Monday, April 8 2019 15:13
Naira Badalian

Vardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDP

Vardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDP

ArmInfo. The restrictions imposed in 2018 related to the legislative regulation of the ratio of public debt to GDP were not an end in themselves and the revision of these parameters is fraught with consequences. Former Minister of Finance of Armenia Vardan Aramyan expressed this opinion in an exclusive interview with ArmInfo.

Earlier, on March 19, at a large press conference, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan stated that in the coming days, the Armenian government together with the Central Bank and the expert community will discuss a possible revision of the acceptable threshold of state debt to GDP. The head of the Armenian government reminded that during his last visit to Brussels it became obvious that the European Union was ready to finance the implementation of development programs in Armenia. According to him, in order to take part in the implementation of the planned programs, Armenia should think about attracting additional resources from abroad. But here, as Pashinyan pointed out, there is a sensitive problem related to the legislative limitation of the ratio of public debt to GDP.

Meanwhile, according to Vardan Aramyan, proposed by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in 2017 the Ministry of Finance of Armenia three threshold levels of public debt - 40%, 50% and 60% for the medium and long term (then Vardan Aramyan headed the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Armenia, Ed. note) Was called upon to become guidelines for the entire debt policy of the Republic

As the expert explains, the establishment of permissible thresholds for public debt has two main objectives:  first, a very high threshold of public debt can lead to crowding out expenses from developing countries for which "debt costs more" and if they exceed 60% threshold, expenses start to grow faster than income. This was the case with Turkey when, after 2000, it began to experience crises precisely in connection with the problems of public debt. Therefore, in many developing countries, the upper permissible threshold of public debt to GDP is set at exactly 60%, and only in very few - at 70%. For Armenia, according to the recommendations of international experts, the "comfort zone" was limited to 60%.

In addition, it is necessary to remember that the state is going to increase the level of public debt in order to make capital expenditures in the long term. They should stimulate the growth of the economies of developing countries with less developed infrastructure.

Meanwhile, according to the data of the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Armenia, in 2018 there was a relatively low rate of fulfillment of foreign credit programs - by 50-60%. These are programs for the development of road and water management, as well as projects in the energy sector, in particular, under the program for extending the service life of the Armenian NPP. In the meantime, as international experience says, it is the economies of countries with developed infrastructure that have the potential to grow, and nothing else. "But if a country does not have its own funds for investments in infrastructure projects, it should attract them from outside. In this case, it's not the increase in debt that is dangerous, but for what purposes the raised funds will go," Aramyan stressed.

In order to stick to the idea and not let "go astray," the Armenian government in 2017 initiated a change in fiscal rules. Having consulted with international experts, and on the basis of concrete logic, Armenia determined the thresholds of public debt that are acceptable for themselves. So, in case of exceeding the 40% threshold of the state debt, capital expenditures should exceed the state budget deficit. At the same time, the republic undertakes to return to a decrease in the state debt. Having exceeded the 50% threshold of the norm, requirements are tightened and, in addition to the previous requirement, restrictions are imposed on current expenses and the golden rule of debt is in place, which provides for the possibility of financing through borrowing only capital expenditures. Approaches are even more tightened after the state debt exceeds 60% of GDP and current expenditures are tied to domestic revenues. At the same time, the state undertakes to return to reducing the level of public debt, in order to form a reliable "airbag".  "Otherwise, not only is the country's ability to resist external shocks, but the number of people willing to issue cheap loans is narrowing. In this context, I urge the authorities to be extremely careful in revising the allowable threshold of public debt," the ex-minister said.

Vardan Aramyan does not agree with the thesis that any debt can generate economic growth. And the mistake is that according to the expert, speaking of the state debt, financial authorities concentrate exclusively on state budget flows, not taking into account such a macroeconomic indicator as national wealth, which includes state-owned enterprises, natural resources and the cost of infrastructures.

For example, according to Aramyan, as an integral part of the national wealth of state savings, unused copper resources must also be registered and taken into account when planning the flow of state treasury. In addition, without macroeconomic stability, it is worth forgetting about investments and economic growth.  At the same time, the expert emphasizes, ensuring macroeconomic stability does not guarantee high economic growth, but it is still the main condition for economic growth.

In 2017, initiating the process of revising the country's fiscal and budgetary rules, reminds Aramyan, the government refrained from changing the upper threshold for the national debt, including understanding that this may adversely affect investor psychology. "It would be unwise if the government today goes to revise the upper threshold of the national debt," said the former head of the Ministry of Finance. It is more correct to adhere to the existing rules, and then, if the public debt threshold is exceeded by 60%, the power to appeal to the public and the investor will lead to objective reasons for exceeding the threshold, while setting out specific dates for returning to the previous level. The last condition, as pointed out by the former head of the Ministry of Finance, may not be so crucial for the population of the country, but is of fundamental importance for the investor in the framework of ensuring macroeconomic stability in the republic. <"The idea of the fix> is as follows - to manage the state debt in such a way as to always maintain the ability to withstand external shocks," concluded Vardan Aramyan.

