Friday, August 23 2019 12:24
Emmanuil Mkrtchyan

IMF: Armenia needs to achieve sustainable inclusive growth

IMF: Armenia needs to achieve sustainable inclusive growth

ArmInfo. Jihad Azour, Director of the Middle East and Central Asia (MCD) Department at the International Monetary Fund (IMF), has recently visited Armenia. He is a well-known Lebanese economist and politician, who served as Lebanon’s Minister of Finance under Fouad Saniora’s government from 2005 to 2008, and author of a number of critical reforms in Lebanon's public administration and taxation system.

 

It is noteworthy that the mission has had meetings with the leadership of the country's economic sectors and discussed a range of issues related to future reforms in the country's socio-economic life, development of inclusive institutions, the fight against corruption, tax transformations, update of the Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP), and preserving macroeconomic stability. Despite his busy schedule, Jihad Azour kindly agreed to answer the questions of journalists.  Below we present the answers of the senior representative of the IMF to the questions of Emmanuil Mkrtchyan, General Director of ArmInfo.

 

- Mr. Azour, in May the IMF approved a three-year Stand-By Arrangement for Armenia amounting to about $ 248.2 million. One-seventh of this amount was made available immediately, and the remaining amount will be made available subject to six semi-annual reviews. Moreover, as was stated, these amounts had not been transferred to the Central Bank’s account, but rather provide assurance, a kind of ‘insurance line’ if Armenia confronts severe shocks at this turbulent time for the global economy and trade. Meanwhile, the program as such provides for the country’s commitments to carry out serious reforms in line with the new government’s ambitious program, which is aimed at drastic transformation of the socio-economic life. Does the IMF have first assessments of the ongoing reform process and in your opinion, what are its strengths and weaknesses?

 

Let me first say a few words about the regional outlook and forecasts. Currently, we are updating our April report (https://finport.am/full_news.php?id=38164&lang=2) on the economic outlook of the CCA region at the IMF, and the update will be issued in October. I would like to note that the Caucasus and Central Asia region, like other regions in the world, is affected by developments in global economy including the challenging global trade situation. And this impact materializes through linkages with major trading partners. In addition to these global trade challenges, economic tensions in the Gulf States can affect the economic situation in the CCA countries. Nevertheless, we believe that during 2019 the economic growth in the region will be stable and in line with our latest forecast produced in April (at 4.1% - Ed.).

 

However, a growth rate of 4-4.5% is not sufficient for sustainably addressing the challenges facing the countries of the region, especially in terms of their inclusive development, job creation and providing the necessary level of social protection for the population. As for Armenia, we reached agreements with the authorities of your country in February aimed at supporting the ambitious structural reform program. According to this program, we will only disburse the funds if necessary, in the event of shocks affecting the country. By providing such an access to these concessional resources, we attempt to promote resilience and sustainable economic development in the country.

 

On the one hand, the IMF is trying to secure future macroeconomic stability, which was also the goal of all previous IMF-supported programs, and on the other, from a macroeconomic perspective, help the country reduce gradually the level of public debt to below 50% of the country's GDP in a growth-friendly manner. At the same time, the program aims at building higher economic resilience to shocks by promoting creation of new institutions of inclusive development and protection of the most vulnerable groups of the population.

 

Structural reforms are, of course, the key pillars of the program. They include the reforms that are planned by the Armenia’s government, namely, to fight corruption and create an effective and strong governance framework enabling higher future economic development, while achieving inclusive growth. Such reforms would also help address the high unemployment, especially among the youth.

 

To this end, the program encompasses the reforms to improve tax administration, reduce the shadow economy and introduce an effective anti-corruption framework. Improvements in property taxation will also enable to have a broad-based and balanced taxation system by including various types of income in the tax framework.

 

Meanwhile, the program aims to expand the fiscal space for the government to have an ability to finance spending, achieve a high level of capital program execution, which will in turn enhance the growth inclusiveness and the direct impact on poverty reduction in the country. To this end, it is necessary to create an effective governance framework that will lead to a significant improvement in business environment and opportunities for fully utilizing public resources while increasing trust between citizens and the state. Using public-private partnership can also become important for effective capital investment. All this, in turn, will create a strong basis for sustainable and inclusive growth supported by increased investment predictability and attractiveness of Armenia.

