Monday, March 12 2018 18:17
Naira Badalian

Expert: The biggest gap in procurement legislation is the lack of an institution for accountability for its violation

Expert: The biggest gap in procurement legislation is the lack of an institution for accountability for its violation

ArmInfo. Procurement experts in Armenia believe that the proposals approved by the Government of Armenia for reforming the procurement system are generally acceptable.  "The ideas themselves are more progressive than the current ones, but we can say that the discussions of the Ministry of Finance with public organizations did not give anything, as the proposals of independent experts remained on paper," the head of the public programs said in an interview with ArmInfo organization "Anti-Corruption Center Transparency International" Varuzhan Oktanyan and Chairman of the Association of Procurement Specialists of Armenia Arsen Hambardzumyan.

According to the representative of Transparency International, it turned out that after discussions with representatives of public organizations, the Ministry of Finance passed proposals for the approval of the government, which he himself initiated. At a single meeting with representatives of the public, the Ministry presented a ready-made project related to the establishment of clearly regulated terms for the review and evaluation of applications, the minimum deadlines for the implementation of the contract. The Ministry of Finance also refused such an instrument to secure the application, as unilateral application of fines against companies that violated the rules of tenders with the amount of state purchases up to 70 million drams.  These innovations, as they noted, are welcomed by the expert community, and the need for them has ripened long ago.  Nevertheless, according to experts, in the current order of procurement organization there are a number of controversial points. In this regard, during the discussions "Anti-Corruption Center Transparency International" and NGO "Association of Procurement Specialists of Armenia" made a number of proposals that were not reflected in the final document. In particular, it was proposed to establish a requirement to secure bids ranging from 2% to 5% of the initial value of the contract, rather than 5% of the bidder's bid, which gives rise to certain abuses. Experts also insisted that the refusal to accept applications be specifically justified, while excluding the possibility of further adjustments. "These and other written comments were ignored without any explanation," said Arsen Armbartsumian.  According to Hamardzumyan, at the end of 2016, when adopting the law "On Procurement", the RA Ministry of Finance set the goal to bring its domestic legislation into line with international obligations.  Nevertheless, the process of harmonization was carried out with serious omissions, as a result of which the adoption of the new law did not make the process fairer. In particular, the electronic platform armeps.am, which is designed to provide equal competitive conditions for all participants of the process due to its publicity and accessibility, in fact does not work in full force, since it does not conduct periodic independent audit of information security, because the human factor nobody canceled it.  The Institute of Disclosure of Real Business Owners, according to experts, is also not able to carry out its mission - to identify the affiliation of the company with a government official or a member of the evaluation commission, if there are no clear mechanisms for verifying the information specified in the application of the company participating in the tender. "It turns out that you have to trust the participant's honest word, since, as a rule, he fills in the full name of the executive director or the main shareholder, but there are no mechanisms, as a result of lack of political will," Varujan Oktanian said. In addition, he does not see the availability of adequate resources from law enforcement agencies, the Commission on Ethics of Senior Officials (which from April will be transformed into the Anti-Corruption Commission), which is entrusted with the status of this issue.

Experts also question the Council's mandate to appeal against procurement. Despite the fact that it is declared as an independent and impartial body, the Ministry of Finance is responsible for ensuring its functioning and the Council itself works as a ministry building. In addition, there are shortcomings associated with the lack of organizational and legal status of the Council. "The biggest gap between the former and current legislation in the sphere of procurement is the absence of an institution of responsibility for violation of the legislation by the participants in the process." Under such conditions, however perfect the procurement legislation, it will be violated, "concluded economist Arsen Hambardzumyan.

READ ALL COMMENTS

Արսեն Համբարձումյան
Հայերենից ռուսերեն սխալ թարգմանելուց հետո գոնե հայերեն տարբերակում հարցերի և պատասխանների բնօրինակը դրեք, ոչ թե նորից սխալ ռուսերենից հայերեն թարգմանեք։ Իմ տված բոլոր պատասխանները աղավաղվել են և ներկայացվել են անիմաստ մտքեր։