To recall, in 2018, Armenia revised the country's fiscal rules, setting a permissible threshold for public debt in the amount of 40, 50 and 60% of GDP. At the same time, it established that in case of force majeure situations such as natural disasters, wars, the government will be allowed to exceed this threshold. As noted then in the Ministry of Finance, in the future, new fiscal rules will tie the hands of those leaders who, within the framework of election programs, decide to increase pensions and wages. It was noted that the law acts as a kind of restraining mechanism and a yellow traffic light signal, "in order to have time to slow down and will not appear in the abyss."


News
IMF sharply improved its forecast for GDP growth in Armenia for 2021 to 6.5%, but warns: IMF sharply improved its forecast for GDP growth in Armenia for 2021 to 6.5%, but warns: "Downside risks remain elevated" 
Economy Minister considers Central Bank`s updated economic forecasts  as pessimisticEconomy Minister considers Central Bank`s updated economic forecasts  as pessimistic
Armenian government to allocate about 357.5 million drams to complete  15 subvention programsArmenian government to allocate about 357.5 million drams to complete  15 subvention programs
Economy Minister on the situation with Iranian trucks: We have a  Economy Minister on the situation with Iranian trucks: We have a  "Plan B"
 Armenian accountants and auditors can grow professionally with help  of British Association of Chartered Certified Accountants Armenian accountants and auditors can grow professionally with help  of British Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
Armenian government approves the ratification of the Agreement of the  CIS countries in the fight against IT crimesArmenian government approves the ratification of the Agreement of the  CIS countries in the fight against IT crimes
Armenia and Singapore exclude double taxationArmenia and Singapore exclude double taxation
Government of Armenia ratified the agreement between the governments  of the Republic of Armenia and the Republic of Malta on the avoidance  of double taxationGovernment of Armenia ratified the agreement between the governments  of the Republic of Armenia and the Republic of Malta on the avoidance  of double taxation
The leadership of SRC of Armenia at a meeting with the head of the  FCS of the Russian Federation noted the special importance of  enhancing contactsThe leadership of SRC of Armenia at a meeting with the head of the  FCS of the Russian Federation noted the special importance of  enhancing contacts
American company Wabtec shows interest in the Armenian market American company Wabtec shows interest in the Armenian market 
Deputy Prime Minister on a possible increase in gas prices: Gazprom  insists that the amount of profit stipulated in the 2013 agreement  does not satisfy themDeputy Prime Minister on a possible increase in gas prices: Gazprom  insists that the amount of profit stipulated in the 2013 agreement  does not satisfy them
Drip irrigation. 5 questions and answers with Converse BankDrip irrigation. 5 questions and answers with Converse Bank
World Bank`s updated Groundswell report warns: Climate change could  force 216 million people to migrate within their own countries by  2050World Bank`s updated Groundswell report warns: Climate change could  force 216 million people to migrate within their own countries by  2050
Expert: The unprecedented rise in gas prices in Europe and EAEU  membership open new opportunities for ArmeniaExpert: The unprecedented rise in gas prices in Europe and EAEU  membership open new opportunities for Armenia
Central Bank of Armenia: In Jan-July 2021, the net inflow of  transfers from individuals increased by 78.5% per annumCentral Bank of Armenia: In Jan-July 2021, the net inflow of  transfers from individuals increased by 78.5% per annum
Efforts are underway to enhance seismic safety at Armenian NPPEfforts are underway to enhance seismic safety at Armenian NPP
EEC Forecast: In 2022, the negative foreign trade balance in the EAEU  will be reduced from $ 5.8 billion to $ 2.5 billion EEC Forecast: In 2022, the negative foreign trade balance in the EAEU  will be reduced from $ 5.8 billion to $ 2.5 billion 
Central Bank of Armenia: Consistent tightening of monetary conditions  has a sufficient impact on the regulation of progressive consumer  demand and on curbing of  inflationCentral Bank of Armenia: Consistent tightening of monetary conditions  has a sufficient impact on the regulation of progressive consumer  demand and on curbing of  inflation
Central Bank upgrades Armenia`s economic growth forecast for 2021 to  5.6%Central Bank upgrades Armenia`s economic growth forecast for 2021 to  5.6%
Central Bank Governor: Inflation in Armenia is more supply-drivenCentral Bank Governor: Inflation in Armenia is more supply-driven
Central Bank: Transfers from USA to Armenia are growing rapidlyCentral Bank: Transfers from USA to Armenia are growing rapidly
Armenia and Ukraine launched the improvement of trade and economic  relationsArmenia and Ukraine launched the improvement of trade and economic  relations
Official and real y-o-y inflation continues to accelerate in ArmeniaOfficial and real y-o-y inflation continues to accelerate in Armenia
Central Bank of Armenia once again raised the refinancing rate - from  7% to 7.25%Central Bank of Armenia once again raised the refinancing rate - from  7% to 7.25%