 

Answering your question about the assessment of program implementation, we plan to conduct the first review in September-October, after which we will be ready to share the findings.

 

- How will the program be reflected in Armenia’s 2020 budget? In your opinion, what should be its main difference from the current year budget? Can we expect a significant increase in capital and social expenditure, which, on the other hand can support the demand in the country amid possible external shocks?

 

As for the capital expenditure, there is also a target in the budget for this year and it would very good if the target was met. In fact, Armenia under-executed capital expenditure in the past too, and before speaking about the expansion of capital expenditure, it would be necessary to reach the full and effective utilization within the already existing expenditure envelope, so that it produces the socio-economic impact. There are many factors hindering full execution, including the public procurement system which needs improvement. In this regard, there are also possibilities of expanding public-private partnership programs.

 

- Do you mean that the country has recently had to limit itself in terms of execution of loan projects of such major international institutional donors as the World Bank (WB), the International Finance Corporation (IFC) and others?

 

Regardless of the source of project funding - whether from purely budget resources or in the framework of loan obligations – at the moment we indisputably have a problem of under-execution of expenditure. Therefore, it is necessary to develop new mechanisms for the effective and correct spending of these funds on time and in full. And as I said, the best way is to ensure that the public procurement procedures are transparent. Expanding the interaction between the state and businesses to solve socially significant problems on mutually beneficial terms within the framework of public-private partnerships can also bring tangible benefits for the development of the economy.

 

- Let's talk about the problem of financial market development. Its stability is not yet in doubt, but its development is one-sided, and unbalanced. The dominant position of the banking sector limits and significantly reduces the diversification of sources of financing the economy. I mean the country's underdeveloped stock market, a very weak insurance sector, and the lack of domestic institutional investors. The level of market transparency and reporting is insufficient, and corporate governance principles do not work in practice. For many years there have been no serious institutional shifts in the country's financial market. It is believed that transferring of the function of a single financial mega-regulator to the Central Bank 15 years ago was a mistake. As a result we have got a disproportionately developing market, where the banking sector dominates significantly and rises alone in the “open field”.

 

Armenia is by far not the only country where the banking sector dominates the financial market. But at present, the picture is gradually changing, and the financial sector seems to be developing. This process is driven by the private pension funds; there are also plans to create other institutional investors, as well as other non-banking institutions. I hope that the process of developing the financial infrastructure will become more intensive to allow a diversification of funding sources over time, which will help to establish a capital market, promote greater transparency and strengthen corporate governance. Increased transparency of economic agents and reforms in tax system will also contribute to financial market development. Importantly, the technology business successfully developing in Armenia creates a demand for non-bank resources including private equity and venture funds. In turn, the reform of tax legislation, particularly regarding the property taxation, as well as the real estate cadastre system will also contribute to this process. However, it should be noted that in so-called “emerging markets” or middle-income countries like Armenia, these processes take time and do not happen as quickly as in developed countries.

 

- There is a concept of “cocoon economy” in economic theory which you are very familiar with as a scholar once engaged in researching integration of developing economies into the world economy. Such a country is characterized by relatively weak ties of integration into the global economy, which, incidentally, has repeatedly saved Armenia from the strong impact of global crises. Can this be considered a temporary benefit of the “safe haven”, which will allow avoiding possible shocks during an economic storm and steadily carrying out the necessary reforms?

 

I do not quite agree with this assessment. It doesn’t matter whether your economy is large or small, the external impact, whether through trade, remittances or capital inflows, would be quite tangible. Instead of counting on weak economic integration, it is important to be prepared for external challenges and strengthen the foundations of the economy. In this regard, it is important to focus on reforming the institutions, markets, and the governance framework to achieve sustainable, long-term and inclusive growth. We understand and agree with these priorities, and we stand ready to assist the government in addressing these challenging issues.

