Friday, August 31 2018 17:39
Alina Hovhannisyan

“Neither old nor new grounds to stop activity of the largest investor’s activities: just a smear campaign”

“Neither old nor new grounds to stop activity of the largest investor’s activities: just a smear campaign”

ArmInfoIn an interview with ArmInfo the lawyer of the Lydian Armenia Company, Armen Melkumyan, to present the situation.

 

- Mr. Melkumyan, tensions are running high over Amulsar Project. What is new about the clashes that happened a few days ago?

 

- Company filed a lawsuit and will follow up to ensure that the culprits of the incident are held responsible. Company’s employees arrived at their workplace relying on the Environmnetal  Inspection Department Resolution and Recommendations that was submitted on Friday, August 24, and contained nothing obligating them to abstain from work (such wording appeared 3 days later). Moreover, the Resolution implied that certain works need to be carried out at site. Taking into consideration the Resolution, company employees went to their workplace. But they never managed to get to the mine. Clashes were instigated and there was an impression that the individuals who illegally blocked the roads, were well-prepared for the clashes they instigated, and which took place in front of high-ranking Police officers. Some of these people who were armed and drunk, attacked the Company’s employees, threw rocks and bottles on them. I must say, most of the people there do not even know what they are “fighting” for. They have joined this group with an unknown source of funding. There is a good chance that this is provocation against the largest investor. In any event, it is unclear what are the financial sources that feed these activities against the Amulsar project. The Law enforcement bodies need to find out what are the sources of financing of these activities aimed at disrupting the Company’s work and what are the real motives and goals of this.  Now these groups have announced crowdfunding. I want to ask, how did they finance these activities for so long before they announced “crowdfunding”?

 

- You are speaking about the best standards, but the Inspection Department suggested the Government to perform a new expertise and stop Lydian’s activities within that period.

 

- It is worth noting that the Environmental Inspection Department’s Report and the relevant Resolution does not support any need for this suggestion. No deviations from the design documentation were detected related to issues like risks of air pollution, water, management of acid rock drainage. It needs to be noted that the Head of the Inspection Artur Grigoryan, before he was appointed as the Head of the Inspection, was notorious for his fight against the Project, including dissemination of unfounded, false accusations of some activists. There is a clear conflict of interest issue and he could not, obviously, be objective. I believe that the Inspection had aimed at attacking the Project at any cost. It is clear, that they failed to find any deviations from the design, they used “new ecological factors” to declare EIA expertise to be no longer in force.  These “new ecological factors” refer to a Red-listed butterfly and a plant species. Lydian has responded to that assumption and will give its legal response. Inspection Department Head Artur Grigoryan was determined to halt the Company’s activity upfront. How could they authorize a person who had repeatedly come out with biased statements on the Project to lead an impartial inspection? In fact, he uses his authority to attack the Project. Nevertheless, despite his big desire to do it, his arguments have the weight of that butterfly.  

 

- Do you mean that the new factors are not serious enough to stop the Project?

 

- First, these “new factors” are not by any means new. Acantholimon caryophyllaceum Boiss plant species and Apollo butterfly (Parnassius apollo) were addressed in Lydian studies. Detailed studies ruled out any adverse impact on these species, as they are not present in the Project immediate impact area. I am speaking about scientifically substantiated conclusions, whereas what the Resolution contains are just assumptions. It is important to note that even the expert that has come up with the argument in the report, does not state that it is exactly Acantholimon caryophyllaceum Boiss plant and only suggests that it “may be” that species. Thus it appears that while the Inspection didn’t find any deviation from design documentation in Company’s activities, they have issued a document against the Company based on assumptions that are not substantiated by science. The Inspection body has relied on an amateurish resolution that impacts a Company that has invested almost half a billion USD and made huge investments into the development of the surrounding communities.

 

- Inspection Department detected apparent illegal extraction of rock mass. A criminal case was initiated against the Company. What do you think about it?  

 

- The Inspection Department failed to provide any proofs indicating that Company extracted anything from borrow pits. During inspections, they tried to prove that clay was extracted from the borrow pits, but even their expert did not confirm that.  Furthermore, under the law, illegal mining is the removal of mineral resources from the site and recovery of valuable elements. There was no proof presented for this claim. In the criminal case, they mention “an apparent” violation. Actually, this is a “violation” “apparent” for Artur Grigoryan.  From legal point of view, such vulnerable claims cause a serious damage to the reputation of that government department. Moreover, this behavior of the Inspection Body contains other risks. That is: will other investors come to Armenia while they see this unserious attitude towards business?





POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
Number of plastic cards up as capital relocated to Armenia Number of plastic cards up as capital relocated to Armenia 
AMD 4,248,945 to AMD 4,248,945 to "QaylTech": The August beneficiary of "The Power of One Dram" is "The Rehabilitation City of Heroes" - psychological rehabilitation center
Airlines, hotels, banks, rental and leasing sectors registered  significant increase in service volumes in ArmeniaAirlines, hotels, banks, rental and leasing sectors registered  significant increase in service volumes in Armenia
Cargo traffic down, passenger traffic up in Armenia in first half,  2022Cargo traffic down, passenger traffic up in Armenia in first half,  2022
Growth of trade sector was facilitated by increase in activity in  wholesale and car trade marketsGrowth of trade sector was facilitated by increase in activity in  wholesale and car trade markets
4.5% increase in proceeds of Armenia`s communication sector in first  half 20224.5% increase in proceeds of Armenia`s communication sector in first  half 2022
188,856 tourists visit Armenia this July188,856 tourists visit Armenia this July
Accelerated growth of Armenian industrial sector was driven by  processing industryAccelerated growth of Armenian industrial sector was driven by  processing industry
Veolia Djur proposes to raise water tariff in ArmeniaVeolia Djur proposes to raise water tariff in Armenia
State Revenue Committee of Armenia starts active administration in  pursuance of law State Revenue Committee of Armenia starts active administration in  pursuance of law " On Non-Cash Transactions"
Armenia`s premier calls for revising economic programmes Armenia`s premier calls for revising economic programmes 
EDB to allocate $25 million to implement Armenia`s largest livestock  programEDB to allocate $25 million to implement Armenia`s largest livestock  program
Double-digit growth in economic activity in Armenia is accompanied by  surge in imports and exportsDouble-digit growth in economic activity in Armenia is accompanied by  surge in imports and exports
Armenian business forum to be held in Yerevan for second timeArmenian business forum to be held in Yerevan for second time
Production of aluminum foil in Armeniaincreased by 8% in June 2022Production of aluminum foil in Armeniaincreased by 8% in June 2022
Metallurgy industry of Armenia sums up H1 2022 with a 7% declineMetallurgy industry of Armenia sums up H1 2022 with a 7% decline
EDB: Armenia ranks first among member countries with small economies  in current investment portfolio of EDB EDB: Armenia ranks first among member countries with small economies  in current investment portfolio of EDB 
EADB to allocate $37mln for construction of 11 solar power stationsEADB to allocate $37mln for construction of 11 solar power stations
Apartments in Yerevan rose in price by 5.4% in Q2, with increase in  transactions for their purchase and sale by 30.8%Apartments in Yerevan rose in price by 5.4% in Q2, with increase in  transactions for their purchase and sale by 30.8%
 Further rise in food prices in Armenia  Further rise in food prices in Armenia 
Loan payoff with another bank via AppLoan payoff with another bank via App
Deputy Minister: 12 more lanes added to 13 existing lanes of Upper  Lars checkpointDeputy Minister: 12 more lanes added to 13 existing lanes of Upper  Lars checkpoint
Ferry communication to be launched this month - minister Ferry communication to be launched this month - minister 
Armenia is among the TOP-5 destinations for Russian tourists this  autumArmenia is among the TOP-5 destinations for Russian tourists this  autum
Austria to invest in Armenia`s SyunikAustria to invest in Armenia`s Syunik
Gyumri Breeding Station reports three-fold growth in barley output Gyumri Breeding Station reports three-fold growth in barley output 
CBA: In February-June 2022, demand deposits of non-residents  increased significantly in Armenian banksCBA: In February-June 2022, demand deposits of non-residents  increased significantly in Armenian banks
CBA: High demand leads to the expansion of the inflationary  environment and maintenance of high inflation expectations, but dram  appreciation partially neutralizes the price increaseCBA: High demand leads to the expansion of the inflationary  environment and maintenance of high inflation expectations, but dram  appreciation partially neutralizes the price increase
Minister: The share of the mining industry in the total volume of  Armenia`s exports has decreasedMinister: The share of the mining industry in the total volume of  Armenia`s exports has decreased