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
Initial public offering of Team Telecom Armenia startedInitial public offering of Team Telecom Armenia started
UNECE Secretary: Armenia has high potential in high technologies and  innovationsUNECE Secretary: Armenia has high potential in high technologies and  innovations
To attract investors to industrial sector  of Armenia, it is necessary to show that country has sufficient  capacities, only  large-capacity unit can cope with this taskTo attract investors to industrial sector  of Armenia, it is necessary to show that country has sufficient  capacities, only  large-capacity unit can cope with this task
Interdepartmental working group to be established in Armenia to  discuss construction on new nuclear unit issues Interdepartmental working group to be established in Armenia to  discuss construction on new nuclear unit issues 
Governor of Gegharkunik: Sotk Gold Mine has ceased operations Governor of Gegharkunik: Sotk Gold Mine has ceased operations 
Metallurgical works to be constructed in Yeraskh to produce ferrous  metal, pipes, fittingsMetallurgical works to be constructed in Yeraskh to produce ferrous  metal, pipes, fittings
Ozon to enter Armenia`s market this autumnOzon to enter Armenia`s market this autumn
Armenia`s government discusses relaunch of Amulsar project Armenia`s government discusses relaunch of Amulsar project 
Konstantin Vladimirovich Tserazov: “In September, we expect a systematic recovery of indices”Konstantin Vladimirovich Tserazov: “In September, we expect a systematic recovery of indices”
Konstantin Tserazov: “The Russian stock market has enough reasons for optimism”Konstantin Tserazov: “The Russian stock market has enough reasons for optimism”
FLYONE ARMENIA airline sets itself the task of transferring 1  million passengers in 2023FLYONE ARMENIA airline sets itself the task of transferring 1  million passengers in 2023
Armenian expert on risks of further domestic debt growth Armenian expert on risks of further domestic debt growth 
Team Telecom Armenia is undertaking its initial public offering (IPO) Team Telecom Armenia is undertaking its initial public offering (IPO) 
Groundbreaking ceremony of new Meghri checkpoint took place todayGroundbreaking ceremony of new Meghri checkpoint took place today
By end of 2023, Armenia to register 2nd largest economic growth and  lowest inflation rate among EAEU countries. But risks still remain -  EDBBy end of 2023, Armenia to register 2nd largest economic growth and  lowest inflation rate among EAEU countries. But risks still remain -  EDB
Vahan Kerobyan: Armenia may become an operator in Iranian port of  ChabaharVahan Kerobyan: Armenia may become an operator in Iranian port of  Chabahar
Tax collections overfulfilled by almost 20% - State Revenue Committee  of ArmeniaTax collections overfulfilled by almost 20% - State Revenue Committee  of Armenia
Money transfers actively flowing to Armenia from Russia are no less  actively flowing  to U.S.Money transfers actively flowing to Armenia from Russia are no less  actively flowing  to U.S.
Armenia`s economy minister meets with SME Cooperation Association  repsArmenia`s economy minister meets with SME Cooperation Association  reps
Converse Bank to present Converse Leasing product at Leasing Expo  2023 exhibition Converse Bank to present Converse Leasing product at Leasing Expo  2023 exhibition 
IDBank`s Visa Business Platinum card now with more profitable termsIDBank`s Visa Business Platinum card now with more profitable terms
Armenia, Georgia discuss joint investment projectsArmenia, Georgia discuss joint investment projects
Armswissbank issues 3 bonds from 1st of juneArmswissbank issues 3 bonds from 1st of june
Ministry of Territorial Administration and Infrastructures believes  that regular flights at Kapan airport to be launched this yearMinistry of Territorial Administration and Infrastructures believes  that regular flights at Kapan airport to be launched this year
FLYONE ARMENIA launches  Yerevan-Tehran-Yerevan direct flightsFLYONE ARMENIA launches  Yerevan-Tehran-Yerevan direct flights
Decline in sales volumes in duty-free stores forced government to  ease tight restrictions on cash transactionsDecline in sales volumes in duty-free stores forced government to  ease tight restrictions on cash transactions
Vahan Kerobyan: feasibility study of Dry Port project is being  carried out by Dutch company; results to be ready in a few monthsVahan Kerobyan: feasibility study of Dry Port project is being  carried out by Dutch company; results to be ready in a few months
PSRC: there are opportunities in Armenia for construction of solar  power plants with a total installed capacity of up to 1 thousand  megawatts, but...PSRC: there are opportunities in Armenia for construction of solar  power plants with a total installed capacity of up to 1 thousand  megawatts, but...
Minister: domestic and international tourism indicators equalized in  ArmeniaMinister: domestic and international tourism indicators equalized in  Armenia