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     


News
Prime Minister: Armenia`s financial market starts the year 2020  aconfidently Prime Minister: Armenia`s financial market starts the year 2020  aconfidently 
Government Decision: The amount of benefits to poor families from 30  thousand will be reduced to 28 thousand dramsGovernment Decision: The amount of benefits to poor families from 30  thousand will be reduced to 28 thousand drams
Ardshinbank placed another large tranche of bonds on international capital market Ardshinbank placed another large tranche of bonds on international capital market 
PM: The state will seize unused agricultural land with their  subsequent transfer to interested partiesPM: The state will seize unused agricultural land with their  subsequent transfer to interested parties
Armenian Armenian "Duster Marianna" company will receive benefits for import  of milk cream from Iran
Forecast: Possible increase in the cost of gas for the Armenian  consumer will not exceed 4-4.5%Forecast: Possible increase in the cost of gas for the Armenian  consumer will not exceed 4-4.5%
Armenian depositors will have the opportunity to receive interest  from the first day of depositArmenian depositors will have the opportunity to receive interest  from the first day of deposit
Vice Prime Minister: Holding Armenia-EU Investment Forum is of great  importance in terms of determining its strategic goalsVice Prime Minister: Holding Armenia-EU Investment Forum is of great  importance in terms of determining its strategic goals
Prime Minister: Subvention programs should be the cornerstone of  territorial development strategiesPrime Minister: Subvention programs should be the cornerstone of  territorial development strategies
VTB Bank (Armenia) offers to issue loans secured by gold on favorable  termsVTB Bank (Armenia) offers to issue loans secured by gold on favorable  terms
Standards of International Capital Market Association (ICMA) to be  applied in ArmeniaStandards of International Capital Market Association (ICMA) to be  applied in Armenia
ISUZU RUS announces the start of sales in the Armenian marketISUZU RUS announces the start of sales in the Armenian market
Armenian Prime Minister does not have a clear position on the project  of introducing Institute of Health InsuranceArmenian Prime Minister does not have a clear position on the project  of introducing Institute of Health Insurance
Armenia Securities Exchange launched a new government bond auction  platformArmenia Securities Exchange launched a new government bond auction  platform
EBRD confirms commitment to continue assistance to ArmeniaEBRD confirms commitment to continue assistance to Armenia
German Siemens and ATOM (Advanced Tomorrow) presidential initiative  can begin fruitful cooperationGerman Siemens and ATOM (Advanced Tomorrow) presidential initiative  can begin fruitful cooperation
Armenian President in Davos held talks with representatives of Qatar  Investment Fund and Mitsubishi Group Japanese companyArmenian President in Davos held talks with representatives of Qatar  Investment Fund and Mitsubishi Group Japanese company
An agreement was signed on the establishment of the TUMO Center in  BerlinAn agreement was signed on the establishment of the TUMO Center in  Berlin
Tatul Manaseryan: Government should start considering stimulating  domestic investmentsTatul Manaseryan: Government should start considering stimulating  domestic investments
Educational courses on the introduction of small and medium  greenhouse farms have startedEducational courses on the introduction of small and medium  greenhouse farms have started
MP: SRC should solve the problem with the deficit of cash registersMP: SRC should solve the problem with the deficit of cash registers
ADB will continue to assist Armenia in developing infrastructuresADB will continue to assist Armenia in developing infrastructures
Expert: At least several ``Nikol Pashinyans`` are needed to organize  the focused work of the Armenian governmentExpert: At least several ``Nikol Pashinyans`` are needed to organize  the focused work of the Armenian government
Economist: Competitiveness continues to be first priority problem in  Armenian economyEconomist: Competitiveness continues to be first priority problem in  Armenian economy
Prospects for building a new smelter discussed in ArmeniaProspects for building a new smelter discussed in Armenia
At a global food forum in Berlin, participating countries adopted a  communique on promoting sustainable agricultural development and food  securityAt a global food forum in Berlin, participating countries adopted a  communique on promoting sustainable agricultural development and food  security
Tax privileges for repatriates expanded in ArmeniaTax privileges for repatriates expanded in Armenia
Armenia intends to improve its performance in World Bank`s Doing  Business ranking by five positionsArmenia intends to improve its performance in World Bank`s Doing  Business ranking by five positions
Armenia is negotiating with Armenia is negotiating with "Gazprom" on developing  mechanisms for fixed gas pricing for a period of 10 years
$ 31.6 million transactions made at currency interbank of Armenia on  January 8-17, 2020$ 31.6 million transactions made at currency interbank of Armenia on  January 8-17, 2020