About 2 billion drams to be allocated for the installation of  photovoltaic stations in seven regions of ArmeniaAbout 2 billion drams to be allocated for the installation of  photovoltaic stations in seven regions of Armenia
"Veolia Djur" proposes to increase water tariff by 43.7 drams
Mher Grigoryan: Trade and economic relations between Armenia and  Ukraine have great potential for developmentMher Grigoryan: Trade and economic relations between Armenia and  Ukraine have great potential for development
"Become a shareholder": ACBA Bank issued its first 500.000 shares  with a total volume of 7.5 billion drams
IDBank as a sponsor of the charity concert IDBank as a sponsor of the charity concert "Armenian Rock for Children with Cancer"
As of September 10, 2021, tax collection exceeded indicators of  pre-crisis 2019 by 4.9% in ArmeniaAs of September 10, 2021, tax collection exceeded indicators of  pre-crisis 2019 by 4.9% in Armenia
The collector coin dedicated to the 30th anniversary of the Republic  of Armenia has been issued by Central BankThe collector coin dedicated to the 30th anniversary of the Republic  of Armenia has been issued by Central Bank
Minister of Finance of Armenia and Ambassador of India discussed  possible directions for development of cooperationMinister of Finance of Armenia and Ambassador of India discussed  possible directions for development of cooperation
 Construction of Construction of "Friendship Bridge" on Armenian-Georgian border is in  full swing
Armenia reduced exports of molybdenum, zinc and copper concentratesArmenia reduced exports of molybdenum, zinc and copper concentrates
Armenia increased export of all alcoholic beverages produced in  countryArmenia increased export of all alcoholic beverages produced in  country
Armenia significantly increased volume of exports and imports of  fruit and berry cropsArmenia significantly increased volume of exports and imports of  fruit and berry crops
Armenia in H1 2021 increased grape exports by 66.7% Armenia in H1 2021 increased grape exports by 66.7% 
Regular meeting of Armenian-German intergovernmental commission took  place in BerlinRegular meeting of Armenian-German intergovernmental commission took  place in Berlin
Exclusive opportunity for VISA Signature cardholders of Converse BankExclusive opportunity for VISA Signature cardholders of Converse Bank
Armenia significantly reduced sugar importsArmenia significantly reduced sugar imports
Imports of oil products to Armenia grew by 3.7% in the first half of  2021Imports of oil products to Armenia grew by 3.7% in the first half of  2021
Armenia continues to reduce imports and exports of passenger carsArmenia continues to reduce imports and exports of passenger cars
Expert: Institutional solutions are needed in the development of  public-private dialogue (PPD)Expert: Institutional solutions are needed in the development of  public-private dialogue (PPD)
Diamond exports from Armenia have increased several-foldDiamond exports from Armenia have increased several-fold
Online processes will replace paperwork and the need to visit customsOnline processes will replace paperwork and the need to visit customs
About 100 thousand residents of 5 regions of Armenia will receive  round-the-clock water supplyAbout 100 thousand residents of 5 regions of Armenia will receive  round-the-clock water supply
Public-private dialogue is not going well in ArmeniaPublic-private dialogue is not going well in Armenia
YOY inflation in Armenia reaches 8.8% in August 2021YOY inflation in Armenia reaches 8.8% in August 2021
Armenia cuts gold exports, increasing importsArmenia cuts gold exports, increasing imports
Exports grow faster than imports in Armenia`s foreign trade with the  EU countries- 41% versus 11%Exports grow faster than imports in Armenia`s foreign trade with the  EU countries- 41% versus 11%
Armenia`s foreign trade turnover with EAEU countries reaches  double-digit growthArmenia`s foreign trade turnover with EAEU countries reaches  double-digit growth
As of the end of August, 488 thousand tourists visited ArmeniaAs of the end of August, 488 thousand tourists visited Armenia
Armenia slightly reduced the export of aluminum foil in H1, 2021Armenia slightly reduced the export of aluminum foil in H1, 2021
"The Power of One Dram" to overcome childhood cancer
A number of Dutch companies are interested in cooperation with  Armenia in IT fieldA number of Dutch companies are interested in cooperation with  Armenia in IT field
One of the successful and long-awaited programs of Ameriabank -One of the successful and long-awaited programs of Ameriabank -"  Generation A 13 "  is launched  
Armenian service sector tries to restore growth ratesArmenian service sector tries to restore growth rates
Nikolay Podguzov: The share of drams in the implementation of  projects on the territory of Armenia will grow Nikolay Podguzov: The share of drams in the implementation of  projects on the territory of Armenia will grow "dramatically"
IDBank prematurely finished the placement of the second tranche of bonds of 2021IDBank prematurely finished the placement of the second tranche of bonds of 2021
Revenue of Armenia`s trade sector increased by 7.5% to $ 3.4 billion  in 7 monthsRevenue of Armenia`s trade sector increased by 7.5% to $ 3.4 billion  in 7 months
Read more


Exchange rates
16.09.2021
RUB6.720.01
USD486.37-0.63
EUR572.46-3.32
GBP672.07-1.26
CAD384.760.39
JPY44.45-0.09
CNY75.610.10
CHF526.43-4.42