Statistical data, real situation in agricultural sector different -  minister Statistical data, real situation in agricultural sector different -  minister 
FLYONE ARMENIA launches flights to Domodedovo International AirportFLYONE ARMENIA launches flights to Domodedovo International Airport
Armenia, Iran deepen cooperation in mining industryArmenia, Iran deepen cooperation in mining industry
CBA raises refinancing rate from 9.25% to 9.5% CBA raises refinancing rate from 9.25% to 9.5% 
23.9% rise in petrol prices in Armenia in first half of 2022 23.9% rise in petrol prices in Armenia in first half of 2022 
Armenia meets Russia`s brand demandArmenia meets Russia`s brand demand
Armenia is not ready to open the land border with Turkey: ExpertArmenia is not ready to open the land border with Turkey: Expert
Armenia, Qatar discuss possible areas of bilateral cooperationArmenia, Qatar discuss possible areas of bilateral cooperation
Massive arrival of Russians to Armenia, along with movement of their  capital, ensured 7-multifold increase in net inflow of remittances  from Russia in Q2 2022Massive arrival of Russians to Armenia, along with movement of their  capital, ensured 7-multifold increase in net inflow of remittances  from Russia in Q2 2022
Ardshinbank offers a new type of loan for small and medium enterprises.Ardshinbank offers a new type of loan for small and medium enterprises.
Armenia among priority partners of Austrian Development AgencyArmenia among priority partners of Austrian Development Agency
International reserves of Armenia reaches historical maximum by July  2022International reserves of Armenia reaches historical maximum by July  2022
More funds for government-sponsored medical services More funds for government-sponsored medical services 
South Caucasus Railway delivers production equipment from Yerevan to  KrasnodarSouth Caucasus Railway delivers production equipment from Yerevan to  Krasnodar
4% inflation expected in Armenia in medium-term 4% inflation expected in Armenia in medium-term 
Ameriabank leads in list of largest taxpaying banks in ArmeniaAmeriabank leads in list of largest taxpaying banks in Armenia
Armenia`s communication companies pay 25% less as taxes to budget in  1st half of 2022Armenia`s communication companies pay 25% less as taxes to budget in  1st half of 2022
Over 500 Armenian servicemen to benefit from soft lending programmeOver 500 Armenian servicemen to benefit from soft lending programme
Washington to allocate $120mln to Armenia for democratic development,  economic stabilityWashington to allocate $120mln to Armenia for democratic development,  economic stability
17.1% increase in food prices significantly affected low-income  citizens of Armenia - study17.1% increase in food prices significantly affected low-income  citizens of Armenia - study
Armenia, Ethiopia consider development of cooperation in e-governance  and technology educationArmenia, Ethiopia consider development of cooperation in e-governance  and technology education
Armenian assets of GeoProMining Group of Compaines significantly  increase payments to state budgetArmenian assets of GeoProMining Group of Compaines significantly  increase payments to state budget
Vardan Aramyan pointed to risks for Armenia`s GDP and loss of  potential of Russian economy amid IMF`s Vardan Aramyan pointed to risks for Armenia`s GDP and loss of  potential of Russian economy amid IMF`s "Gloomy and More Uncertain"  forecast
Armenia`s vice-premier hosts AMD company vice-presidents Armenia`s vice-premier hosts AMD company vice-presidents 
MFA: Sanctions against Russia have their negative direct or indirect  impact on Armenia`s economic development MFA: Sanctions against Russia have their negative direct or indirect  impact on Armenia`s economic development 
Mirzoyan, Lipavsky note need to fully realize potential of trade and  economic bilateral relationsMirzoyan, Lipavsky note need to fully realize potential of trade and  economic bilateral relations
Zangezur Copper-Molybdenum Combine topped list of taxpayers in  Armenia in H1 2022Zangezur Copper-Molybdenum Combine topped list of taxpayers in  Armenia in H1 2022
Converse Bank completes distribution of bonds ahead of scheduleConverse Bank completes distribution of bonds ahead of schedule
Armenia implements intellectual property development strategyArmenia implements intellectual property development strategy
Iran successfully expands trade with Armenia: Iran TPO headIran successfully expands trade with Armenia: Iran TPO head
Converse Bank offers new loans to SME’sConverse Bank offers new loans to SME’s
Read more


Exchange rates
15.08.2022
RUB6.60-0.06
USD406.190.28
EUR414.31-3.25
GBP490.96-1.29
CAD314.90-2.81
JPY30.460.08
CNY60.260.05
CHF429.56-0.89