Exchange rates
23.01.2020
RUB7.730.00
USD478.73-0.17
EUR530.62-0.62
GBP628.432.84
CAD363.72-2.80
JPY43.710.16
CNY69.51-0.04
CHF494.050.90


Experts
RAEX-Europe confirmed Armenia`s ratings at `BB-` with outlook  RAEX-Europe confirmed Armenia`s ratings at `BB-` with outlook  "Positive"
AmRating: A growing low-cost mortgage is AmRating: A growing low-cost mortgage is "spurred on" by a steady  increase in property prices
AmRating: Increasing toxicity of consumer loans will push banks to  not put all their eggs in one basketAmRating: Increasing toxicity of consumer loans will push banks to  not put all their eggs in one basket
Analysts Opinion on Central Bank Report Analysts Opinion on Central Bank Report 
ArmInfo has released its 100th anniversary bank bulletinArmInfo has released its 100th anniversary bank bulletin
Mining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-MiceMining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-Mice
Tigran Khachatryan: Attracting several transnational investors to  Armenia will allow the country to start playing for high stakesTigran Khachatryan: Attracting several transnational investors to  Armenia will allow the country to start playing for high stakes
During the first 5 years, the agricultural insurance market in Armenia will operate at a lossDuring the first 5 years, the agricultural insurance market in Armenia will operate at a loss
Artak Kamalyan: Education is the key to success. Everything else is of secondary importanceArtak Kamalyan: Education is the key to success. Everything else is of secondary importance
Head of PSRC: Whatever the agreement, the domestic tariff is  dependent on the price at the borderHead of PSRC: Whatever the agreement, the domestic tariff is  dependent on the price at the border
IMF: Armenia needs to achieve sustainable inclusive growthIMF: Armenia needs to achieve sustainable inclusive growth
Artur Atoyan: Problems of fish farmers are solved by the communist  method, that is, they are not solved at allArtur Atoyan: Problems of fish farmers are solved by the communist  method, that is, they are not solved at all
HSBC Bank Armenia digitalizes cooperation with retail clients HSBC Bank Armenia digitalizes cooperation with retail clients 
AmRating agency in cooperation with European Rating-Agentur Expert RA  GmbH has issued regular research on Armenia`s banking systemAmRating agency in cooperation with European Rating-Agentur Expert RA  GmbH has issued regular research on Armenia`s banking system
Yulia Ustyugova: Armenia can get access to IMF “insurance line”Yulia Ustyugova: Armenia can get access to IMF “insurance line”
Armand Arton: The question whether citizenship should be granted in  return for investments is rather rhetoricalArmand Arton: The question whether citizenship should be granted in  return for investments is rather rhetorical
Former head of the Ministry of Finance: <Confrontation> with Lydian may cost much to ArmeniaFormer head of the Ministry of Finance: with Lydian may cost much to Armenia
Vardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDPVardan Aramyan: It will be unreasonable if the government goes to revise the allowable national debt ceiling in GDP
HSBC Bank Armenia increases efficiency and focuses on digital servicesHSBC Bank Armenia increases efficiency and focuses on digital services
Bulgarian Minister: The level of Armenian-Bulgarian economic  cooperation is still unsatisfactoryBulgarian Minister: The level of Armenian-Bulgarian economic  cooperation is still unsatisfactory

Search by date

Government Bonds

Issue volume

10 billion

Volume of T-bills for placement

200 million

Volume of submitted competitive applications

200 million

Volume of satisfied bids

200 million

Yield at cut-off price

 5.8314%

Maximum yield

 5.8314%

Мinimum yield

 5.8314%

Weighted average yield

 5.8314%

Number of participants

2

The maturity date of T-bills

03.02.2020

ArmEx

 

СПРОС (Покупка)

USD

Средневзв. Цена

482,00

ПРЕДЛОЖЕНИЕ (Продажа)

  USD

Средневзв. Цена

-

СДЕЛКИ

USD

Цена откр.