Pashinyan: Since July 1, 2023, RA citizens` pensions to be increased  once againPashinyan: Since July 1, 2023, RA citizens` pensions to be increased  once again
Growth of budget revenues conditioned by three main factors: economic  growth indicators, shadow reduction, implemented reforms - PashinyanGrowth of budget revenues conditioned by three main factors: economic  growth indicators, shadow reduction, implemented reforms - Pashinyan
AraratBank underwrites FINCA UCO bondsAraratBank underwrites FINCA UCO bonds
Team NGN`s 25Gbps network is already available to 150,000 households  in ArmeniaTeam NGN`s 25Gbps network is already available to 150,000 households  in Armenia
Pashinyan: Armenia considers it important to form collective food  security system in EAEUPashinyan: Armenia considers it important to form collective food  security system in EAEU
Trade, services and construction continue to be main drivers of  double-digit growth in economic activity in ArmeniaTrade, services and construction continue to be main drivers of  double-digit growth in economic activity in Armenia
Armenian investment crowdfunding platform ARFI and ANIF to be  presented at Orion 2023 Summit in New YorkArmenian investment crowdfunding platform ARFI and ANIF to be  presented at Orion 2023 Summit in New York
Transavia Airlines to start Marseille-Yerevan-Marseille operating  flightsTransavia Airlines to start Marseille-Yerevan-Marseille operating  flights
Georgia refutes information about launch of shipment to NovorossiyskGeorgia refutes information about launch of shipment to Novorossiysk
Batumi-Novorossiysk ferry service put into operation Batumi-Novorossiysk ferry service put into operation 
Plant producing aluminum radiators to be put into operation in  ArmeniaPlant producing aluminum radiators to be put into operation in  Armenia
Vahan Kerobyan on Vahan Kerobyan on "impressive" indicators of FDI in Armenian economy
Yerevan brandy company could stop exports to RussiaYerevan brandy company could stop exports to Russia
Kaps reservoir construction project resumed in Armenia Kaps reservoir construction project resumed in Armenia 
CMTPL E-polices sales stalled pending more visible discounts as part  of tariff liberalization CMTPL E-polices sales stalled pending more visible discounts as part  of tariff liberalization 
ANIF to invest EUR 3.9mln in Universal Closures company ANIF to invest EUR 3.9mln in Universal Closures company 
Germany to assist Armenia in strengthening local government systemGermany to assist Armenia in strengthening local government system
Fix Price announces entry into Armenia`s marketFix Price announces entry into Armenia`s market
Presentation of ROBBO company held in Armenia Presentation of ROBBO company held in Armenia 
EBRD improves its GDP growth forecast for Armenia EBRD improves its GDP growth forecast for Armenia 
FLYONE ARMENIA started operating flights on the route Yerevan-Larnaca-YerevanFLYONE ARMENIA started operating flights on the route Yerevan-Larnaca-Yerevan
Armenian Diaspora of United States is ready to invest in  technological development of ArmeniaArmenian Diaspora of United States is ready to invest in  technological development of Armenia
CBA Forecast: Inflation in Armenia to reach target level of 4% from  H2 2023CBA Forecast: Inflation in Armenia to reach target level of 4% from  H2 2023
Foreigners` transactions on buying and selling property  reduced in  ArmeniaForeigners` transactions on buying and selling property  reduced in  Armenia
In Yerevan, real estate market activity is declining, but prices  continue to riseIn Yerevan, real estate market activity is declining, but prices  continue to rise
RA citizens` perception of EU has changed dramatically. Pashinyan The  reputation of the European Union has significantly improved after the  Union decided to send an observation mission to Armenia RA citizens` perception of EU has changed dramatically. Pashinyan The  reputation of the European Union has significantly improved after the  Union decided to send an observation mission to Armenia 
German investments for the sake of Armenia`s sustainable developmentGerman investments for the sake of Armenia`s sustainable development
Bright future for solar energy in Armenia - Expert on measures to  ensure sustainable development and true independence of  energy  sectorBright future for solar energy in Armenia - Expert on measures to  ensure sustainable development and true independence of  energy  sector
EDB discusses and implements number of energy projects in Armenia -  Head of BankEDB discusses and implements number of energy projects in Armenia -  Head of Bank
EDB is ready to support Amulsar mine development project - PodguzovEDB is ready to support Amulsar mine development project - Podguzov
Armenian-Czech business forum held in Prague Armenian-Czech business forum held in Prague 
Read more


Exchange rates
07.06.2023
RUB4.75-0.02
USD386.75-0.29
EUR414.330.20
GBP481.500.95
CAD288.960.60
JPY27.75-0.01
CNY54.32-0.14
CHF427.020.44