan: Armenian companies do not fully exploit opportunities  in innovative terms
U.S. warning against countries` help to Russia: Armenia`s government  takes everything into account - MPU.S. warning against countries` help to Russia: Armenia`s government  takes everything into account - MP
3.5% decline in living standard of average statistical employee in  Armenia 3.5% decline in living standard of average statistical employee in  Armenia 
Turkey suddenly stops  transit of sanctioned goods to RussiaTurkey suddenly stops  transit of sanctioned goods to Russia
American SADA to contribute to digitalization of Armenian education  systemAmerican SADA to contribute to digitalization of Armenian education  system
Armenia`s rank fell by 19 points in WIPO Global Innovation Index.  Economist advises to update data on timeArmenia`s rank fell by 19 points in WIPO Global Innovation Index.  Economist advises to update data on time
Armenia`s travel agencies lost 25% of income in 2022 due to dram  revaluationArmenia`s travel agencies lost 25% of income in 2022 due to dram  revaluation
Read more


Exchange rates
27.03.2023
RUB5.080.01
USD388.530.46
EUR418.372.20
GBP476.383.05
CAD283.041.46
JPY29.56-0.32
CNY56.54-0.22
CHF424.112.80