482,00

Цена закр.

482,00

Мин. Цена

482,00

Макс. Цена

482,00

Ср/взв. Цена

482,00

-0.16

Кол-во сделок

1

Объем (инвал.)

200 000

0бъем (драм)

96 400 000

Commented
John D & Sosi Balian Foundation will allocate $ 1.65 million for  construction and improvement of new building of Erebuni  Archaeological Museum-ReserveJohn D & Sosi Balian Foundation will allocate $ 1.65 million for  construction and improvement of new building of Erebuni  Archaeological Museum-Reserve
Mining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-MiceMining Industry as a Fanciful Game of Cats-and-Mice
Russian processing company Russian processing company "MultiCarta" discussed cooperation  opportunities with Yerevan Municipality in the transport sector
$ 270 Million to be invested in the construction of the first  skyscraper in Yerevan$ 270 Million to be invested in the construction of the first  skyscraper in Yerevan
The AGBU Women Entrepreneurs Program Launched in Artsakh: FRUITFUL  ARMENIA Foundation is the partnerThe AGBU Women Entrepreneurs Program Launched in Artsakh: FRUITFUL  ARMENIA Foundation is the partner
Forecast: Armenia has good prospects for expanding its presence in  the Polish marketForecast: Armenia has good prospects for expanding its presence in  the Polish market
Armenian government`s delegation headed by Prime Minister will take  part in the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum on June 6-7Armenian government`s delegation headed by Prime Minister will take  part in the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum on June 6-7
Concessionaire of Zvartnots International Airport promises to become  one of the best operators in the worldConcessionaire of Zvartnots International Airport promises to become  one of the best operators in the world
Arthur Javadyan: Central banks are not responsible for economic  growthArthur Javadyan: Central banks are not responsible for economic  growth
Forecast: Electricity exports to the Middle East through Iran are a  key component of Armenia`s geo- economic strategyForecast: Electricity exports to the Middle East through Iran are a  key component of Armenia`s geo- economic strategy
ArmInfo IC: In Armenia,  CMTPL loss ratio increased up to 64.5% in Q1  2019ArmInfo IC: In Armenia,  CMTPL loss ratio increased up to 64.5% in Q1  2019
From January 1, 2020, the cost of customs clearance of cars from  non-EEU countries in Armenia will increase by at least 4-5 fold:  whether the market for used cars is going upFrom January 1, 2020, the cost of customs clearance of cars from  non-EEU countries in Armenia will increase by at least 4-5 fold:  whether the market for used cars is going up
Overdue loans accelerate growth in banking system of ArmeniaOverdue loans accelerate growth in banking system of Armenia
RA Prime Minister: European Union is not ready to finance 100% of  development programs implementation in ArmeniaRA Prime Minister: European Union is not ready to finance 100% of  development programs implementation in Armenia
Converse Bank offers online loans at a low effective interest rateConverse Bank offers online loans at a low effective interest rate
Starting from Jan 1, 2020, a new micro-business taxation system will  be introduced in ArmeniaStarting from Jan 1, 2020, a new micro-business taxation system will  be introduced in Armenia
Renco company will attract additional shareholders and partners to  the project of building a new thermal-power plant in ArmeniaRenco company will attract additional shareholders and partners to  the project of building a new thermal-power plant in Armenia
T.Avinyan: The Government is open for cooperation and encourages  active dialogue and interaction in all areas T.Avinyan: The Government is open for cooperation and encourages  active dialogue and interaction in all areas 
Agreement on construction of a new unit with combined gas cycle  signed in YerevanAgreement on construction of a new unit with combined gas cycle  signed in Yerevan
Veolia Jur: Regulatory charges are false and unfoundedVeolia Jur: Regulatory charges are false and unfounded
Armenian Prime Minister: We are gaining momentum for economic takeoffArmenian Prime Minister: We are gaining momentum for economic takeoff